Earwig and the Witch review – a disappointing CGI debut for Studio Ghibli

Gorō Miyazaki’s foray into computer generation, a magical tale of a gleeful brat adopted by a witch, falls far short of Ghibli’s hand-drawn output

Eighty-year-old animation legend Hayao Miyazaki once described computer-generated imagery as “thin, shallow, fake”. Now Studio Ghibli has made its first ever fully CG feature, and it’s, well, erm … The politest thing to say about Earwig and the Witch is that it’s not a patch on Ghibli’s hand-drawn output, with plasticky-looking characters and an aimless plot. More painfully still, the film-maker responsible is Miyazaki’s son, Gorō Miyazaki (who previously directed the pretty decent Tales from Earthsea and From Up on Poppy Hill).

To be fair, Earwig was made for Japanese TV, but there are so many echoes here of Ghibli films past that it’s impossible not to compare and despair. Like Howl’s Moving Castle, the script is based on a classic children’s book by Diana Wynne Jones; and just like Kiki’s Delivery Service the heroine is a plucky young witch. It begins on the doorsteps of an English orphanage where baby Earwig is left by her rock star mum along with a note: “Got the other 12 witches all chasing me. I’ll be back for her when I’ve shook them off. It may take years.”

The baby is renamed Erica Wig and grows up to be cheerfully brattish, wrapping everyone at the orphanage around her little finger. Unlike the other kids, Erica (voiced by Taylor Henderson) has no intention of being adopted. But one day a gruesome twosome shows up: buxomy blue-haired witch Bella Yaga (Vanessa Marshall) and her bad-tempered fella Mandrake (Richard E Grant). The witch needs a helper with her spells – and puts Erica to work grinding rat bones and picking prickly nettles.

There are some nice touches here and there, like the whirling little demons with batwings who are devoted to Mandrake. But the script ignores all the interesting bits of the story – who are the witches chasing Earwig’s mum and how does she shake them off? How does Earwig feel about being abandoned? Since the last Studio Ghibli release five years ago I’ve become a parent. I used to roll my eyes when friends said how much their young kids loved Ghibli films – sceptical that the slow bits and big complicated feelings would keep little ones entertained. Then I saw it first-hand – the dreamy faraway look on my four-year-old’s face watching When Marnie Was There. So this new film is genuinely disappointing.

And there’s a while to wait yet for the latest from Miyazaki Sr. Sixty animators are currently working – by hand, naturally – at a rate of one-minute of animation a month on his new film. Speaking last year, a producer said they have 36 minutes in the bag with three years to go.

• Earwig and the Witch is released on 28 May in cinemas.


Cath Clarke

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Every Studio Ghibli film – ranked!
In a bonus edition, we rank all the animated films – from Spirited Away to Ponyo – by the revered Japanese studio, most of which will be available on Netflix from February

Miriam Balanescu

28, Jan, 2020 @2:12 PM

Article image
Kiki’s Delivery Service review – lovable Studio Ghibli coming-of-age story
This sunny 1989 animation by Hayao Miyazaki broaches the issue of female sexuality more boldly than any Western children’s movie would dare

Steve Rose

26, May, 2016 @4:15 PM

Article image
Studio Ghibli's Hayao Miyazaki to return to features with caterpillar movie
The Japanese animator has come out of retirement to work on a full length version of Kemushi no Boro, about ‘a tiny, hairy caterpillar’ due to be completed in 2019

Andrew Pulver

14, Nov, 2016 @3:54 PM

Article image
Earwig and the Witch review – Studio Ghibli’s CGI debut fails to enchant
Clunky animation lets down Gorō Miyazaki’s tale of a quick-witted pigtailed orphan whose adoption has a magical twist

Simran Hans

30, May, 2021 @11:30 AM

Article image
How we made Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles
‘The question was: if Bruce Lee was an animal, what’s the silliest one he would be?’

Interviews by Graeme Virtue

10, May, 2016 @6:00 AM

Article image
‘I bought two dog encyclopedias’: how we made Dogtanian and the Three Muskehounds
‘When I give my name to make a restaurant reservation, everyone starts singing the Dogtanian theme song at me. The same happens in Portugal, in France, in Italy. It’s unbelievable’

Interviews by Rich Pelley

05, Jul, 2021 @1:25 PM

Article image
Puppet pups: is PAW Patrol authoritarian propaganda in disguise?
As a new film of the kids’ cartoon hits cinemas, the puppies’ popularity has made it a fascinating case study for the cultural politics of a generation

Caspar Salmon

11, Aug, 2021 @1:03 PM

Article image
The Deer King review – Studio Ghibli graduates take on dystopian deer tamer saga
Two grandees of Japanese animation adapt a Nahoko Uehashi fantasy novel that covers too much ground to take flight

Phuong Le

25, Jul, 2022 @12:00 PM

Article image
The Tale of the Princess Kaguya is a joy but won't hold kids' attention
‘A tumultuous emotional journey’ it might be, but this beautiful Japanese animated film still can’t compete with the likes of Big Hero 6 or Frozen

Josh Strauss

19, Mar, 2015 @3:36 PM

Article image
The Quintessential Quintuplets review – sisters compete for love in charming anime
The premise of a high-school tutor forced to choose which of his students to marry could have been disastrous but this romantic fantasy film avoids ickiness

Phil Hoad

05, Dec, 2022 @7:00 AM