Smyrna review – raw, shocking violence in epic take on Greek-Turkish conflict

Grigoris Karantinakis’s bustling ensemble drama recreates the buildup to a 1922 massacre in what is now İzmir, even if some characters are just walking Wikipedia entries

This epic historical drama could have been called Once Upon a Time in Asia Minor or Once Upon a Time in Turkey, depending on which side of the Greek-Turkish divide you sit. That thorny geopolitical entanglement is what it attempts to unpick, sometimes too forcefully, in telling the story of the one-time melting pot of Smyrna (now İzmir). It culminates in a shockingly raw depiction of the 1922 massacre and ethnic cleansing of the Greek and Armenian population by Kemal Atatürk’s irregulars after they entered the city.

Filio Baltatzis (Mimi Denissi) is the matriarch of a Greek olive oil family in Smyrna, relaxed in their affluence in the Levantine port even as first world war storm clouds encroach. Greece is neutral but her husband Dimitris (Leonidas Kakouris) thinks it should join the Allies and unseat the Ottomans. His brother Spyros (Krateros Katsoulis) is more practical, not wanting to antagonise the ruling Turks. Dimitris should probably have paid more attention, as there are a fair few Turks among his servants, including Halil (Burak Hakkı), who has taken a shine to Ataturk – then a politically ambitious military figure.

Director Grigoris Karantinakis matches Merchant Ivory in his richly sketched depiction of this bustling hub, heavy on the coffee, baklava and the zither. The ensemble is large, in the film’s attempt to cast a net over the city’s many factions, from the English toffs to whom the Baltatzises hope to marry their daughter off, to the local orthodox bishop. (Slightly improbably, a squad of veteran British faces – Susan Hampshire, Jane Lapotaire, Rupert Graves – put in an appearance.) The tactic is successful to some degree, especially in spotlighting the divided allegiances of their Turkish intimates: Halil warns his employers that the young Turks plan to assassinate Dimitris. But the desire to fully map out this polyglot world has a tendency to reduce many characters to walking Wikipedia entries.

There’s also a faint but unsettling Greek bias here, especially in continued assertions that the ancient Hellenic presence means “Asia Minor” is truly theirs. The intransigence is understandable in the light of the later bloodshed but it’s at odds with the film’s supposed multiculturalism and prevents a more rounded grasp of history (such as reflecting on the irony that Atatürk, responsible for this nationalistic sanitising, was born in Greece). Smyrna catches the intoxication and panic of the moment, but its longer-term perspective – as seen in its overarching recipe-book conceit – is sickly sweet.

• Smyrna is in UK cinemas on 4 December for one night only.

Contributor

Phil Hoad

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Echoes of the Past review – Max von Sydow’s final film is coda to a Nazi atrocity
Kalavryta was a real war crime committed in Greece, but this fictional drama – featuring von Sydow in his last film role – fails to deliver much justice

Peter Bradshaw

15, Feb, 2022 @10:00 AM

Article image
Digger review – family tensions are unearthed in slow-burn Greek drama
A corporate destruction project offers a symbolic backdrop for this poignant drama about a father-son relationship

Phil Hoad

15, Feb, 2021 @12:00 PM

Article image
Atlantis review – strangely upbeat exploration of war-ravaged Ukraine
Valentyn Vasyanovych’s award-winning drama casts deeply likable non-professionals – most with direct experience of the conflict with Russia

Leslie Felperin

03, May, 2021 @11:00 AM

Article image
Kurier review – Polish war hero fights through gritty spy thriller
A Polish agent follows a perilous route from London to Warsaw in this taut and arresting piece of storytelling

Phil Hoad

26, Jun, 2019 @4:00 PM

Article image
Reflection review – a shaken, horrifying outcry for Ukraine – and statement of hope
Ukrainian director Valentyn Vasyanovych’s enigmatic war drama, set in Donbas, is brutal in its depiction of conflict but also elusively redemptive

Phil Hoad

30, May, 2022 @2:00 PM

Article image
Image of Victory review – study of Arab-Israeli conflict from all angles hopes to heal
Avi Nesher’s film set near the Gaza Strip in 1948 empathises with every side – which is a laudable, if idealistic, ambition

Leslie Felperin

16, May, 2022 @12:00 PM

Article image
In the Fog review – Sergei Loznitsa’s meditation on the poisonous shame of collaboration
When a Nazi collaborator is led into the Belarusian forest to be executed, why doesn't he protest? Loznitsa's lacerating film explores the agonies of war and puts European history on trial

Peter Bradshaw

25, Apr, 2013 @2:30 PM

Article image
The Rifleman review – Latvian war epic aims high
This trench-warfare tale is its country’s biggest box-office success, but it is guilty of some bad misfires

Ellen E Jones

24, Jul, 2020 @6:00 AM

Article image
Natural Light review – reprisals and revenge in chilling examination of the toll of war
Documentary director Dénes Nagy explores how conflict erodes loyalty, morality and human consciousness in his award-winning first feature

Peter Bradshaw

09, Nov, 2021 @10:00 AM

Article image
All Quiet on the Western Front review – anti-war nightmare of bloodshed and chaos
Teenage boys quickly find themselves caught up in the ordeal of trench warfare in this German-language adaptation of the first world war novel

Peter Bradshaw

12, Oct, 2022 @8:00 AM