Racist trolls may think they own Star Wars, but the saga's diversity issues are not cut and dried

The social media harassment of Kelly Marie Tran was abominable, but it’s not fair to say that racism is baked into the epic franchise’s core

It’s ironic that Star Wars, perhaps the ultimate tale of good triumphing over evil, has become embroiled in the current culture wars. George Lucas’s original trilogy is as universally adored as Brothers Grimm fairytales, the paintings of Leonardo da Vinci or the songs of the Beatles. Finding out that it is also loved by racists is a bit of a shock.

It’s hard to imagine Lucas sitting down in the mid-70s to ponder which far-out, disparate elements to throw into his original Star Wars film in order to concoct that perfect, swirling blend of science fiction and fantasy, because it’s hard to conceive of a time when the early Star Wars films didn’t exist. One thing we can be pretty sure of, however, is that Lucas did not imagine the early movies as standard bearers for Aryan white supremacy, such that attempts to create more multiracial casts for later episodes would be attacked as somehow letting the side down. Yet that is surely the only way we can read the mindset behind the hideous attacks by “alt-right” trolls suffered by the Asian American actor Kelly Marie Tran in 2017, after she was cast in a relatively small role in Rian Johnson’s The Last Jedi.

Tran, currently winning rave reviews for her voice turn in Disney’s Raya and the Last Dragon, revealed this week that the Last Jedi experience felt as if she “fell in love very publicly and then very publicly had an embarrassingly horrible breakup” in an interview with the Hollywood Reporter. The actor, who felt compelled to quit social media after the attacks, described a “succession of events in which I left the internet for my own sanity”.

Watch the trailer for Star Wars: The Last Jedi

“If someone doesn’t understand me or my experience, it shouldn’t be my place to have to internalise their misogyny or racism or all of the above,” said Tran. “Maybe they just don’t have the imagination to understand that there are different types of people living in the world.”

Why did these extremist trolls feel any ownership over Star Wars? Could it be because of Lucas’s unwieldy approach to race in the prequel films, which were criticised for imagining extra-terrestrials such as Jar Jar Binks, Nute Gunray and Watto according to, variously, Caribbean, east Asian and Jewish ethnic stereotypes? Even the Star Wars creator’s harshest critics usually saw such missteps as wrongheaded attempts to imagine a diverse galaxy.

Lucas borrowed successfully from the samurai films of Akira Kurosawa for his first trilogy, a move that these days might be seen as cultural appropriation, and his Imperial stormtroopers clearly recall the Nazi Sturmabteilung – not a problem, he made them the bad guys.

But perhaps the film-maker’s hamfisted attempts to broaden the cultural mix for the prequels accidentally ended up warming the cockles for modern-day Nazi Star Wars fans, a development few saw coming but a sign of how deeply problematic such blunders can be.

That the sequel trilogy tried to offer up a view of the galaxy as a diverse place with the casting of Tran and John Boyega, among other actors, is surely to its credit (even if Boyega has spoken publicly about the way he felt the series’ actors of colour were ultimately sidelined). It does seem bizarre that certain so-called fans balk at the prospect of seeing black men or Asian women flying the new movies’ X-wings, but have no issue at all with syntactically challenged, green-skinned, giant-eared Jedi homunculi or oversized dog-faced teddy bear sidekicks.

Perhaps Mark Hamill’s Luke Skywalker was himself the problem. Maybe generations of racists grew up on the idea of the ultimate hero being a white-skinned, blue-eyed kid with shiny blond hair, so that the idea of anyone of different ethnicity stepping to the fore felt like a personal insult.

But there has always been more to Luke than meets the eye. There’s just no way you can be poster-boy for white supremacy when your dad is really James Earl Jones.


Ben Child

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
After Russian trolls tarnished The Last Jedi, is it safe to like Star Wars again?
So the bad press was manipulated, the bigots and gender warriors have owned up to abusing its actors … now we can just enjoy Episode VIII for what it was: an OK film

Ben Child

04, Oct, 2018 @11:53 AM

Article image
A modern space opera: has Star Wars escaped the George Lucas worldview?
Disney’s takeover of the Star Wars has seen bigger roles for women and people of colour, in a sophisticated cinematic universe that looks more like the one we live in

Ben Child

20, Feb, 2017 @4:58 PM

Article image
Star Wars: The Last Jedi abuse blamed on Russian trolls and 'political agendas'
Report finds half of negative comments aimed at Rian Johnson’s movie came from Twitter bots or trolls, indicating fan backlash was overstated

Andrew Pulver

02, Oct, 2018 @12:33 PM

Article image
First trailer revealed for Star Wars: The Last Jedi
First footage of Episode VIII of the Star Wars saga hits the net after unveiling at the Star Wars Celebration fan event in Florida, along with the film’s poster

Gwilym Mumford

14, Apr, 2017 @4:00 PM

Article image
'You lot can’t rattle me': John Boyega defends explicit anti-racism posts in wake of George Floyd death
The Star Wars actor expanded on his defiance of racist social media users in an Instagram Live video

Catherine Shoard

28, May, 2020 @12:50 PM

Article image
Is the Han Solo Star Wars spin-off spiralling towards disaster?
Fans have got a bad feeling about the prequel after more reports of on-set turmoil. But recent history suggests we shouldn’t panic yet

Ben Child

28, Mar, 2018 @11:38 AM

Article image
Would George Lucas's Star Wars sequels have been better than Disney's?
It was a relief to many fans when the creator of Jar Jar Binks lost control of the space saga but his vision for the films that followed made a lot of sense

Ben Child

12, Nov, 2020 @3:48 PM

Article image
Disney's 'clean' Star Wars release could have a sting in the tale
Many of George Lucas’s additions to the special edition Star Wars trilogy were heinous. But those keen to see such tweaks reversed should be careful what they wish for

Ben Child

28, Feb, 2017 @5:21 PM

Article image
A load of 'MacClunkey': will George Lucas’s Star Wars tinkering never end?
Lucas has reportedly changed the famous Greedo scene in 1977’s Star Wars again, for its broadcast on Disney+. It’s yet another pointless edit by the director

Ben Child

13, Nov, 2019 @5:24 PM

Article image
Can Star Wars finally shake off the shadow of the original trilogy?
With an all-new trio of films in the works and Lucasfilm’s long-planned spin-offs looking doomed, are audiences ready to part ways with Luke, Leia and Han?

Ben Child

02, Nov, 2018 @11:20 AM