The Witch: Robert Eggers’ folk horror debut worms its way under your skin

As The Northman arrives in cinemas, Eggers’ first feature – which also introduced Anya Taylor-Joy to audiences – values dread over cheap jump scares

Robert Eggers’ new movie, The Northman, arrives in Australian cinemas this week. In order to get prepped for this bloody tale of Viking vengeance, check out his unsettling horror debut The Witch: a folk horror movie that does not rely on gore to terrify the audience, but instead gradually worms its way under your skin to slowly unnerve you. It’s not the plunge from the top of the rollercoaster but a slow drive down a dark, country lane.

The trailer for The Witch.

Set in 1630, a Puritan settler family are banished from their New England village after a heated religious argument in the colony. Isolated theologically and physically, patriarch William (Ralph Ineson) moves to the edge of a vast, dense forest with his family: wife Katherine (Kate Dickie) and their children Thomasin (Anya Taylor-Joy), Caleb (Harvey Scrimshaw), twins Mercy and Jonas (Ellie Grainger and Lucas Dawson), and infant Samuel. But nature is unforgiving and the family’s crops fail. Suddenly, while under Thomasin’s care, baby Samuel disappears, stolen by a witch who dwells within the forest.

This tangled woodland is the demarcation line between the God-fearing Puritans and the ancient, primal terror living within it. Witchcraft was an accepted reality of the 17th century: William and his family live in accordance with their strict religious convictions, and if God exists, so too must the Devil. When events start to unravel, we believe it because they believe it.

But it is not solely the witch’s actions that cause family bonds to deteriorate. Existing tensions are strained by the failing harvest and, as Thomasin was responsible for Samuel when he was taken, it is not long before fingers are pointed her way. There is also an interesting level of ambiguity to the tale – is this all the result of simple bad luck, or does each family member hold some responsibility for what befalls them?

Eggers’ meticulous attention to detail goes a long a way to making The Witch work. Costumes were made from 17th century patterns; the houses are constructed faithfully in the thatched style of the time. Even the dialogue is cribbed from genuine diary entries and documents from the period. While the characters’ manner of speaking may take a little getting used to at first, the payoff is an immersive and authentic experience.

With the Pilgrims having only recently arrived in North America, Eggers cast British actors in the movie. Ineson’s imposing height and gravelly accent lend William important gravitas, and Dickie convincingly spirals in the face of disaster upon disaster. But most notably, this is Taylor-Joy’s first film, and Thomasin is the most complex character of all. As the eldest child, she spends most of her time trying to corral her boisterous younger siblings and getting blamed for everything. She has little in the way of options for her future. In many ways, she is the black sheep of the family.

Mark Korven’s twisted score uses abrasive strings, sinister drones and weird vocalisations to fray your nerves; even seemingly innocuous events are made malevolent with these off-kilter undertones. And Jarin Blaschke’s atmospheric cinematography contrasts the chaos of nature against the neat order of the austere farmland.

Ultimately, The Witch works so well because it values atmosphere, slowly cultivating a pervasive sense of dread over sleazier, cheaper thrills. This is not a film that will be forgotten as soon as the credits roll, for The Witch prefers to crawl inside your head and stay there.


Adam Fleet

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The Wicker Man: 1973 folk-horror endures to this day as a masterpiece of the form
Free love and folk-singing hides a dark secret on the Scottish island of Summerisle in a film that’s bracing, exciting and downright funny

Shaad D'Souza

31, May, 2021 @1:00 AM

Article image
The Witch review – an eerie campfire tale that gets under your skin
Robert Eggers’ outstanding horror story does for witches what other film-makers have done for vampires and zombies

Benjamin Lee

10, Mar, 2016 @10:00 PM

Article image
Thoroughbreds: a murderous upper-class gambit from Anya Taylor-Joy
Two school friends reconnect over their lack of empathy and hatch a deadly plan in this marvellous 2017 thriller

Adam Fleet

02, Jun, 2021 @1:21 AM

Article image
The best horror films of the 21st century? You can’t go past It Follows
If you are casting about for a movie to watch this Halloween, you have to watch – or rewatch – It Follows, which is heart-racing perfection

Adam Fleet

25, Oct, 2022 @3:00 PM

Article image
Scream: darkly funny, extremely meta horror and a 90s time capsule that never gets old
Whether you caught the slasher series the first time around or only got the pop culture supercut, the original Scream films are still worth a watch

Elizabeth Flux

15, Feb, 2021 @4:30 PM

Article image
Norse code: are white supremacists reading too much into The Northman?
Robert Eggers’ Viking blockbuster has already been hailed by white nationalists keen to exploit European mythology. Can Hollywood tell historical tales without unwittingly appealing to toxic ideologies?

Steve Rose

22, Apr, 2022 @5:00 AM

Article image
The Witch review - original sin and folkloric terror
Robert Eggers’s Sundance-garlanded period horror is a chilling study of fear and the devils that live within us all

Mark Kermode, Observer film critic

13, Mar, 2016 @9:00 AM

Article image
From Ozploitation to Ice-T, Squid Game is just the latest splatter of class warfare on screen
Long before the Korean Netflix hit, the rich were using the poor for blood sport in action classics like Surviving the Game and Australian cult horror Turkey Shoot

Adam Fleet

09, Nov, 2021 @4:30 PM

Article image
Lean, mean and submarine: Underwater is an overlooked genre treat
This Kristen Stewart horror-thriller received mixed reviews – but when it comes to creature features, true genius lies in the middle to lower reaches of Rotten Tomatoes

Adam Fleet

07, Mar, 2023 @2:00 PM

Article image
The Host: Bong Joon-Ho's breakout monster movie is eerily prescient, not-quite-escapist fare
Parasite director focuses on humanising the dysfunctional family at the heart of a story that avoids obvious villains

Ying-Di Yin

09, Aug, 2020 @5:30 PM