The Eight Hundred review – ear-rattling, breathtaking battle for 'Chinese Alamo'

One regiment’s symbolic and often suicidal defence of a warehouse in bombed-out Shanghai is the subject of this tub-thumping war epic

The domestic release of this thunderous Chinese war epic was delayed last year for what trade magazine Variety described as “mysterious political reasons”. It is thought the film displeased Communist party academics by portraying rival Kuomintang army officers during the 1937 Sino-Japanese war in too positive a light. To an outsider, however, The Eight Hundred looks like a paragon of tub-thumping patriotism in its description of heroic Chinese soldiers defending the Sihang warehouse in the battle for Shanghai. Like Dunkirk for Brits, the incident is seen here as an honourable defeat, a moment to galvanise national pride.

The Eight Hundred. Epic war drama, set during the Battle of Shanghai, directed by Chinese Sixth Generation director Guan Hu (Mr. Six). It stars acclaimed actors Zhang Yi, Wang Qianyuan, Jiang Wu and Li Chen.
Watching as if it is free street theatre ... The Eight Hundred. Photograph: Trinity Film

Director Guan Hu plunges straight into nightmarish battlefield chaos with breathtaking scenes of Shanghai bombed to ashes and burning rubble. The Chinese army is defeated, outnumbered and outgunned. The city has fallen but a single regiment is ordered stay behind to defend the warehouse – a symbolic last stand (western newspapers called it “the Chinese Alamo”). It would be miracle if these troops could hold out for a single day against the Japanese artillery slamming into the factory walls. And Guan goes hammer and tongs with the special effects, delivering stupendously, joint-rattlingly-loud battle scenes and combat sequences edited to the lightning pace of a superhero movie.

Watch the trailer for The Eight Hundred

Across the river from the warehouse is Shanghai’s neutral zone – populated by a chic cosmopolitan mix of Chinese and foreigners, who initially watch the spectacle across the water while sipping cocktails as if it was free street theatre. As the four-day struggle for survival nears its end, the bravery of Chinese soldiers becomes suicidal, as they strap on grenades and leap out of windows on to the Japanese troops below. But with so much intense focus lavished on the action, there’s none to spare for the characters’ emotional lives, and it’s hard to care much about who lives or dies. As for the musical score, it ought to be cautioned by the police for sonic assault and battery.

  • The Eight Hundred is in cinemas now

Contributor

Cath Clarke

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The Battle at Lake Changjin review – China’s rabble-rousing propaganda war epic
China’s costliest film ever is a sporadically thrilling, historically dubious account of a Korean war standoff, with all the subtlety of a rocket launcher

Phil Hoad

19, Nov, 2021 @12:00 PM

Article image
The Battle at Water Gate Bridge review – gung-ho Chinese war epic takes on Uncle Sam
With its wooden script and earnest tone, Tsui Hark’s government-sanctioned Chinese war epic may not win many hearts and minds

Peter Bradshaw

20, Dec, 2022 @7:00 AM

Article image
Ambush review – battle fatigued Nam actioner fights worn-out war tropes
This low-budget effort featuring phoned-in turns from Jonathan Rhys Meyers and Aaron Eckhart ticks off all the cliches while lacking a moral perspective

Phil Hoad

27, Feb, 2023 @11:00 AM

Article image
Burial review – alternative-history drama of the battle over Hitler’s corpse
Intriguing alt-history about a struggle to capture the dictator’s corpse is ill-served by vague characterisation and feeble action scenes

Phil Hoad

20, Sep, 2022 @2:00 PM

Article image
Mulan review – Disney's female warrior charges into reality
The live-action remake has blue-chip acting talent and exciting battles, adroitly sidestepping any awkward sexual issues in favour of glossy family entertainment

Peter Bradshaw

03, Sep, 2020 @4:05 PM

Article image
Ip Man: Kung Fu Master review – stylish martial arts potboiler
Li Liming’s film takes itself a bit too seriously, but fight fans will enjoy the nifty and inventive combat scenes

Leslie Felperin

16, Apr, 2021 @6:00 AM

Article image
Ip Man: The Awakening review – martial-arts action offers quickstep fight rhythms
The British are the baddies in a clunky origin story that can’t land a blow on Donnie Yen’s original series

Phil Hoad

28, Mar, 2023 @12:00 PM

Article image
The Warrior Queen of Jhansi review – Indian rebellion epic gets feminist retelling
Devika Bhise as the widowed monarch Rani Lakshmibai shows the Victorian Brits, including Rupert Everett, what she’s capable of in this impressive drama

Leslie Felperin

11, Dec, 2020 @9:00 AM

Article image
Condor’s Nest review – Tarantino-esque Nazi-hunt thriller heads for the pampas
Director Phil Blattenberger wears his love for the genre on his sleeve, but this allows him to outrun the film’s uneven execution and loose plot

Phil Hoad

13, Mar, 2023 @9:00 AM

Article image
The problem with Mulan: why the live-action remake is a lightning rod for controversy
The remake of Disney’s hit animation has triggered pro-democracy and human rights protests in Hong Kong and around the world

Jingan Young

07, Sep, 2020 @2:07 PM