Prince William's ticking off means Bafta must get serious about diversity

Bafta seeks to project the image of a global, inclusive institution but the reality suggests it is guided by outdated traditions and prejudices

Bafta likes to think of itself as a cut above its American counterparts, in terms of classiness at least, if not actual importance. Our world-beating film industry might have blurred into Hollywood more than we would like to admit, but I think you’ll find we Brits invented the “black tie” dress code. And the president of our esteemed institution is the second in line to the throne, no less. And we’ve got the Royal Albert Hall. Beat that, “Hollywood royalty”.

But when Bafta’s royal figurehead is giving the institution a royal ticking off, you know they’ve got problems. At Sunday’s ceremony, Prince William addressed the elephant in the hall: the overwhelming whiteness and maleness of this year’s nominees. His speech was surprisingly direct: “In 2020, and not for the first time in the last few years, we find ourselves talking again about the need to do more to ensure diversity in the sector and in the awards process – that simply cannot be right in this day and age.”

Considering the house of Windsor’s own issues embracing diversity lately, Prince William’s comments could put him in contention for the “biggest stone thrown from glassiest house” award. More than one presenter slipped in a gag about “Megxit”. Meanwhile, Rebel Wilson’s line about the “Royal Andrew Hall” had Wills and Kate squirming in their seats. Like the royal family, and perhaps post-Brexit Britain itself, the words and the deeds aren’t quite aligning for Bafta. While it seeks to project the image of a modern, global, inclusive institution, the reality suggests something altogether more insular, guided by outdated traditions and prejudices. Ironic that the trophy itself is shaped like a mask.

No disrespect to Sam Mendes’s 1917, which won best film, best British film and best director, but it is exactly the kind of movie that pushes Bafta’s buttons: well-trodden British history done with a twist, filled with familiar faces (predominantly of the white male variety), cursory nod to representation with the inclusion of a Sikh character. Arguably, it has not been a vintage year for performances by actors of colour, especially in British cinema, although this a bit of a Catch-22 argument – diverse talent won’t flourish if Bafta doesn’t recognise it; Bafta can’t recognise diverse talent if it isn’t there. But how to account for the lack of love for Joanna Hogg’s The Souvenir, a quintessentially British drama of the highest order and Sight & Sound magazine’s best film of 2019. It received not a single nomination, not even in the outstanding British film category, which raises serious questions about how cine-literate the membership of this esteemed institution really is.

Even the introduction of a Bafta for casting this year backfired somewhat. Casting is one area of the industry where women traditionally dominate – which could go some way to explaining why it never had an award of its own before. Bafta had an opportunity to really make a statement here, since the boldest nominee on the list was The Personal History of David Copperfield, a movie whose radical colour-blind casting both reinvigorated a familiar old story and reflected the very modern, multicultural Britain Bafta is always banging on about. Instead, the winner on the night was … Joker.

Once again, hands will be wrung and fingers pointed. In response to this year’s debacle, Prince William announced, Bafta had launched “a full and thorough review of the entire awards process”. It has done this before. In 2016, Bafta set new diversity criteria for its British film and writer categories, intended to encourage inclusion on screen and off. Clearly they’re not working yet. And certainly there are deeper structural problems behind British cinema’s lack of diversity than just the awards.

Modernising doesn’t happen overnight. But in today’s Britain it’s becoming less a question of rates of progress as how much we really want it at all.


Steve Rose

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Baftas 2020: who will win – and who should win
The run-up to this year’s Baftas have proved unusually controversial, but what will actually happen on the night? Here’s what we think

Peter Bradshaw

01, Feb, 2020 @1:02 PM

Article image
The full list of winners at the 2020 Bafta film awards
All the prizes – including the new one for best casting – at the 73rd British Academy film awards

Guardian film

02, Feb, 2020 @9:05 PM

Article image
The Souvenir leads nominations for London critics' circle film awards
Joanna Hogg’s autobiographical relationship drama has seven nominations, ahead of Martin Scorsese’s mob epic The Irishman and Sam Mendes’ war movie 1917

Andrew Pulver

17, Dec, 2019 @2:53 PM

Article image
White, male and boring: diversity row should make Bafta look in the mirror
This year’s outrageous crop of overwhelmingly white Bafta nominations shows that the academy needs to act now to make its members more diverse

Simran Hans

07, Jan, 2020 @3:57 PM

Article image
Baftas 2020: Sam Mendes and 1917 emerge victorious with seven awards
Mendes’s harrowing first world war movie takes best film and best director, while Joaquin Phoenix and Renée Zellweger win the top acting prizes

Mark Brown and Lanre Bakare

02, Feb, 2020 @9:42 PM

Article image
Prince William's Baftas tirade was insultingly misdirected – he should resign as its president | David Cox
Is the Duke of Cambridge sabotaging the voting system? Or simply saving face by attacking an acceptable – if innocent – party?

David Cox

06, Feb, 2020 @1:04 PM

Article image
Colossally overrated Joker beneficiary of Bafta awards groupthink | Peter Bradshaw
Supervillain origin story crowding out better films, while the lack of diversity in the acting categories is infuriating

Peter Bradshaw

07, Jan, 2020 @10:42 AM

Article image
A weaponised hell-run of selfie-taking: my journey into the heart of the Baftas | Stuart Heritage
Surely the Baftas couldn’t be as bad as they look on TV? The Guardian’s intrepid reporter hit the red carpet to find out

Stuart Heritage

03, Feb, 2020 @4:59 PM

Article image
Bafta changes rules to increase diversity in awards and membership
Moves mean British film and outstanding debut nominees must show they have boosted opportunities for ethnic minority and socially disadvantaged film-makers

Andrew Pulver

14, Dec, 2016 @12:27 PM

Article image
Baftas 2020: 1917 and Joaquin Phoenix triumph – as it happened
It’s the biggest night of the year in British cinema. Join us to find out who wore what, whether incoming host Graham Norton managed to make us forget the horror of Joanna Lumley – and who won this year’s prizes

Alex Needham, Lauren Cochrane and Ellie Violet Bramley

03, Feb, 2020 @12:00 AM