Harvey Weinstein trial: witness details complex relationship with ex-producer

Rape trial continued with cross-examination of accuser who suffered a panic attack under questioning on Monday

The dramatic rape trial of Harvey Weinstein continued on Tuesday with the cross-examination of an accuser who suffered a panic attack under questioning the day before.

The 34-year-old witness alleges she was violently raped twice by the film producer in 2013. Her claims form a central pillar of the prosecution’s case.

The Guardian is not naming the witness because she has not indicated publicly if she is happy to be identified.

Her time in the witness stand was cut short on Monday afternoon after Donna Rotunno, Weinstein’s lead lawyer, instructed her to read an email she wrote to her boyfriend in May 2014 about her relationship with Weinstein. The witness began to cry uncontrollably.

By lunchtime on Tuesday the woman had been through several hours of cross-examination by Rotunno, who has tried to paint her as a serial liar who manipulated Weinstein, 67, in order to advance her career in the film industry.

The witness described Weinstein as the manipulative one. She said she looked up to him like a father figure and had a complex relationship with him, in which she would be on the receiving end of his fluctuating emotions. She said he raped her twice, though she and Weinstein also had a number of consensual sexual encounters.

The charges against Weinstein stem from this accusation and that of Miriam Haley, who has testified that he assaulted her in 2006. Weinstein faces five counts: two of rape, one of forcibly performing oral sex on a woman and two of predatory sexual assault. Facing a maximum sentence of life in prison, he has denied all charges.

Rotunno is a veteran attorney of sexual assault cases known for aggressively defending men accused of assault. Her hardline tactics could be seen throughout her cross-examination of the second witness.

“You manipulated Mr Weinstein every single time you saw him, isn’t that correct?” she said, in a barrage of questioning on Monday. “Every time you engaged in consensual sexual encounters with him you manipulated him, isn’t that correct? You made him feel you wanted sexual relations with him.”

The witness replied: “No, that is not correct.”

A witness testifies in a courtroom sketch at Harvey Weinstein’s trial in New York, New York, on 4 February.
A witness testifies in a courtroom sketch at Harvey Weinstein’s trial in New York, New York, on 4 February. Photograph: Jane Rosenberg/Reuters

On Tuesday morning, the witness walked into court looking dazed, her eyes puffy, a bright orange stress ball in her hand. Throughout the morning her responses were soft, mumbled into a microphone.

The defense continued to paint a picture of a transactional relationship where the witness agreed to meet Weinstein and initiated meetings herself. In return, it said, Weinstein invited her to exclusive premieres and parties.

Rotunno showed for the jury several friendly emails between Weinstein and the witness from 2014 through 2016. They showed the witness reaching out multiple times, asking if Weinstein was in Los Angeles and wanted to meet up. Weinstein’s responses, Rotunno noted, were cordial.

She pointed to two instances documented by email in which the witness went to Weinstein for help. In the first she asked if he could help her and her “boss” get a membership at Soho House, a members-only club in New York. In the other instance, the witness reached out regarding trouble she was having with her car registration.

“So the person you wanted to sponsor you to this exclusive club is your rapist?” Rotunno asked.

The witness turned to the jury and said: “I do want [you] to know that he is my rapist and I can continue to explain.”

Rotunno also brought up occasions where Weinstein invited the witness to parties for award shows and premieres. Emails from the witness showed she accepted invitations and asked to bring friends.

Before the witness took the stand, Emanuela Postacchini, an actor based in Los Angeles, was called to testify.

The main witness said Weinstein invited her to a hotel room in New York where, after a short period, Postacchini was brought in too. Weinstein asked them both to undress and began telling them what to do.

The witness described how, upon seeing how uncomfortable Postacchini seemed, she ran into the bathroom and began to “crying and crying and I was completely overwhelmed by it”. She said Postacchini ran after her to console her.

Postachinni said she could not recall any details about what Weinstein asked them to do, but said she remembered the witness “was in a fetal position on the ground, crying” and recalled trying to console her. She said she did not remember what happened after that.

Damon Cheronis, a Weinstein lawyer, asked if the situation was “forced”. Postacchini paused and said the situation was not forced.

She later said that while it was not forced, she felt she had been “manipulated” because she was invited to the hotel room and did not expect to see another woman there.

“I felt tricked by that,” Postacchini said.

In response, Cheronis showed the jury emails Postacchini sent Weinstein, showing the two had remained amicable.

Later in the afternoon, the jury was shown official photographs taken by the district attorney’s office of Weinstein’s body. The witness has previously testified about the appearance of his genitals.

The case continues.

Additional reporting by Ed Pilkington

  • In the US, Rainn offers support at 800-656-4673 or by chat at Rainn.org. In the UK, the rape crisis national freephone helpline is at 0808-802-9999. In Australia, support is available at 1800Respect (1800-737-7328) or 1800respect.org.au. Other international helplines can be found at Ibiblio.org.


Lauren Aratani in New York

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Harvey Weinstein trial: how finding an impartial jury became a spectacle
A surprise appearance from Gigi Hadid, the threat of prison for an ill-judged tweet and protests have plagued jury selection

Lauren Aratani in New York

18, Jan, 2020 @8:30 AM

Article image
Harvey Weinstein trial: accuser described alleged assault to roommate
Former roommate of Miriam Haley, one of two accusers at sex crimes trial, says Haley described alleged attack after it happened

Ed Pilkington in New York

28, Jan, 2020 @6:05 PM

Article image
Weinstein set to face his toughest legal challenge yet in New York trial
The trial, which begins 6 January, will include testimony from two alleged victims and Annabella Sciorra amid concerns he may not be ultimately held legally accountable

Lucia Graves

05, Jan, 2020 @7:00 AM

Article image
‘His reputation will never recover’: the rape trial that took down Harvey Weinstein
The guilty verdict means that the movie career of one of the most powerful men in Hollywood is almost certainly over

Lucia Graves

24, Feb, 2020 @4:49 PM

Article image
Gigi Hadid dismissed as juror in Harvey Weinstein trial
Weinstein’s legal team wrote in a motion that the model was friends with Cara Delevingne, who has accused him of misconduct

Ed Pilkington in New York

16, Jan, 2020 @4:42 PM

Article image
Harvey Weinstein accusers gather in solidarity to mark start of trial
Rose McGowan and Rosanna Arquette among those outside the courthouse to support alleged victims who will take the stand

Lauren Aratani in New York

06, Jan, 2020 @10:17 PM

Article image
Harvey Weinstein trial to kick off two years after lighting fire under #MeToo
Former film producer will finally be confronted in court with allegations he raped and sexually assaulted multiple women

Ed Pilkington in New York

22, Jan, 2020 @6:30 AM

Article image
What is Harvey Weinstein charged with – and what happens next?
The movie mogul could spent up to 25 years in prison, and officials have said they may add to the charges

Edward Helmore in New York

25, May, 2018 @5:24 PM

Article image
Harvey Weinstein: judge allows sex trafficking case to move to trial
New York judge says Weinstein may have broken sex trafficking law in potential landmark case brought by British actor Kadian Noble

Erin Durkin and agencies

14, Aug, 2018 @5:25 PM

Article image
Harvey Weinstein trial is 'not a referendum on #MeToo', says judge
James Burke issued directive as jury selection entered its final stage on Thursday

Ed Pilkington in New York

16, Jan, 2020 @7:36 PM