Joker 'a betrayal' of mentally ill people, says David Fincher

Mank director rails at the risk-averse production strategy of major Hollywood studios

Mank director David Fincher has described Todd Phillips’ Oscar-winning Joker as “a betrayal” of mentally ill people.

In an interview with the Daily Telegraph, Fincher was reflecting on Joker’s surprise success at the box office in a wide-ranging attack on the risk-averse production strategy of the major Hollywood studios. Saying that studios “don’t want to make anything that can’t make them a billion dollars”, he also suggested that occasionally “challenging” material can get support, if there is solid previous evidence of commercial potential.

Without the example of The Dark Knight – a similarly dark-themed take on a superhero story – Fincher suggested that Joker, with its evident allusions to classic Martin Scorsese movies from the 1970s and 80s, would have struggled to get off the ground. Fincher said: “I don’t think ­anyone would have looked at that material and thought, ‘Yeah, let’s take [Taxi Driver’s] Travis Bickle and [The King of Comedy’s] Rupert Pupkin and conflate them, then trap him in a betrayal of the mentally ill, and trot it out for a billion dollars.’”

Joker, which won a best actor Oscar for its lead, Joaquin Phoenix, was criticised on its release for “perpetuating damaging stereotypes” in its characterisation of its central figure, Arthur Fleck, as a psychiatric patient who becomes violent after stopping his medication. In the Guardian, medical professionals Annabel Driscoll and Mina Husain described this as “not only misinformed but [it] further amplifies stigma and fear”.

In contrast, however, film-maker and disability activist Justin Edgar praised Joker as “a classic of disability cinema, a film that takes the experience of the outsider and makes us root for them”.


Andrew Pulver

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Joker makes great disability art by letting its hero bite back
The new Batman spin-off understands perfectly the frustration and helplessness caused by involuntary mental health conditions – but refuses to milk them for tragedy

Justin Edgar

27, Sep, 2019 @2:26 PM

Article image
'It's mind-blowing': Emma Tillinger Koskoff on producing The Irishman and Joker
From an eight-minute standing ovation at Venice to ecstatic reviews, both the producer’s 2019 movies have been huge hits. She explains how it panned out

Alex Godfrey

19, Dec, 2019 @10:03 AM

Article image
Joker – the incels, the incitement, the ending: discuss with spoilers
Joaquin Phoenix’s cackling baddie is unleashed today – here’s your chance to talk about whether Todd Phillips is trolling us, or if his film deserves all the Oscars it can get

Jordan Hoffman

04, Oct, 2019 @11:53 AM

Article image
We should feel sorry for Jared Leto. His Joker never had a chance
The actor’s Suicide Squad character had been sidelined long before Todd Phillips’s film starring Joaquin Phoenix as Batman’s arch enemy was greenlit

Ben Child

22, Oct, 2019 @12:21 PM

Article image
Auteurs assemble! What caused the superhero backlash?
They’ve conquered the box office. Now it’s payback time. As they are attacked by film-makers like Martin Scorsese, are TV and movie superheroes fighting a losing battle against reality?

Steve Rose

23, Oct, 2019 @4:03 PM

Article image
Hollywood's gender divide laid bare by analysis of this season's Oscar contenders
Exclusive: Data on this year’s awards contenders reveals three youngest best actor hopefuls have never made a film with a female director

Katherine Purvis and Catherine Shoard

15, Nov, 2019 @3:38 PM

Article image
Gary Glitter will not receive Joker royalties, say rights holders
Snapper Music and Universal Music Publishing Group say they own the rights to the singer’s catalogue and do not pay him

Ben Beaumont-Thomas

15, Oct, 2019 @7:49 AM

Article image
Quentin Tarantino: I am in combat with blockbuster franchises
Quentin Tarantino says ‘original movies’ are in a ‘war’ with superhero and Star Wars franchises, echoing Martin Scorsese’s attack on Marvel films

Andrew Pulver

23, Jan, 2020 @2:32 PM

Article image
Scorsese on superhero movies: 'The situation fills me with terrible sadness'
Director rejoins controversy he started, praising the artistry of the blockbuster franchises but complaining they lack mystery and emotional danger

Andrew Pulver

05, Nov, 2019 @12:08 PM

Article image
Marvel's Kevin Feige brushes off Scorsese superhero movies criticism
Studio chief describes as ‘unfortunate’ the director’s claim that the blockbusters were like theme parks and not cinematic

Andrew Pulver

11, Nov, 2019 @11:16 AM