Hear me out: why Batman v Superman isn't a bad movie

The latest in our series of writers standing up for derided films is in praise of Zack Snyder’s gloomy superhero match-up

The most famous (or infamous) sequence in Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice comes along just after Batman has bashed Superman over the head with a washbasin. Weakened by Kryptonite gas grenades, the Man of Steel (Henry Cavill) gasps that Lex Luthor has kidnapped his mother, Martha. “Why did you say that name,” roars the Caped Crusader (Ben Affleck). His own mother, you see, was called Martha, too.

I remember, on seeing the film, being almost as staggered as Batman was. I’d been a superhero geek for decades, but I’d never noticed that the mothers of DC Comics’ two most iconic characters had the same name. And yet Zack Snyder, the director of Batman v Superman, or one of the writers, Chris Terrio and David S Goyer, hadn’t just spotted the coincidence, they had imagined the impact it might have on the characters in question, given that Batman’s parents were murdered when he was a boy, and that Superman was adopted by Martha Kent after his own biological parents were vaporised in a planetary cataclysm. As different as the two superheroes were, Batman v Superman showed that they were linked by the trauma of their parents’ horrific deaths. Genius! This is a film, I thought, that my fellow nerds were going to adore.

I wasn’t entirely correct. Most critics slated Batman v Superman as a miserable mess with a headache-inducing score by Hans Zimmer and Junkie XL, and a colour palette so dingy that it looked as if Superman had washed his blue and red jumpsuit along with his black jeans. Even viewers with a high tolerance for masks and capes were unimpressed. All too soon, Snyder’s film became a symbol of the way that Warner was mishandling DC’s superheroes, as opposed to the way that Disney was handling Marvel’s. And nothing about it was as derided as the Martha scene.

Well, OK. I admit that the dialogue could have been more elegant. Maybe the characters shouldn’t have kept referring to Superman’s adoptive mother by her Christian name. But I maintain that the Martha idea was a clever one, and it’s connected to the key theme which makes me love Batman v Superman while so many people loathe it. Snyder dared to take two of the most popular, commercially viable superheroes ever created, and to say that they were both screwed-up mummy’s boys. Marvel’s cinematic universe, in contrast, is stocked with well-adjusted, quip-swapping paragons. Even the Batman played by Christian Bale was a clubbable fellow. But Snyder gave some serious thought to the question of what our favourite costumed crime-fighters might be like if they actually existed, and he concluded, not unreasonably, that a near-omnipotent extraterrestrial and an orphaned, billionaire vigilante might have deep-rooted psychological issues. Inspired by Frank Miller’s game-changing 1986 graphic novel, The Dark Knight Returns, Snyder decided that Batman and Superman would be insecure, angry, guilt-ridden, nightmare-haunted – and despised by a fearful populace. Somehow, he got away with making a multimillion-dollar blockbuster on that very subject.

Yes, it’s hectic, dystopian and apparently lit by a low-watt torch bulb. Yes, it has an over-inflated sense of its own importance. But that’s how its two paranoid frenemies see the world. Affleck’s Batman is a sadistic loner who – thanks to the star’s imposing size and well-publicised personal demons – could plausibly beat up a roomful of Russian gangsters. This was the brutal bruiser that we Dark Knight Returns devotees had been waiting for. Cavill’s perma-frowning Superman, meanwhile, isn’t the gentle charmer that Christopher Reeve’s was. Snyder prefers to depict him as a living missile, sonic booming through the sky, or else as a divine messenger, floating down from on high for a brief, contemptuous word with us earthbound mortals. Since Batman v Superman was released, a television series (The Boys) and a film (Brightburn) have both played with the notion that an indestructible, unaccountable Superman-type might be a terrifying existential threat. But Snyder’s uncompromisingly subversive epic did so with Superman himself.

In a startling early sequence, the director recaps the climactic fight between Superman and General Zod from 2013’s Man Of Steel, but this time we see it from ground level. We see the shattering skyscrapers, the choking dust clouds, the innocent civilians who are killed and maimed. In short, we see the mass destruction which tends to be glossed over in Marvel’s blockbusters.

I understand why this doom and gloom might have been off-putting, but it was supposed to be. Batman v Superman isn’t a superhero movie, but an anti-superhero movie: a film about two people only a mother could love.

  • Batman v Superman is available on HBO Max in the US and on Now TV in the UK

Contributor

Nicholas Barber

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Batman v Superman: new synopsis and DIY Batmobile unveiled
Official plot details reveal a ‘new threat’ facing the duelling superheroes and a version of the classic car made entirely by the Caped Crusader

Benjamin Lee

10, Jun, 2015 @8:21 AM

Article image
Batman v Superman: five surprises we've learned this week
A mech-suited Batman, Wonder Woman without her tiara and Lex Luthor with the barnet of a 1990s footballer are among the shocks revealed in new shots from the Dawn of Justice set

Ben Child

03, Jul, 2015 @1:23 PM

Article image
Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice review – dark days in Metropolis
Ben Affleck and Henry Cavill clash in a bid to launch a new superhero franchise, but Zack Snyder’s shoddy adventure never gets off the ground

Mark Kermode, Observer film critic

27, Mar, 2016 @8:00 AM

Article image
Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice review – Ben Affleck earns his batwings
Gotham and Metropolis – not Affleck and Henry Cavill – are the true stars of Zack Snyder’s polished superhero showdown

Andrew Pulver

22, Mar, 2016 @10:00 PM

Article image
Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice – five things we learned from the new trailer
Clark Kent seems to be all over Bruce Wayne’s secret identity, Wonder Woman pivots the plot, the possible return of General Zod and more

Ben Child

03, Dec, 2015 @10:47 AM

Article image
Five tasks Justice League must complete to save the DC universe
Can the much-anticipated superhero team-up feel less like the critically reviled Batman v Superman and more like this year’s Oscar-buzzed Wonder Woman?

Ben Child

01, Nov, 2017 @4:29 PM

Article image
Batman v Superman trailer: Wonder Woman joins superhero duo
Trailer for Zack Snyder’s 2016 film premieres on late-night chat show in US to the delight of fans ... and Lex Luthor, apparently

Nancy Groves

03, Dec, 2015 @12:33 PM

Article image
Could Ben Affleck be the hero Superman vs Batman needs?

Ben Child: Fans are horrified by the Argo director's casting in Zack Snyder's film – but he could add a surprisingly cerebral touch

Ben Child

30, Aug, 2013 @11:23 AM

Man of Steel 2 will see Batman and Superman in 'physical conflict'

Director Zack Snyder reveals the superheroes will come to blows in the sequel to the Christopher Nolan-produced Man of Steel

Andrew Pulver

11, Nov, 2013 @9:08 AM

Article image
Every single thing that is wrong with Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice
A spoiler-packed guide to all that’s terrible about the superhero clash, from Lex Luthor as a malfunctioning android to Bruce Wayne’s fickle take on demolition

Dave Schilling

25, Mar, 2016 @5:23 PM