Stars at Noon review – languid tale of sex, lies and intrigue in the Nicaraguan heat

Benny Safdie stands out among a strangely lethargic cast in Claire Denis’ erotic and intimate political drama

A heavy tropical raincloud of sensual languor and political intrigue looms over this interesting if sometimes uncertainly acted movie from director Claire Denis – and incidentally, casting Benny Safdie in a small role is to risk everyone else getting upstaged, and so it proves here.

This film touches on her keynote themes of sexuality and colonialism, in its 21st-century manifestation, though maybe the romantic passion and duplicity don’t come across as strongly as they might have done with leads who had a stronger chemistry.

Denis has co-adapted the 1986 novel by Denis Johnson, originally set in Nicaragua during the Sandinista revolution of the early 80s but here updated to the Covid period, the pandemic evidently fulfilling the “life-during-wartime” background function, although this is necessarily far less dramatic and explicit and Denis substitutes the eerie emptiness of the streets as a kind of military curfew. It is certainly more intimate than a film like The Year of Living Dangerously (1982), often more resembling an erotic hotel-room chamber piece.

Margaret Qualley plays Trish, who has come to the capital, Managua, as a freelance journalist but infuriates her sometime editor back in the US (a nice Zoom cameo for John C Reilly) by being utterly useless and unreliable. She is unable to get any lifestyle/travel articles off the ground and a rash political piece criticising corruption has earned her the loathing of the authorities. Now she is reduced to hanging around luxury hotel bars, selling sex for US dollars. She is also having a sordid affair with a local cop (Nick Romano) in return for her continued press corps privileges and with an ageing government official who has offered help.

Joe Alwyn, right, and Margaret Qualley in Stars at Noon.
Worrying close to Roger Moore … Joe Alwyn, right, and Margaret Qualley in Stars at Noon. Photograph: Courtesy Cannes film festival

Trish meets a mysterious, handsome Englishman in the bar one evening. Daniel (Joe Alwyn) claims to be in the energy business and engages her services for the evening. Trish later sees Daniel in the company of a certain local who has told Daniel he needs his professional help. But Trish – wily and streetsmart in ways that Daniel isn’t – tells Daniel this man is clearly a Costa Rican cop working for a government agency making common cause with the CIA against what Uncle Sam sees as an unhelpful nation state. Soon, this man is after Daniel’s head. Daniel, too, is not what he seems and as their danger increases, Trish and Daniel embark on a passionate affair.

It is reasonably acted, although the cool, enigmatic sophistication required of Alwyn brings him worryingly close to Roger Moore territory. Qualley nicely conveys neediness, alcoholism and self-reproach although her performance, like Alwyn’s, sometimes feels a bit callow. They are outclassed by Safdie as the mysterious US expat who befriends Trisha.

What works better is the ambient mood of torpor, cynicism and bad faith in the insupportable heat – all shrewdly conjured by Denis.

• Stars at Noon screened at the Cannes film festival and is released on 19 June in the UK on digital platforms.

Contributor

Peter Bradshaw

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Close review – a heartbreaking tale of boyhood friendship turned sour
When two 13-year-olds are no longer close, the fallout is unbearably sad, in Lukas Dhont’s anguished second feature

Peter Bradshaw

01, Mar, 2023 @11:40 AM

Article image
The Eight Mountains review – a movie with air in its lungs and love in its heart
A meditation on our capacity for love shapes this sweeping story of two friends, torn apart by family and life’s journeys but bound by something deeper

Peter Bradshaw

10, May, 2023 @9:35 AM

Article image
Cairo Conspiracy (aka Boy from Heaven) review – stirring spy thriller set on an Egyptian campus
Egypt’s religious and secular institutions both breed mistrust in Tarik Saleh’s superbly realised paranoid nightmare

Peter Bradshaw

20, May, 2022 @4:00 PM

Article image
EO review – an innocent donkey leads the way in surreal Bresson-inspired ride
Life is seen through the eyes of a put-upon beast of burden in this beautifully photographed homage to Au Hasard Balthazar by the veteran Polish director Jerzy Skolimowski

Peter Bradshaw

01, Feb, 2023 @4:24 PM

Article image
Aftersun review – beach holiday with Paul Mescal and daughter is a sunny delight
This effortlessly relaxed debut by Charlotte Wells is a subtle and complex investigation of post-divorce parenthood, with a brilliant performance by young Francesca Corio

Peter Bradshaw

17, Nov, 2022 @10:45 AM

Article image
RMN review – sickness beneath the skin as racism breaks out in Romanian village
Latest from Cristian Mungiu is a low-key drama about a multi-ethnic community in Transylvania who turn on a group of Sri Lankan immigrants

Peter Bradshaw

21, Sep, 2023 @12:46 PM

Article image
Tori and Lokita review – clarity of purpose in the Dardennes’ parable of the dispossessed
The new film from double Palme d’Or winners focusses on a pair of young immigrants to Belgium who find themselves working in dangerous situations

Peter Bradshaw

24, May, 2022 @4:58 PM

Article image
Enys Men review – a supremely disquieting study of solitude
Bait director Mark Jenkin delivers another eerie prose-poem of a film, about an isolated woman lost inside her own mind

Peter Bradshaw

20, May, 2022 @2:15 PM

Article image
Corsage review – a cry of anger from the pedestal-prison of an empress
Vicky Krieps puts in a star turn as lonely, patronised Elisabeth of Austria in Marie Kreutzer’s austere drama

Peter Bradshaw

20, Dec, 2022 @11:01 AM

Article image
Triangle of Sadness’s Dolly de Leon: ‘Women my age are more in touch with our sexuality. We know how to flirt’
She’s made a career back home in the Philippines as jobbing actor, but now she’s the breakout star of a Palme d’Or-winning film – and enjoying every minute of her newfound fame

Ryan Gilbey

20, Oct, 2022 @3:00 PM