In Her Hands review – all about the musical boy genius, again

A sulky young pianist is talent-spotted at a Paris station in this dull drama that is enlivened by Kristin Scott Thomas and the charismatic Karidja Touré

What is it about the classical music world – populated mostly by people with sophisticated tastes and exacting standards – that so often inspires film-makers to make sentimental, middlebrow schlock? Does it spring from some patronising if well-intentioned desire to make high art available to consumers of lower-browed forms, such as cinema? Or is that too many movies about classical music are made by people who barely understand the milieu, the music, or institutions that nourish them?

Watch the trailer for In Her Hands

Probably all of the above would explain this painfully programmatic twaddle about Mathieu, a sulky but high-cheek-boned kid from the Paris banlieues (Jules Benchetrit), who mostly hides his genius-level pianistic talent from his hood-rat friends and his family. However, his inability to resist tickling the ivories with some Bach on a public piano in the Gare du Nord catches the ear of Pierre Geithner (Lambert Wilson), the national conservatoire director.

In the first of a series of silly plot implausibilities, Geithner helps Mathieu stay out of jail by hooking him up with a janitorial job at said conservatoire, evoking the spectre of Good Will Hunting but with music instead of maths. Before long, Mathieu is taking lessons from an intimidating but immaculately coiffed piano teacher known only as the Countess (Kristin Scott Thomas), whose withering tongue disguises for her passion for music. But, of course, although she helps Mathieu perfect his technique, she can never match his passion – which makes him a true genius … or some nonsense like that.

Scott Thomas and Wilson add skilful shibori folds to this tissue-thin baloney, and almost succeed in making it bearable. Ultimately, however, the film’s greatest crime is wasting the talents of Karidja Touré, the intensely charismatic star of Céline Sciamma’s Girlhood, who gets lumbered with a standard-issue supportive-girlfriend part, compelling her to smile beatifically at all times over surly, dreary Mathieu. Despite being called In Your Hands in most countries outside France (the original title was Au Bout Des Doigts – At the End of the Fingers), the British title doesn’t make any sense, since none of the female characters’ agency is examined. Instead, it makes you wonder why a film couldn’t have been made about Touré’s character instead of another dull meditation on a young male “genius”.

In Her Hands is available on Curzon Home Cinema from 10 July.


Leslie Felperin

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
In Your Hands – review
Kristin Scott Thomas adds to her recent Francophone transgressive sex canon – but this one runs out of ideas, says Peter Bradshaw

Peter Bradshaw

19, Jul, 2012 @9:10 PM

Article image
In Safe Hands review – lives collide in intelligent adoption drama
In a welcome but heavy-handed tale, a fortysomething woman embarks on a momentous quest to bring a child into her home

Phil Hoad

29, May, 2019 @12:00 PM

Article image
The Disciple review – Indian classical musician sings a lonely tune
Years of adherence to stringent rules leave a performer at odds with society in this melancholy film from India’s first Venice competitor for two decades

Xan Brooks

01, May, 2021 @9:47 AM

Article image
God of the Piano review – icy family drama is a virtuoso debut
A family worships musical greatness above all else in Itay Tal’s film about a mother raising a pianist son under the scrutiny of her family

Cath Clarke

26, Jan, 2021 @10:01 AM

Article image
The Audition review – Nina Hoss is compelling in brutal classical music drama
Hoss plays a violin teacher under pressure in her personal and professional life as she begins work with a new student

Leslie Felperin

28, Mar, 2022 @2:00 PM

Article image
We Are from Jazz review – zany Russian musical comedy
In this entertaining fantasy from the Soviet era, a brilliant pianist is expelled from the music academy because of his passion for decadent American jazz

Peter Bradshaw

02, Jan, 2020 @10:00 AM

Article image
Love Crime – review

Kristin Scott Thomas and Ludivine Sagnier are compelling leads in a glossy French thriller, writes Philip French

Philip French

16, Dec, 2012 @12:01 AM

Article image
Happening review – cleverly structured and impeccably produced abortion drama
Winner at the Venice film festival, Audrey Diwan’s film captures the panic of an unwanted pregnancy before the legalisation of abortion in provincial France

Peter Bradshaw

20, Apr, 2022 @12:00 PM

Article image
Pacifiction review – trouble in paradise, in apocalyptic Tahitian mystery
Benoît Magimel’s French high commissioner confronts the end of his personal Eden in Tahiti, in Albert Serra’s distinctive film

Peter Bradshaw

26, May, 2022 @5:20 PM

Article image
Lost Illusions review – Balzac adaptation is period-drama perfection
Benjamin Voisin and Cécile de France star in a superb costume coming-of-age story for the Netflix generation

Peter Bradshaw

10, May, 2022 @12:00 PM