Mulan review – Disney's female warrior charges into reality

The live-action remake has blue-chip acting talent and exciting battles, adroitly sidestepping any awkward sexual issues in favour of glossy family entertainment

The most empowered Disney heroine of all has returned. Here is a rousing and forthright live-action remake of the 1998 Disney animation with a blue-chip cast, all about the female warrior in 4th-century China who disguises herself as a man and joins the army to fight an invasion threat against the emperor. The result is an entertaining if straightforwardly glossy action-adventure from the Disney workshop.

Liu Yifei plays Mulan, a young woman from a small village, whose parents are fondly indulgent of her unladylike energy but secretly plan to get her married off. There is a nice performance from the veteran Chinese-American character actor Tzi Ma as Zhou, Mulan’s gentle, kindly father, who is himself an old soldier, still nursing a painful leg injury incurred in battle. But out in the wider world, storm clouds are gathering. Rebellious warrior Böri Khan, played with pantomime ferocity by Jason Scott Lee, is leading an attack on the emperor – a suitably stately performance from Jet Li – in revenge for the emperor killing his father. His small outlaw band gets supernatural help from Xianniang, played by Gong Li, a woman with witch-like magic powers.

All families must provide one man to fight, and Zhou, with no sons but determined to do his duty, limps grimly forward to offer himself when the recruiting officer arrives. It is actually a rather powerful moment in the 1998 animation: slightly less so here. But Mulan steals his uniform, sword and horse and rides off to volunteer in his stead, disguised as a boy, intensely uncomfortable in the men’s garrison with semi-unclothed guys boisterously fooling around flicking towels at each other etc, and forever volunteering for guard duty rather than take a shower with the rest – a sort of 4th-century inversion of Some Like It Hot. But Mulan astonishes Commander Tung (played with characteristic poise by Donnie Yen) with her amazing warrior skills in training. She also has an ambiguous, meet-cute-type bromance-romance rivalry with fellow soldier Honghui (Yoson An).

This new Mulan places a 21st-century emphasis on the parallels between Mulan and Xianniang. They are polar opposites, but both are women who have infiltrated a man’s world; both must use shapeshifting subterfuge to assert themselves, both in battle against the enemy and also to fit in with their comrades. Finally, there are to be encounters and significant dialogue scenes between Mulan and Xianniang, who have more in common than either of them supposed, even in the drama’s biblical temptation-in-the-desert scene, when Xianniang attempts to seduce Mulan to the ways of evil in the vast wilderness of her exile.

The battle scenes are very well managed, as watchable and exciting as anything else in the film, although for me the sheen of CGI illusion in the spectacle reduces its visceral power. And what about the ambiguously romantic and even sexual charge in Mulan’s disguise? This movie adroitly sidesteps any real-world discomfort on this score, presenting it as a matter of hilarious family movie embarrassment. There is one comic moment when Commander Tung reveals to Mulan that he knew her father as a young man and now wishes her to marry his own daughter. “I look forward to seeing your father’s face when he hears the news!” he chortles.

The crunch comes when Mulan has to take a moonlit bathe in a lake away from the guys in the middle of the night and – wouldn’t you know it – the handsome Honghui shows up, sees Mulan up to her neck in the water, and strips off to join what he still supposes to be his male pal. Surely, we wonder, Mulan can’t avoid revealing herself? But with narrative and editing sleight-of-hand, the imposture is maintained. And so the story continues, as Mulan is to earn everyone’s respect, even being awarded an “I’m Spartacus” moment as all of her fellow soldiers declare their admiration for her. An enjoyable piece of machine-tooled entertainment – though the envelope is not exactly pushed.

• Mulan is on Disney+ from 4 September.


Peter Bradshaw

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Mulan review – Disney's dynamic girl warrior hits the small screen…
This terrific live-action remake cries out to be seen in cinemas

Wendy Ide

06, Sep, 2020 @10:00 AM

Article image
The problem with Mulan: why the live-action remake is a lightning rod for controversy
The remake of Disney’s hit animation has triggered pro-democracy and human rights protests in Hong Kong and around the world

Jingan Young

07, Sep, 2020 @2:07 PM

Article image
The Call of the Wild review – old-fashioned shaggy-dog story with bite
Disney’s adaptation of the classic Jack London adventure, starring Harrison Ford and a pack of CGI critters, is enjoyably corny

Peter Bradshaw

17, Feb, 2020 @8:00 PM

Article image
The Mulan trailer is a dismal sign Disney is bowing to China's anti-democratic agenda | Jingan Young
Mulan has been transformed from life-affirming epic to patriotic saga, showing Hollywood is prioritising box office success

Jingan Young

08, Jul, 2019 @3:46 PM

Article image
Onward review – Pixar conjures big-screen adventure with wizard quest story
Chris Pratt and Tom Holland play teenage elves in this standard-issue but entertaining supernatural quest story

Peter Bradshaw

06, Mar, 2020 @6:00 AM

Article image
Spies in Disguise review – Will Smith brings pecks appeal to animated caper
A secret agent ruffles feathers in the espionage world when he is accidentally transformed into a pigeon in this entertaining family adventure

Peter Bradshaw

16, Dec, 2019 @2:00 PM

Article image
Mulan: why it was a missed opportunity to create a strong Asian woman on screen
In casting waif-like Liu Yifei in its live-action remake, Disney squandered its chance to show a Chinese audience that girls can be both beautiful and tough

Yuan Ren

22, Sep, 2020 @7:00 AM

Article image
'Wrong' for a white man to direct new Mulan film, say fans
Choice of Alex Graves ends hopes that an Asian film-maker would direct the live action story of a Chinese woman who joins the army in place of her sick father

Alan Evans

18, Oct, 2016 @10:06 AM

Article image
The Lion King review – deepfake copycat ain't so grrreat | Peter Bradshaw's film of the week
Disney’s reboot of its much-loved 1994 animation is a plausibly real retelling of the story of prince Simba and his struggle against wicked uncle Scar

Peter Bradshaw

11, Jul, 2019 @4:04 PM

Article image
Moana review – Disney's amiable Polynesian adventure
Princess Moana battles to reunite an ancient goddess with a precious stone in the studio’s latest attempt to match Frozen

Peter Bradshaw

01, Dec, 2016 @10:00 PM