Emancipation review – Will Smith flees slavery in fierce, sombre thriller

Smith brings movie-star presence to historical figure whose suffering and dignity became an iconic abolitionist image

Whatever his current travails, Will Smith brings a movie-star presence to this brutally violent civil war drama, with a physical stillness and defiantly steady gaze. It is inspired by the true story of “Whipped Peter”, the escaped slave who in 1863, having enlisted at a Union military camp in Baton Rouge, Louisiana, showed his horrendously scarred back to two civilian photographers there, shockingly disfigured with a lattice of raised welts and whip marks. The resulting photograph became an iconic abolitionist image: evidence of the savagery and Peter’s own heroic dignity and calm.

Smith’s Peter is not shown being whipped in this way, but it is clear that, like all the enslaved people, he has been subject to systematic cruelty, a type of racist violence that is not a distinct punitive event, but a continuous fact of life, a condition of existence. The violence is embedded in the language used as the owners have an ugly way of referring to the slaves as “it”. The movie imagines Peter to be married to Dodienne (a fierce performance from Charmaine Bingwa), with whom he speaks French dialect, but is separated from his wife and children when he is bought by another owner and put brutally to work on the south’s railroad and military fortifications. Like most of the film, this chaotic camp is shot in a bleached-out near monochrome, with flashes of flame picked out in colour: a visual approach perhaps borrowed from Schindler’s List.

Peter is electrified by news that Lincoln’s soldiers are freeing slaves in Baton Rouge, across the swamp, and the jittery, trigger-happy white overseers, already unnerved by the enemy’s advance, are terrified that this rumour will make their slaves ungovernable. Peter escapes across the swamp with slave masters in pursuit on horseback and with dogs, led by an unruffled, pipe-smoking man called Fassel (coolly played by Ben Foster), a familiar figure in this kind of narrative. (Joel Edgerton played a similar slave hunter in the recent TV adaptation of The Underground Railroad, and like him, Fassel has a black man in his employ, to Peter’s disgust.) Peter faces a gruelling ordeal in the gator-filled swamp but there is no guarantee that the commanding officers of the Union army will be any less high-handed.

The movie creates for Peter an absent family which is to provide the quest narrative and also a stubbornly strong Christian faith, which he has perhaps garnered in the US (he is supposed to have been born in Haiti). Director Antoine Fuqua and screenwriter Bill Collage tread reasonably carefully with this religion and are not tempted to make Peter’s scars equivalent to Christ’s scourging; instead they contrive a quietly powerful, still moment when Peter, alone on a crude rowing boat that he has taken, looks out on to the sunlit landscape. It evidently looks beautiful to him but is shot so austerely that its beauty is restrained. Is Peter having an epiphany? Is he lost in thought? The scene is left unexplained and unnarrated.

Elsewhere, the movie works very efficiently as a thriller, with Peter on the run from his pursuers. There is a great moment when he stumbles into a burning plantation left in a surreal ruin; running into the house in search of food, he catches a glimpse of himself in a mirror, for clearly the first time in a long time, or maybe the first time in his adult life. Is he struck by how careworn he looks? Or just by the strange fact of his own existence and survival? Again, it is a mystery.

Perhaps the final showdown with the hated Fassel is anticlimactic, given that it has to come before the third act of Peter’s military enlistment, but this is a strong, fierce, heartfelt movie.

• Emancipation is released on 9 December on Apple TV+.


Peter Bradshaw

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The Pale Blue Eye review – baffled, beardy Christian Bale in gruesome murder yarn
Set in 1830, a mildly ridiculous plot sends a haunted Bale to investigate the gothic killing of a military cadet

Peter Bradshaw

22, Dec, 2022 @5:00 PM

Article image
Beef broth and body shaming: the punk drama about why Empress Elisabeth was the Meghan Markle of her time
Director Marie Kreutzer talks about her latest film, which aims to portray a complex female character – whose story resonates with modern pressures on royal women under the glare of media scrutiny

Cath Clarke

01, Dec, 2022 @3:00 PM

Article image
Babylon review – Brad Pitt suaves through a grand hymn to golden age Hollywood
Pitt and Margot Robbie, and many razzle dazzle setpieces, help lift a story in no hurry to engage with the true-life nastiness of its era

Peter Bradshaw

19, Jan, 2023 @10:30 AM

Article image
Harriet review – Cynthia Erivo is sublime as legendary slave rebel
The remarkable life of freedom fighter Harriet Tubman is told with heart and cinematic craft in Kasi Lemmons stirring biopic

Peter Bradshaw in Toronto

11, Sep, 2019 @12:39 PM

Article image
Hotel Mumbai review – unflinching but uncertain terror-attack thriller
Starring Dev Patel and Jason Isaccs, this carnage-filled drama based on the real-life 2008 atrocity makes for uneasy viewing

Mike McCahill

27, Sep, 2019 @10:00 AM

Article image
The Birdcatcher review – ropey rural wartime thriller
Disguising herself as a boy, a Jewish girl escapes the Nazis by getting a job on a Norwegian farm in this hammy Euro-drama

Peter Bradshaw

02, Oct, 2019 @5:00 PM

Article image
She Said review – breaking the male silence around Harvey Weinstein
Admirably straightforward drama follows two of the reporters who cut through the defences around the apparently invulnerable producer

Peter Bradshaw

24, Nov, 2022 @1:00 PM

Article image
Extraction review – hokey, high-octane action thriller
Chris Hemsworth plays a super-tough mercenary on an all-guns-blazing mission to rescue a crime lord’s kidnapped son

Peter Bradshaw

22, Apr, 2020 @3:00 PM

Article image
Rebecca review – overdressed and underpowered romantic thriller | Peter Bradshaw's film of the week
Ben Wheatley’s take on the Daphne du Maurier story has moments of spectacle and disquiet but hunky Armie Hammer is miscast as the troubled widower

Peter Bradshaw

15, Oct, 2020 @4:00 AM

Article image
Tori and Lokita review – clarity of purpose in the Dardennes’ parable of the dispossessed
The new film from double Palme d’Or winners focusses on a pair of young immigrants to Belgium who find themselves working in dangerous situations

Peter Bradshaw

24, May, 2022 @4:58 PM