Sheep Without a Shepherd review – perky Chinese thriller that toes the line too carefully

A father uses his obsession with the movies to help his daughter when she is unjustly suspected of murder

It turns out that cinephilia is a productive use of time after all. When his computer is searched, Li Weijie, protagonist of this perky Chinese thriller, has watched 838 films in a year – and he uses his superior knowledge of the seventh art to get his family out of a pickle. Chinese but living in northern Thailand, he scrapes by as an internet technician, but his daughter finds herself at the centre of a murder investigation after she accidentally kills the son of a police chief who was trying to blackmail her with smartphone-filmed rape footage.

A remake of the 2013 Malayalam film Drishyam, this big Chinese hit ultimately doffs the cap to Korean cinema: it is Jeong Keun-seob’s 2013 film Montage that inspires Li when he has to provide his family with an alibi.

The cat-and-mouse game that ensues is fairly engaging, rooted in two sturdy performances from the main combatants: Xiao Yang’s Li, with his outwardly dopey demeanour but operating with an intelligent pragmatism, and police chief Laoorn, a crack investigator played by Joan Chen with a turbulent confluence of steeliness and maternal anguish. The fine details of Li’s scheme are rather broadly relayed – something not helped by director Sam Quah’s over-eager rhythms. The film cites Hitchcock as the master of tension, and puts commendable effort in to devise similar set pieces. But often the results are a touch forced, as in one scene sparked by a goat noticing Li before the car he is attempting to dispose of sinks into a river.

But Sheep Without a Shepherd gets the basics right and, as the town rises in anger in support of the family, it is swept along on a tide of indignation about police corruption and brutality. Given how pertinent a subject this is, it’s a shame about the film’s odd ending, with moralising overtones that make nonsense of Li’s reasons for earlier evading justice. It smacks of Production Code-type censorship and China Film Group, whose production this is, toeing the line on law and order.

· Sheep Without a Shepherd is released on 26 April on digital platforms.

Contributor

Phil Hoad

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Lost in the Stars review – Chinese doppelganger twist-a-thon is too fun to resist
A couple visit an island to celebrate their one-year wedding anniversary. The wife’s disappearance sparks a dizzying display of double takes and plot pivots

Leslie Felperin

11, Jul, 2023 @6:00 AM

Article image
No More Bets review – Chinese Wolf of Wall Street aims to teach moral lesson
With its exposé of digital scammers, fraud farms and gangmasters, Ao Shen’s thriller is inventive and snappily directed. A shame, then, that it morphs into a public health warning

Phil Hoad

04, Sep, 2023 @8:00 AM

Article image
Everything Under Control review – endearing gangster mashup from Hong Kong
Comedy caper deserves credit for fighting the corner of the city’s cinema in the face of the mainland film behemoth

Phil Hoad

21, Jan, 2023 @3:47 PM

Article image
Kill Boksoon review – intense Korean assassin thriller with satisfying complexity
This fast-moving yarn about a woman balancing contract killing with raising a teenage daughter has flair and depth to spare

Leslie Felperin

30, Mar, 2023 @6:00 AM

Article image
The Killer review – super-violent South Korean thriller with well-coiffed assassin
A retired mercenary must free a kidnapped teen in this lurid and drum-tight thriller

Leslie Felperin

21, Mar, 2023 @7:00 AM

Article image
Beasts Clawing at Straws review – jet-black comedy in arch Korean thriller
A long-suffering sauna worker finds a bag stuffed full of cash in a crime caper with perfectly pitched performances

Leslie Felperin

10, Aug, 2021 @11:00 AM

Article image
Target Number One review – gritty thriller about Canadian junkie caught in Thai sting
Antoine Olivier Pilon and Josh Hartnett are on good form as a heroin addict caught in police trap and the journalist who reports on the case

Leslie Felperin

28, Oct, 2020 @3:00 PM

Article image
Deliver Us From Evil review – frenzied hit-man thriller is full of cinematic life
Rooftop chases, vengeful yakuzas and brutal fistfights. What’s not to like in this Korean actioner from Hong Won-chan?

Peter Bradshaw

04, Jan, 2021 @2:00 PM

Article image
Midnight review – deaf heroine brings a new element to super-tense Korean thriller
Kwon Oh-Seung’s impressive debut cleverly uses social sexism to ramp up disbelief in his female characters

Leslie Felperin

08, Mar, 2022 @4:00 PM

Article image
Raging Fire review – bad cop steals show from good in savage Hong Kong thriller
With adrenaline-pumping action, Nicholas Tse’s vengeful villain cuts an almost tragic figure

Phuong Le

08, Nov, 2021 @4:00 PM