Why Joker should win the best picture Oscar

Superhero movies have saved Hollywood. And here’s one that features a magnetic star turn, takes mental illness seriously – and wrestles with the collapse of liberalism

Even if it doesn’t happen, it would be a good idea for Joker to be awarded the best picture Oscar – mostly because it would signal Hollywood’s acceptance of, and reconciliation with, the genre that has basically saved it over the last couple of decades: the superhero movie. Every year it seems the heavy guns get wheeled out to protest that the films which make everyone in Hollywood rich – and for which audiences appear to have inexhaustible affection – are slighted by the Academy and that they are owed recognition.

This year they might have a point. The portents may be suggesting that 1917 is in pole position to win the big one, but Joker has the lead in the nomination count (not always an infallible guide), and Joaquin Phoenix, by most measures, is the favourite to be named best actor.

More significantly, perhaps, the character himself is the most Oscar-friendly aspect of cinema’s various superhero universes. It can’t be a coincidence that the only previous occasion a superhero movie has troubled the winners enclosure for one of the headline categories was in 2009, when The Dark Knight’s Heath Ledger won best supporting actor – for playing the Joker. Grief over Ledger’s death may have been a factor, but there’s also something dramatically rich and tonally ambiguous about the character that responds to the alchemy of top-notch acting.

Wannabe king of comedy … Joker.
Wannabe king of comedy … Joker. Photograph: Niko Tavernise

That’s not something you could ever say of Batman, despite the heavyweights that have occupied the role; still less of the one-dimensional costume-hangers that populate the Marvel films. Most characters in superhero films are conceived around single-tic personalties connected to their superpower and/or activity, with a sledgehammer-sized neurosis in the background to try and give them some relationship to plausibility. Joker is very much part of this tradition; but somehow his forced grin and skirling laughter chime to a certain extent with real-life mental illness – in a way that, say, the Penguin doesn’t – even if its on-screen representation may be flawed.

Joker has also been hammered for its obvious borrowings from early Scorsese – not the least by the Guardian’s Peter Bradshaw – but I don’t see that as a problem: lots of films rip off others, borrow ideas and motifs. It’s what they do with them that counts. For my money, Phoenix and director Todd Phillips really succeed in creating the disquieting, grimy mood they aim for; if they hadn’t the film wouldn’t have been half as popular. Where it falls short is in the passages of street riots and disturbance: like, say, Fight Club, or V for Vendetta, it’s a film that underimagines the mechanics of actual social meltdown.

But more than any of that, Joker is the film that best represents the times we are in. Liberalism is on the retreat, and Joker is unabashed in trying to excavate its wobbling foundations. I don’t buy the idea that it’s not a political statement: films that go in for shallow sloganeering are never this acute. If it wins on Sunday, it’s what we’ll deserve.


Andrew Pulver

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Joaquin Phoenix responds to best actor Oscar with impassioned speech
Star of origin story for Batman supervillain takes top male acting prize at the Academy Awards

Andrew Pulver

10, Feb, 2020 @6:48 AM

Article image
Hollywood's gender divide laid bare by analysis of this season's Oscar contenders
Exclusive: Data on this year’s awards contenders reveals three youngest best actor hopefuls have never made a film with a female director

Katherine Purvis and Catherine Shoard

15, Nov, 2019 @3:38 PM

Article image
Why 1917 should win the best picture Oscar
We start our annual series with the frontrunner: Sam Mendes’s cinematic groundbreaker, which immerses us in the horror of war as never before

David Cox

28, Jan, 2020 @6:00 AM

Article image
Why Parasite should win the best picture Oscar
Bong Joon-ho’s tragicomic thriller is the dark horse of this year’s Oscars race. An exquisite piece of storytelling, this is classical film-making at its best

Simran Hans

03, Feb, 2020 @6:00 AM

Article image
Why Jojo Rabbit should win the best picture Oscar
Critics are divided on this whimsical satire about the Hitler Youth but ultimately it’s an uplifting movie about love trumping hate

Ann Lee

30, Jan, 2020 @6:00 AM

Article image
Why Little Women should win the best picture Oscar
Greta Gerwig’s remake of the classic is a clever balance of staying true to Louisa May Alcott and current feminism

Laura Snapes

29, Jan, 2020 @6:00 AM

Article image
Why The Irishman should win the best picture Oscar
Martin Scorsese has distilled a lifetime of expertise into this outstanding meditation on the mafia, ageing and the loss of agency

Peter Bradshaw

04, Feb, 2020 @6:00 AM

Article image
Why Marriage Story should win the best picture Oscar
Noah Baumbach’s film about divorce, starring Scarlett Johansson and Adam Driver, is unique: it is simultaneously sad and funny, mean and hilarious

Hadley Freeman

05, Feb, 2020 @6:00 AM

Article image
Why Ford v Ferrari should win the best picture Oscar
Christian Bale and Matt Damon are stellar in this motor-sport drama, an ode to petrolheads, grease-monkeys and the 60s – and audiences love it

Paul MacInnes

31, Jan, 2020 @6:00 AM

Article image
Parasite's brilliant win is a portent of change in the conceited Hollywood club | Peter Bradshaw
The Academy has finally caught up with the outside world – its task now is to avoid returning to its insular ways

Peter Bradshaw

10, Feb, 2020 @6:45 AM