Gulabo Sitabo review - mildewed mansion drama bustles and crumbles

Amitabh Bachchan and Ayushmann Khurrana star in Shoojit Sircar’s puzzling tale of class and property management

The first big Indian release of 2020 to divert towards streaming is an offbeam, strangely mismanaged parable about property management that renders its stars all but unrecognisable. The established Amitabh Bachchan is buried beneath old-age latex and thick-lensed glasses; emergent pin-up Ayushmann Khurrana is weighed down by a (presumably prosthetic) middle-aged spread. However director Shoojit Sircar’s gaze keeps drifting beyond them, to a location you couldn’t make-under: a mildewing Lucknow mansion house, lorded over by Bachchan’s shuffling miser Mirza, ever looking for ways to kick Khurrana’s collected waifs-and-strays to the kerb. The curious, altogether tentative drama that ensues may be as close as any film-maker has come to signing off on a Hindi redo of TV’s Rising Damp.

Alas, it’s also one of those cases where forced idiosyncrasy tries the patience from an early stage. With 2015’s sharp, breezy Piku and 2018’s delicate but involving October, Sircar had nudged Indian commercial cinema in a rewarding, naturalistic direction; but this just feels like a strain. A laboured first half scopes out the characters’ dingy surrounds without threatening to go anywhere, and feet are apparently being dragged because Sircar and generally reliable screenwriter Juhi Chaturvedi aren’t themselves sure which direction to move in. Brakes are soon applied to the mounting narrative of landlord-tenant class war – “Parasite!”, yells Mirza, reminding us of a more decisive film on a similar subject – in favour of a softer landing as both antagonists fall prey to creeping gentrification.

Watch the trailer for Gulabo Sitabo (without subtitles)

While the supporting cast successfully suggest a bustling, mutually sustaining community, the stars come to seem like liabilities, which wasn’t the case with Sircar’s previous films. Bachchan works hard at his swaddled meanie character, but make-up and props are doing most of the work, work that ultimately serves to distance actor from audience. A tired-seeming Khurrana, meanwhile, presents as blandly anonymous, reducing a final push for pathos to a limp shrug. Everyone appears at the mercy of shaky narrative foundations; even a cursory survey would suggest that whatever happened on this story’s journey to the screen, vital elements just didn’t take. You watch puzzled as – like the ageing pile at the story’s centre – the film flakes, moulders and crumbles before you.

• Gulabo Sitabo is available on Amazon Prime Video from 12 June.


Mike McCahill

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The Disciple review – Indian classical musician sings a lonely tune
Years of adherence to stringent rules leave a performer at odds with society in this melancholy film from India’s first Venice competitor for two decades

Xan Brooks

01, May, 2021 @9:47 AM

Article image
Salaam Bombay! review – still fiercely unsentimental and throbbing with energy
The re-release of Mira Nair’s unflinching 1988 story of street children, prostitutes and drug dealers shows it has lost none of its power

Peter Bradshaw

17, Jun, 2021 @6:00 AM

Article image
Kalank review – an opulent attempt to save the Bollywood melodrama
Abhishek Varman’s spares no expense in this tale of forbidden love – but heavenly visuals are marred by clunky storytelling

Mike McCahill

19, Apr, 2019 @11:00 AM

Article image
The Big City review – Satyajit Ray’s miraculous look at a new world of possibility
The struggles and triumphs of a 1950s Kolkata family whose highest earner is a woman is told with marvellous lucidity in an optimistic masterpiece

Peter Bradshaw

21, Jul, 2022 @6:00 AM

Article image
Pink review – subtle drama that grapples with India's rape culture
This story of a shaming campaign against three young Delhi women makes a powerful and progressive statement

Mike McCahill

15, Sep, 2016 @8:45 PM

Article image
Joyland review – subtle trans drama from Pakistan is remarkable debut
Saim Sadiq’s film explores the unsettled social and sexual identities of a widower and his children with delicacy and tenderness

Peter Bradshaw

22, Feb, 2023 @9:00 AM

Article image
Gurinder Chadha: My film has been wilfully misrepresented as anti-Muslim
The director of Viceroy’s House argues that her film about India’s partition of 1947, far from ignoring the freedom struggle, celebrates it

Gurinder Chadha

03, Mar, 2017 @5:53 PM

Article image
Gold review – shining drama of India's triumph on the hockey field
Reema Kagti’s stirring film celebrates the nation’s first post-independence Olympic medal at the 1948 Wembley Games

Mike McCahill

17, Aug, 2018 @7:00 AM

Article image
Love Sonia review – flawed but powerful sex-trafficking drama
Slumdog Millionaire producer Tabrez Noorani’s hard-hitting directorial debut is about an Indian village girl sold into slavery and shipped to California

Cath Clarke

25, Jan, 2019 @8:00 AM

Article image
Gehraiyaan review – Deepika Padukone mesmerises in a torrid drama
There are shades of 90s erotic thrillers in this enjoyable if overcooked tale of romantic dissatisfaction and infidelity

Phuong Le

11, Feb, 2022 @9:33 AM