The Human Voice review – Tilda Swinton on the verge in Almodóvar’s tale of despair

Swinton plays a woman abandoned by her lover in a short, affecting drama that echoes the uncertainties of lockdown

For the times of lockdown, Pedro Almódovar’s new short film is perhaps the most viable and relevant type of film production: a tale of someone isolated, regretful, anxious, unable to tell whether current arrangements are contingent or permanent, retreating into gestures of self-immolating despair. This theatrical piece is loosely based on Jean Cocteau’s 1930 stage play of the same name. It was adapted by Rossellini in the 40s, and also proved to be a jumping-off point for Almódovar’s own Women on the Verge of a Nervous Breakdown.

Tilda Swinton plays a woman who is on the verge of something similar. Or maybe the verge is now long behind her. She is living in what appears to be an apartment in Spain, vividly and richly presented in soupy reds and oranges that pop on the screen, with a hint of retro – decor that could exist only in an Almódovar picture. The play has this woman speaking on the telephone, in anguish, to the lover who has just left her – and that’s what Swinton does, too, only with cordless earphones, while his bags are packed ready to go in the hall, and his dog, miserable and confused to be abandoned as well, leaps trustingly along behind her as she strides restlessly about the flat or down to a hardware store to buy an axe. She needs it for a bit of futile pseudo-violence, whose only effect can be to make her feel worse.

Almódovar deconstructs both the woman’s state of mind – and perhaps his own emotional rhetoric as well – by at first keeping his camera well within this apartment and then by moving above it, revealing it to be a ceiling-less set constructed within the cavernous sound stage we see at the beginning of the film, some of whose kitchen drawers don’t open, and some of whose shelf adornments are fake. Like the woman’s life together with this departed man, this apartment is a phoney.

The woman is beautiful, elegant, evidently a star of stage and screen, or a model – at any rate, she is talking wryly about how her mature looks are now fashionable again: producers now want her at the moment that her lover feels the opposite. She speaks in a kind of muted, hyper-cerebralised depression and rage, but seems only to want a real, face-to-face goodbye – isn’t it the least he can do? We might assume that she is the injured party and that he has strayed. But at one moment she concedes that you might call her an “adventuress”. So perhaps things aren’t all that clear.

Swinton’s delivery has a theatrical style – it very much feels as if we could be watching a stage show – and there is something frozenly despairing about it; it is the voice of someone who is unwilling to relinquish her dignity or rationality and just give in to an aria of sadness. Even taking pills doesn’t completely allow her to let go – and there is something incidentally very sweet about the dog waking her up by slurpingly licking her ear. But she jiu-jitsus her loneliness and desertion into the raw material for performance and for self-expression.

An elegant jeu d’ésprit from Almódovar, with a bleak hint that moving on from the present malaise will mean some kind of wholesale destruction.

• The Human Voice is released on 19 May in cinemas, with a Q&A with Tilda Swinton and Pedro Almódovar.


Peter Bradshaw

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Pedro Almodóvar and Tilda Swinton: ‘I love the idea of the woman on the edge of the abyss’
The director and actor have finally achieved ‘a far-fetched dream’ by working together on his first film in English, The Human Voice. They talk about their mutual admiration, filming in lockdown – and how falling in love can destroy your sense of humour

Ryan Gilbey

14, May, 2021 @5:00 AM

Article image
Tilda Swinton Answers an Ad on Craigslist review – resplendent with movie-star magic
The ethereal star – as seen in an exuberant drag act by Tom Lenk – becomes a spirit guide in this wry show about the role movies play in our lives

Kate Wyver

08, Feb, 2019 @11:41 AM

Article image
Simple Passion review – sensitive French study of erotic obsession
Laetitia Dosch is sensational as a lecturer passionately embroiled with Sergei Polunin’s reptilian Russian diplomat

Peter Bradshaw

03, Feb, 2021 @2:00 PM

Article image
The Father review – Anthony Hopkins superb in unbearably heartbreaking film
Hopkins gives a moving, Oscar-winning turn as a man with dementia in a film full of intelligent performances, disorienting time slips and powerful theatrical effects

Peter Bradshaw

10, Jun, 2021 @10:00 AM

Article image
Ma Rainey's Black Bottom review – Chadwick Boseman glorious in his final film role
The movie version of August Wilson’s story of the blues, starring Boseman and a tremendous Viola Davis, is a ferocious opera of passion and pain

Peter Bradshaw

20, Nov, 2020 @5:00 PM

Article image
Wild Mountain Thyme review – Emily Blunt in an awful Irish stew
This bucolic romance, co-starring bashful Jamie Dornan, is awash with whimsy, wonder – and laughable accents

Peter Bradshaw

30, Apr, 2021 @6:00 AM

Article image
The Boys in the Band review – fierce fun and games in the pre-Aids era
This new film version of the off-Broadway hit about gay lives in New York is strange, compelling and unexpectedly potent

Peter Bradshaw

02, Oct, 2020 @8:43 AM

Article image
The Human Voice review – Leanne Best delivers a tour de force of despair
Gate theatre, London
Guilt, anguish and female torment simmer within a stunning star turn in this revival of Jean Cocteau’s study of a woman on the brink

Arifa Akbar

21, Sep, 2018 @7:00 PM

Article image
In the Heights review – Lin-Manuel Miranda musical loaded with Sunny-D optimism
There’s no space for bad feelings as Miranda’s exuberant and innocent Broadway hit transfers to the screen

Peter Bradshaw

21, May, 2021 @3:00 PM

Article image
Chemical Hearts review – elaborately contrived YA tale of young love
A high-school story tackling a complex and painful relationship with familiar tropes riddled with cliche

Peter Bradshaw

20, Aug, 2020 @9:00 AM