Million-pound question: why save Secret Cinema while real cinemas are in ruins? | Marc Burrows

As affordable arts venues fight to survive, the exorbitant events company got a huge bailout. And film fans will pay the price

Film fans experienced a collective meltdown on Monday when it was revealed that Secret Group, the company behind immersive movie experience Secret Cinema, had received almost a million pounds in aid as part of the government’s culture recovery fund, while more affordable and accessible venues had been turned down.

The fund, announced by Rishi Sunak after widespread criticism that Covid-19 bailouts weren’t doing enough to protect the arts, awarded its first wave of grants this week: £257m split between 1,385 arts organisations. Big winners included Manchester’s Mission Mars, responsible for numerous venues and events in the city (£1m), London’s Wigmore Hall (£1m), the Royal Philharmonic (£996,702) and Brighton and Hove city council (£990,000). However, it was the awarding of £977,004 to the Secret Cinema franchise that raised eyebrows.

Founded in 2007 by entrepreneur Fabien Riggall, Secret Cinema has become known for its immersive screenings, recreating the worlds of much-loved movies such as Star Wars, Blade Runner, Back to the Future and The Shawshank Redemption. Recently it tackled television for the first time, with a well-received experience based around the Netflix show Stranger Things. Secret Cinema events are huge productions, with elaborate sets and dozens if not hundreds of performers. The Stranger Things presentation boasted a recreation of the series’ Starcourt Mall set and an impressive 360-degree projection of clips from the show, augmented by actors and stunt performers.

A 2015 production of the Empire Strikes Back cast visitors as rebel agents, acting out the entire first Star Wars movie in a disused print factory converted to look like the Death Star and the planet Tatooine, before settling back to watch its sequel. The events are hugely impressive operations and terrifically good fun. They are also hideously expensive. The cheapest ticket for Stranger Things was £49, the most expensive £139. This is out of the price range of many people.

The whopping grant awarded to Secret Group, the ninth largest of 1,385 organisations, quickly raised hackles. The problem isn’t so much the funding of Secret Cinema per se – it’s an arts organisation missing out on business during the pandemic, which is what the fund is for. What many object to is the size of the grant, particularly at a time when affordable cinemas – including London’s Peckhamplex, which charges just £4.99 for all tickets – are being forced to close until further notice. Independent cinemas are covered under the scheme by a £30m grant distributed by the BFI, but so far only 42 theatres have received money. Those 42 venues are sharing a total of £650,000, around two-thirds the amount granted to Secret Cinema, or Wigmore Hall. It has given the impression that Arts Council England and the BFI are favouring highbrow and metropolitan events over affordable grassroots venues.

Peckhamplex in south London
Peckhamplex in south London Photograph: Susannah Ireland/The Guardian

It’s easy to see where the bitterness comes from. While some of the most powerful organisations enjoyed £1m grants, a third of applicants were turned down under the scheme’s strict criteria. Manchester’s Frog & Bucket comedy club says it was denied funding on the grounds that it was not “culturally significant and/or contributing to provide cultural opportunity in England” despite being one of the few venues in the UK currently offering performers work. The club is now desperately trying to fundraise privately. Applicants to the culture recovery fund are required to prove they were “viable businesses”, but Secret Cinema has reported pre-Covid losses in the millions. All of which has created the impression of a double-standard: that bigger organisations are being granted a substantially bigger slice of the pie.

There may be some comparison of apples with oranges here: Secret Cinema, which is essentially a giant theatre production with a film shown at the end, and the likes of Peckhamplex or Cineworld – which also announced it was closing its venues until further notice – are very different ways of consuming movies. But critics cannot be blamed for feeling resentful when the disparity in funding is so wide. A family of five can see a blockbuster at Peckhamplex for £25, half the cost of the cheapest single ticket to Secret Cinema. Grassroots cinemas provide a valuable and, crucially, affordable escape from the grim reality of pandemic life. Perhaps such venues deserve to be a little higher on the government’s list of cultural priorities.

• This article was amended on 15 October 2020. An earlier version mistakenly said that two-thirds of applicants to the first round of the culture recovery fund were turned down. This has been corrected to a third of applicants. In addition, a reference to Secret Cinema employing volunteers has been removed as the company no longer does so.


Marc Burrows

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Arts Council England is supporting the best of the UK’s cultural sector | Letter
Letter: The funding body’s CEO, Darren Henley, on how the government’s culture recovery fund is helping struggling creative organisations of all shapes and sizes


19, Oct, 2020 @4:01 PM

Article image
Seth Rogen and Meryl Streep comedies burned by the sun at UK box office
Secret Cinema’s 28 Days Later beats the heat as the Bad Neighbours sequel and diva Florence Foster Jenkins wilt

Charles Gant

10, May, 2016 @1:32 PM

Article image
Emma Watson's new film makes £47 at UK box office
Harry Potter star’s latest release The Colony, about a woman infiltrating a cult in Pinochet-era Chile, had a token cinema release and will rely on home streaming

Henry Barnes

05, Jul, 2016 @5:17 PM

Article image
Secret Cinema’s new owners want to be the Netflix of live events
TodayTix eyes global expansion for UK firm known for immersive film screenings, which took a Covid hammering

Mark Sweney

08, Oct, 2022 @7:00 AM

Article image
UK cinema box office sees strongest first quarter since 2011
Hits such as Fifty Shades of Grey and The Theory of Everything led to more than 42m admissions in the first three months of the year

Benjamin Lee

23, Apr, 2015 @11:29 AM

Article image
UK box office: Taken 3 grabs the prize, while cinema earnings rise 33% year-on-year
Charles Gant: Awards contenders are coming thick and fast at the box office, but tough cookie Liam Neeson triumphs in the shootout for top chart honours

Charles Gant

13, Jan, 2015 @5:53 PM

Article image
Why Mrs Brown's Boys was d'saviour of cinema this summer | Catherine Shoard
Catherine Shoard: The critics may have panned it but Mrs Brown's Boys is true auteur cinema, a triumph of Brendan O'Carroll's vision

Catherine Shoard

04, Jul, 2014 @5:56 PM

Article image
Secret Cinema: Dirty Dancing review – the UK's biggest hen party
Re-enactments of the film’s big scenes enable a hyped-up, hula-hooping crowd in a sing-along with the atmosphere of a drunken sleepover

Kate Hutchinson

25, Jul, 2016 @11:44 AM

Article image
Save our cinemas before it is too late | Letter
Letter: Producers and distributors must support exhibitors through this crisis, or independent venues may soon become extinct, says Prof Ian Christie


10, Aug, 2020 @4:35 PM

Article image
28 Days Later at Secret Cinema: a bloodthirsty attack on the wallet
Danny Boyle’s cult horror seems an ideal showpiece for the immersive event company, but this well-staged show was hobbled by the dead-eyed pursuit of punters’ pounds

Stuart Heritage

15, Apr, 2016 @10:22 AM