Superintelligence review – Melissa McCarthy can't save unfunny AI comedy

The two-time Oscar nominee sleepwalks through another underwhelming collaboration with her film-maker husband Ben Falcone

Melissa McCarthy, a respected two-time Oscar nominee and hysterically funny comic dynamo, has a problem, a longtime allegiance that leads an inarguable talent into inarguably dodgy territory time and time again. His name is Ben Falcone: actor, writer, director and also her husband.

While it was cute enough to see him cameo alongside her in the excellent Paul Feig trifecta of Bridesmaids, The Heat and Spy, it’s rapidly become less cute when he corrals her into making something he’s directing, a reliably uninteresting film-maker who’s mastered the art of crafting almost deliberately unfunny comedies centred around a star who deserves much much better. There were sparse scraps of vaguely amusing physical humour to be found in their first collaboration, Tammy, all of which had disappeared by the time they came together again for The Boss, a film which is a certified masterwork in comparison to their next, the punishingly joyless back-to-school farce Life of the Party, a string of throwaway films that have turned him into something of an albatross around her neck. One might have naively hoped that her breakthrough dramatic work in Can You Ever Forgive Me would have caused a much-needed step back, a re-evaluation of sorts, a move away from the one-note dross he’d been peddling but sadly, she’s doubling, or rather tripling, down with one set for release just in time for Thanksgiving and two more on the way.

So before she plays a superhero in one and Santa Claus’s wife Margie in the other (yes, really), she’s up against a megalomaniacal Alexa in Superintelligence, a film that’s actually not quite as interminable as it sounds and not as bad as the similarly themed Jexi, the faintest praise one can give a movie but praise nonetheless. McCarthy is Carol, an average Joan, who left behind a high-powered career in tech to focus on more philanthropic pursuits, a quest that also tanked her relationship. One day, her uneventful life gets an unlikely upgrade when she’s contacted by a superintelligence, voiced by James Corden (the reason being that Carol is his biggest fan, one of many reasons why it’s hard to ever truly like Carol). She’s been picked to prove whether humanity is worth saving or not and she has just three days to prevent the end of the world.

There’s a clear uptick in ambition here with a lower, family-friendly rating and a wider scope, both with the apocalyptic sci-fi plot and a lurch into a more straight-faced sentimentality, something that’s not usually part of Falcone’s oeuvre. But in an effort to reach a larger audience, there’s a smoothing out of McCarthy’s edges, often best on display in raunchier, less constrained comedies that showcase her ability to improvise and do whatever is needed to get a laugh, vanity be damned. She has a few bigger moments here, such as trying to gracefully land on a bean bag chair, but it’s mostly a rather thanklessly beige role, just ambling along from A to B without much to do in-between. So often with McCarthy, it’s hard to imagine any other actor being able to pull off one of her performances but here it’s hard to imagine any other actor who couldn’t do this in their sleep. There’s something interesting to say about a self-confessed do-gooder’s good deeds taking on a destructive edge, how selflessness can ultimately be selfish but the script, from longtime Falcone collaborator Steve Mallory, avoids anything too knotty, choosing to make Carol a boringly blemish-free everywoman instead.

There’s room here for more comedy than we end up getting but the script is so light on laughs, criminally so, that instead we’re forced to find something else to latch on to, such as Carol’s surprisingly low-key and likable romance with her ex, played by Bobby Cannavale. Their scenes are the most engaging even if their dynamic isn’t sketched thoroughly enough for us to truly invest. The use of Corden is as charmless as he is while elsewhere, Jean Smart and Brian Tyree Henry are wasted as the president and Carol’s BFF respectively, turning up with enthusiasm but given little to play with.

It speaks to the extremely low bar set by Falcone and McCarthy’s previous films together that something as forgettable and unfunny as Superintelligence won’t be filed as a total disaster. Instead, it’s just another regrettable waste of her talent and another reminder that the best marriages can lead to the worst movies.

  • Superintelligence is available on HBO Max on 26 November and will be released on the UK on 11 December


Benjamin Lee

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The Starling review – toe-curlingly embarrassing Melissa McCarthy drama
Netflix’s strange, sentimental film about a grieving woman who befriends a bird is a wildly misjudged mess

Peter Bradshaw

12, Sep, 2021 @4:13 PM

Article image
The Happytime Murders: Melissa McCarthy snorts ecstasy with puppets in Henson comedy trailer
The star teams up with A Muppet Christmas Carol director Brian Henson for raucous new film The Happytime Murders

Guardian staff

18, May, 2018 @3:23 PM

Article image
The Boss review – unfunny adventures in capitalism with Melissa McCarthy
McCarthy’s disgraced tycoon deals in cheap jokes in a foul-mouthed caper that swats at suburbia, salesmanship and girl-scouting, directed by the star’s husband

Jordan Hoffman

06, Apr, 2016 @4:00 PM

Article image
The Happytime Murders review – puppet comedy is stuffed with unfunny jokes
Melissa McCarthy investigates a series of brutal puppet murders in a staggeringly bad attempt to add X-rated humour to Sesame Street

Charles Bramesco

22, Aug, 2018 @9:00 PM

Article image
Life of the Party review – Melissa McCarthy's college comedy fails the grade
An aggressively unfunny shamble of cliches marks a regrettable addition to the comic performer’s patchy resume

Benjamin Lee

10, May, 2018 @2:00 PM

Article image
Thunder Force review – Melissa McCarthy gets superstrength in rote superhero comedy
McCarthy and Octavia Spencer are childhood friends turned crime-fighting duo in this by-the-numbers comedy

Peter Bradshaw

09, Apr, 2021 @7:01 AM

Melissa McCarthy and Paul Feig may reunite on new comedy Susan Cooper

New film would be third time pair have worked together – following Bridesmaids and The Heat – if plans go ahead

Kelechi Anucha

26, Jul, 2013 @4:15 PM

Article image
Can You Ever Forgive Me? review – Melissa McCarthy forges a great performance
In this shaggy, melancholic true story, the Oscar nominee delivers some of her best work yet as a struggling biographer who finds an unlikely new source of income

Benjamin Lee

10, Sep, 2018 @9:08 PM

Article image
Melissa McCarthy to lob fairy dust at Tinker Bell role
Actor, known for her outrageous supporting roles in Bridesmaids and The Heat, will take the lead in 20th Century Fox’s live action story, based on Peter Pan

Ben Child

21, Nov, 2014 @9:18 AM

Article image
Ocean's 8 review – starry cast can't steal enough attention in all-female reboot
Sandra Bullock, Cate Blanchett and Rihanna head up a gender-swapped take on Ocean’s Eleven that suffers from an absence of tension

Benjamin Lee

06, Jun, 2018 @3:59 AM