Moxie review – upbeat defiance wins out in Amy Poehler's rebel girl comedy

A quiet student finds her voice in print, battling everyday sexism at her high school in Poehler’s forthright but fun #MeToo drama

A breezy tale of riot grrrl power passed down from mother to daughter, Amy Poehler’s return to the director’s chair (after 2019’s Wine Country) is a winningly optimistic high-school romp with timely #MeToo-era themes. Adapted by screenwriters Tamara Chestna and Dylan Meyer from the hit YA novel by Jennifer Mathieu, it may lack the depth of Eighth Grade or the punch of Booksmart, but it’s still blessed with enough post-punk energy to raise a smile, several chuckles and the occasional fist-punching cheer.

Hadley Robinson is Vivian, a head-down student (“It’s so nice not to be on anyone’s radar”) voted “most obedient” in the crass list compiled by high-school jocks, grotesquely ranking girls in categories including “best rack” and “most bangable”. Like the majority of her female schoolmates, including studious best friend Claudia (Lauren Tsai), Vivian accepts and even expects this kind of everyday sexism, thanks in part to the complacency of Principal Shelly (a smilingly dismissive Marcia Gay Harden) who sees it as just a bit of “fun”.

But when no-nonsense new arrival Lucy (Saved By the Bell star Alycia Pascual-Peña) stands up to leering school football idol Mitchell (Patrick Schwarzenegger), Vivian is inspired to join her battle – albeit anonymously. Fired up by an old suitcase packed with the detritus of her mother’s punky past (flyers, badges, cassettes), she knocks together the titular DIY feminist zine, and then secretly distributes it around the washrooms and corridors of East Rockport High. Soon, the whole school is asking: “Who is Moxie?”, as formerly downtrodden girls of all social groups come together, taking a leaf out of the newsletter’s luridly photocopied pages to fight back against the boys.

Nico Hiraga, Amy Poehler and Hadley Robinson in Moxie.
Nico Hiraga, Amy Poehler and Hadley Robinson in Moxie. Photograph: Colleen Hayes/Netflix

Anyone with a soft spot for spiritedly rebellious high-school pics will find much here that is familiar, whether it’s the internecine intrigues of the Jane Austen-inspired Clueless, the thumbnail sketches of teen cliques so perfectly delineated in the Tina Fey-scripted classic Mean Girls, or the unpicking of sexual politics that harks back to the already heavily genre-reflexive Easy A. There are scenes of wardrobe solidarity that slyly echo the shoulder-strap rebellion of Stick It, and Nico Hiraga is clearly cut from Twilight’s “Team Jacob” cloth as late-bloomer Seth, formerly known as “the shrimp”, now a buff yet sensitive skateboarder who displays a puppyish new-man devotion to Vivian.

It would be easy to sneer at the diverse rainbow coalition whom Moxie imagines can suddenly put aside their differences, but the film is smart enough to acknowledge that middle-class white girl Vivian doesn’t have all the answers. A scene in which Claudia has to explain to her best friend that being the daughter of immigrants puts her in a very different position to Vivian strikes exactly the right note.

Smart casting is key to Moxie’s appeal, most notably rising star Robinson (previously best known for TV’s Utopia), who hits a well-judged balance between sympathetic, stroppy and occasionally sanctimonious. In the “adult” roles, Ike Barinholtz is spot-on as out-of-his-depth teacher Mr Davies, whose answer to “women’s issues” is to leave the room, while Marcia Gay Harden’s forced smile perfectly suits the principal who appears to lack principles. As for Poehler, she’s in her element as Vivian’s single mom, in search of a quiet life but whose rebellious spirit has not quite been quashed. “When I was 16,” she tells Vivian, “all I cared about was smashing the patriarchy,” a mantle that she has duly – if accidentally – bequeathed to her daughter.

A joyous performance by musical youths the Linda Lindas adds sparky charm, taking a lively stab at Bikini Kill’s anthemic Rebel Girl. Such positivity is entirely in keeping with a film that manages to address the spectre of bullying, harassment and rape with a sturdy spirit of defiance, humour and, most importantly, collective optimism.

Watch a trailer for Moxie.


Mark Kermode

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Emma review – Austen's sweet satire gets a multiplex makeover
Autumn de Wilde’s adaptation ramps up the comedy, but Anya Taylor-Joy remains wonderfully edgy as the meddling heroine

Mark Kermode

16, Feb, 2020 @8:00 AM

Article image
Stan & Ollie review – a love letter to cinema’s odd couple
Steve Coogan and John C Reilly excel in this bittersweet film about the twilight years of the great double act

Mark Kermode, Observer film critic

13, Jan, 2019 @8:00 AM

Article image
The Square review – an archly entertaining swipe at the art world
A satire on the contemporary art world sits edgily alongside a skewering of male privilege and middle-class altruism in Ruben Östlund’s surreal Palme d’Or winner

Mark Kermode

18, Mar, 2018 @9:00 AM

Article image
The Good Boss review – Javier Bardem bosses it in unsubtle Spanish satire
The star delivers a masterclass in reptilian charm as the unscrupulous head of a provincial firm in Fernando León de Aranoa’s tragicomedy

Mark Kermode, Observer film critic

17, Jul, 2022 @7:00 AM

Article image
Patrick review – wry, existential nudist comedy
The fact that almost everyone’s in the nude is the least remarkable thing about this deadpan delight from Peaky Blinders director Tim Mielants

Mark Kermode Observer film critic

22, Nov, 2020 @8:00 AM

Article image
How to Build a Girl review – enjoyably rough-and-ready
Wobbly Wolverhampton accent and all, American actor Beanie Feldstein carries this hard-to-resist adaptation of a coming-of-age bestseller

Mark Kermode

26, Jul, 2020 @7:00 AM

Article image
The Worst Person in the World – a mesmerising heroine for our times
Renate Reinsve’s barnstorming, flesh-and-blood performance is the heartbeat of Joachim Trier’s wistful tragicomic romance

Mark Kermode, Observer film critic

27, Mar, 2022 @7:00 AM

Article image
Red Rocket review – Sean Baker’s queasy comedy of a predatory, past-it porn actor
A charismatic, washed-up adult film actor grooms a teenage girl as his protege in the director’s ambiguous follow-up to Tangerine and The Florida Project

Mark Kermode, Observer film critic

13, Mar, 2022 @8:00 AM

Article image
Sorry to Bother You review – Boots Riley finds soul-selling comedy gold
A likable loser takes cold calling to a new level in Riley’s gleefully anarchic directorial debut

Mark Kermode

09, Dec, 2018 @8:00 AM

Article image
Moxie review – Amy Poehler's high-school comedy plays it straight
Poehler’s female-empowerment film is like Booksmart or Election – with all the humour and satire stripped out

Peter Bradshaw

01, Mar, 2021 @8:00 PM