Tax concerns axed Batgirl, but studios will suffer if they become too cynical

Hollywood has always been hard-hearted – but now more than ever, it needs to remember that films are more than just profit-generating ‘content’

Gamblers and other types of investor are aware of the overwhelming need to avoid the “sunk cost fallacy”, to reject the irrational belief that even if a long-planned course of action is now clearly unworkable, you just have to keep on because you have sunk so much money and sweat into it. Ruthlessly cutting your losses is how executives demonstrate their virility. It’s what Rupert Murdoch did by closing the News of the World and it’s what Wayne Enterprises did in the DC Comics world by discarding the old merchant branches of its business in the 19th century.

But does that – should that – apply to movies?

Clearly, David Zaslav thinks so: the new CEO of the merged Warner Bros Discovery conglomerate has spectacularly pulled the plug on the $90m new Batgirl film during post-production. Even though “shelving” movie projects is common enough at early stages, actually throwing a finished film into the vault is rare. Zeslav had publicly made it his business to reverse Warner Bros’ existing strategy of prioritising streaming services, focusing instead on premiering prestige movies in movie theatres – only to find that Batgirl was not big enough to justify the additional promotional cost for a cinema rollout, yet somehow too big to dump on to the small screen. It’s a new iteration of the classic “mid-budget” nightmare that has been a perennial Hollywood problem. What to do with the mid-range movie that was once a solid bread-and-butter performer in 1970s and 80s cinemas, and still cleans up at awards season, but now falls between the two stools of blockbuster and indie?

Sienna Miller in 2020. A film in which the actor plays Louise Ferrier, Richard Neville's girlfriend, has not yet been seen.
Sienna Miller in 2020. A film in which the actor was cast as Louise Ferrier, Richard Neville’s girlfriend, has not yet been seen. Photograph: Taylor Jewell/Invision/AP

Reportedly, Zaslav has strategically decided to “shelve” Batgirl for a tax write-down, call its budget a dead loss to reduce the company’s tax liability, and by that token enhance profits generally – a strategy that of course will be bolstered by this spectacular and much-publicised failure. Do we hear the ghostly sound of laughter from those legendary producers Max Bialystock and Leo Bloom …?

This is what happens when studios treat movies as pure, undifferentiated corporate “content”, a Gazprom pipeline of superhero mush which can be turned off when the accountants say that it makes sense to do so. Yet it can happen to even the most well-regarded and prestigious-seeming indie films. The industry still whispers about the disappearance of Hippie Hippie Shake, the indie British movie about the 60s counterculture and the Oz trial with Sienna Miller as Louise Ferrier, Richard Neville’s girlfriend – a film that became mired in legal and contractual disputes and has still not been seen aside from test screenings.

Batgirl may well finally emerge on precisely those screening services that Warner Bros Discovery had disavowed: like the much-discussed “Snyder Cut” of DC’s Justice League, it will probably emerge, after the lawsuits have been settled, to great fan excitement.

Cynics may smile at this latest demonstration of corporate philistinism and heartlessness with regard to the work of directors, writers, actors, cinematographers and other artists. But hasn’t Hollywood always been an unsentimental business? Do you think Harry Cohn or Jack Warner or Sam Goldwyn would have fainted with shock at the news of what Zaslav is doing? Or would they just shrug and say, OK, yes, it had to be done …?

Maybe. But treating movies as individual artworks isn’t simply a cinephile mannerism or quixotic romance. If you fail to keep the faith with the idea of films as artworks, that will hurt your bottom line. The public will sense the cynicism and the emptiness and they will turn away from these films: there will be a colossal crisis, a kind of colony collapse disorder in the cinema.

So Batgirl should be released, on streaming services if need be. And Zaslav and his executives had better show the courage of their management convictions and see all their planned movies through to completion and distribution.

• This article and a photo caption were amended on 3 August 2022. Sienna Miller was cast as Louise Ferrier, not Germaine Greer, in the unreleased film Hippie Hippie Shake.


Peter Bradshaw

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Kevin Smith: ‘It’s an incredibly bad look to cancel the Latina Batgirl movie
The director and others have criticised Warner Bros over its decision to scrap the superhero movie starring Leslie Grace

Catherine Shoard

08, Aug, 2022 @1:22 PM

Article image
Batgirl axed, The Flash floundering – can Black Adam turn things round for DC’s troubled superheroes?
Any company with characters like Batman and Wonder Woman should be laughing all the way to the bank. So why are DC and its owner Warner Bros struggling with so many projects?

Steve Rose

18, Oct, 2022 @5:00 AM

Article image
Batgirl star Leslie Grace thanks fans for ‘love and belief’ following film’s cancellation
Actor speaks after the film, shot entirely in Glasgow on a $90m budget, was dropped from all platforms

Catherine Shoard and Severin Carrell

04, Aug, 2022 @10:18 AM

Article image
Joss Whedon to direct first ever Batgirl film
The Avengers director to move from Marvel to DC as writer, director and producer of the film, which will feature characters from the world of Gotham

Gwilym Mumford

31, Mar, 2017 @8:55 AM

Article image
‘Irredeemable’ Batgirl movie unexpectedly cancelled despite being in final stages
Warner Bros confirms film starring Leslie Grace as Barbara Gordon, Michael Keaton, JK Simmons and Brendan Fraser won’t ever be released

Sian Cain

03, Aug, 2022 @1:02 AM

Article image
Batgirl directors respond to surprise axing of film: ‘We still can’t believe it’
Adil El Arbi and Bilall Fallah have released a statement to express shock and sadness over the decision for their already shot film to be killed

Benjamin Lee

03, Aug, 2022 @6:24 PM

Article image
‘Secret’ screenings of cancelled Batgirl movie being held by studio – reports
It remains unlikely the public will ever see the scrapped $90m film, with the directors saying ‘it cannot be released in its current state’

Sian Cain

25, Aug, 2022 @2:57 AM

Article image
The Batgirl you’ll never see: why some films disappear for ever
She cost a cool $90m but the comic book heroine won’t even be streamed. Why do some productions deserve such an extreme fate?

Guy Lodge

06, Aug, 2022 @2:00 PM

Article image
3D mermaids, CobraGator and Louis CK: the never-released films Batgirl will join in Hollywood’s vault of shame
Warner Bros is not the first studio to bury a film six feet deep. Here are a few more of the worst movies you’ll never see

Stuart Heritage

03, Aug, 2022 @10:19 AM

Article image
Glasgow becomes Gotham for Batgirl as Scottish film industry booms
Culture minister says country is at a ‘critical mass of screen production’ that will keep jobs in Scotland

Libby Brooks Scotland correspondent

23, Jan, 2022 @3:29 PM