The Shop Around the Corner review – Lubitsch romcom still a Christmas delight

James Stewart and Margaret Sullavan’s love-hate romance, which spawned many later meet-cutes, is more eccentric than you might remember

Ernst Lubitsch’s 1940 romcom classic stars James Stewart and Margaret Sullavan as the two squabbling shop assistants, Alfred and Klara, who are anonymous romantic penpals falling in love without knowing who the other really is and who in real life can’t stand each other. It’s a parallel universe situation that effectively takes the dislike/love duality of the meet-cute scenario and perpetuates it through almost the entire drama.

The Shop Around the Corner is based on the Hungarian stage play Parfumerie and keeps the Mitteleuropa setting of elegant Budapest: strange to think that this film was appearing just as Hungary was joining the war, on the wrong side. It inspired many remakes, most famously the Tom Hanks/Meg Ryan weepie-romance update You’ve Got Mail in 1998 – with emails instead of letters – which shifted the action to New York. (My own personal theory is that the original’s ensemble set-up, with its gallery of shop assistants and a venerable father-figure boss, inspired the BBC TV comedy Are You Being Served?)

This is the first time I have sat down to watch The Shop Around the Corner since the last revival in 2010, and some of its weirder moments struck me afresh. Modern-day romcoms probably wouldn’t have a thwarted suicide attempt leading to a two-week hospitalisation, with the patient being swiftly cured by the spectacle of his store doing very well on Christmas Eve: a weird link to It’s a Wonderful Life. But revisiting this film lets you see how ingeniously constructed it is: Klara’s romantic letters, with their grand and high-flown insistence on general ideas, mean that Alfred and Klara don’t start talking about their specific situation and so don’t give the game away to each other. And naturally Alfred is miserable and grumpy: he is being unfairly victimised by his boss Mr Matuschek (Frank Morgan, famed for playing the Wizard of Oz) who wrongly suspects him of having an affair with his wife: a crisis that is to trigger his depression. Were it not for that unjust suspicion, Alfred might be in a sunnier mood and we wouldn’t have a story: and the scenes in which he indignantly stands up for himself are strangely real and uncomfortable.

And there are more epistolary complications: Mr Matuschek finds out about his wife’s infidelity from an anonymous letter. Who can have sent it? My money is on the nosey errand boy Pepi (William Tracy) who’s always out and about on his bicycle, pretends to be other people on the phone, saves his boss’s life and finally gets a promotion. There is a sprinkling of vinegary malice from the smarmy shop assistant Vadas, played by Joseph Schildkraut (an Oscar-winner a few years previously for his portrayal of Alfred Dreyfus in The Life of Emile Zola): it always makes me laugh when this conceited popinjay tries to tell his co-workers a joke and they coldly cut him off. A paprikash of romantic misadventure.

• The Shop Around the Corner is released on 3 December in cinemas.


Peter Bradshaw

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

The Shop Around the Corner – review

James Stewart and Margaret Sullavan shine in the central roles of Ernst Lubitsch's twice-remade classic, writes Philip French

Philip French

12, Dec, 2010 @12:07 AM

Article image
The Shop Around the Corner – review
Rerelease for Ernst Lubitsch's 1940 comedy, a sharp, elegant, unsentimental picture starring James Stewart. By Peter Bradshaw

Peter Bradshaw

09, Dec, 2010 @10:02 PM

Article image
Everybody Loves Jeanne review – salty romcom with intriguing edge of quirk
The stylish feature debut from Céline Devaux explores the life of businesswoman Jeanne, her louche ex-lover and a strangely seductive new acquaintance

Peter Bradshaw

24, Jul, 2023 @10:00 AM

Article image
The Worst Person in the World review – Nordic romcom is an instant classic
Renate Reinsve is sublime as a young woman veering between lovers in a film that reminds us of the genre’s life-affirming potential

Peter Bradshaw

24, Mar, 2022 @1:10 PM

Article image
Dare to Dream review – Berlin movie love story waltzes around the Wall
Can a movie rescue two film-studio lovers who are separated by geopolitics? This crowdpleasing German romantic drama tells the tale

Phil Hoad

08, Dec, 2020 @1:13 PM

Article image
Lost at Christmas review – sickly sweet Highlands romcom takes the wrong road
In this sentimental, unfunny seasonal story, two unlucky-in-love travellers join forces after getting trapped in a snowstorm

Leslie Felperin

03, Dec, 2020 @1:00 PM

Article image
Lucky review – spirited Ghanaian romcom captures the social media age
An idling student enlists the help of a wideboy friend in pursuit of a hot date in a comedy that veers between likable and laddish

Phuong Le

03, May, 2021 @1:00 PM

Article image
Attachment review – queer horror romcom is a rare Valentine’s Day treat
Director Gabriel Bier Gislason deftly combines dry Jewish humour with horror to create a surprisingly compelling and emotionally complex date-night thriller

Phuong Le

14, Feb, 2023 @7:00 AM

Article image
The Philadelphia Story review – fun and wit rise like champagne bubbles
The rerelease of this utterly beguiling comedy reminds us how extraordinary Katharine Hepburn, Cary Grant and James Stewart really were

Peter Bradshaw

12, Feb, 2015 @10:00 PM

Article image
Passengers review – spaceship romcom scuppered by cosmic creep
Chris Pratt and Jennifer Lawrence have plenty of chemistry but his cyber-stalker behaviour is objectionable and unexplained: don’t believe the trailers

Andrew Pulver

15, Dec, 2016 @2:00 PM