Rose Plays Julie review – eerie, edge-of-your-seat suspense

This uncanny and transgressive film about a young woman who tracks down her birth parents is Christine Molloy and Joe Lawlor’s best work yet

Writer-directors Christine Molloy and Joe Lawlor have created their best work yet: an eerie and uncanny movie shot with cool blankness and emotional distance, a meditation on the themes they have already explored in earlier movies such as Helen (2008) and Mister John (2013) – ideas about double lives, impersonations, alternative existences and identities. But Rose Plays Julie has much more dramatic solidity and punch. Whereas some of their earlier work, however intriguing, sometimes looked like melting away into the mist, this film grabs you by the throat.

The drama begins by seeming to be hardly more than a poignant evocation of loneliness and regret. Then it escalates into an edge-of-the-seat suspense thriller of the sort that Chabrol might have admired, or even something written by Joe Eszterhas that you could have rented on VHS some time in the 80s. Yet even Eszterhas might have have flinched at the pure transgression of what is being implied. And by the end, it’s got something very real to say about #MeToo issues. There is scope for disagreement about the final balance of thriller and real-world drama, and some unresolved plot-plausibility implications, but there is no doubt about the chillingly accumulated potency and force of this movie, or the quality of the performances.

It is a story about two women, one younger and one older. Rose (Ann Skelly) is a veterinary student with an inscrutable, watchful manner, who has recently found out she was adopted and has discovered the identity of her birth mother. This is Ellen (Orla Brady), a very successful TV actor whom Rose begins to stalk online. Discovering that Ellen is selling her house, Rose poses as a buyer and manages to gain access to the property and talk to her, revealing who she is.

The confrontation is traumatic: having come through some tough times, and having now made a real success of herself, with a family of her own, Ellen does not want to rake up a painful past. But finally, she will reveal that the past is even more painful than Rose could have imagined. Then Rose begins to seek out her real father, Peter, a celebrity archaeologist played by Aidan Gillen, and she does so with a fake name – “Julie” – and, somehow inspired by Ellen’s profession, disguises herself with a wig. She is playing a very dangerous game, teetering on an abyss of horror.

Metaphorical possibility is everywhere about. Archaeology, and the digging up of the past, is an obvious example. There is also the grim subject Rose happens to be studying in her veterinary classes: the euthanasia of animals, and the ethically tricky business of euthanising healthy animals. We see what Rose sees: animals being wheeled in, killed and then dissected. At first, these scenes, clinically filmed with a lack of immediate emotional content, seem to be pointing to the disconnectedness and alienation in Rose’s heart. But there is also a real plot point to it all.

The most prominent metaphor is of course acting: Ellen has been acting ever since Rose’s birth, acting the part of someone who hasn’t been hurt, acting the part of someone who is a success inside and out, acting the part of someone who doesn’t care about her daughter. And it is only now that she can cast off the theatrical costume of pretence.

It is a really powerful film and Brady’s final dialogue scene exerts a lethal grip.

• Rose Plays Julie is released on 17 September in cinemas.


Peter Bradshaw

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Incitement: the film about the man who murdered the Israeli peace process
The makers of a controversial new film about the assassination of prime minister Yitzhak Rabin describe their conversations with the killer, Yigal Amir

Anne Joseph

11, Oct, 2019 @6:00 AM

Article image
'Of course Marvel is cinema!' Why the Scorsese backlash is justified
Kevin Smith, Taika Waititi and James Gunn reject veteran film-maker’s dismissal of superhero movies as ‘theme park’ fare – while his output exposes a debt to spectacle and innovation

Ben Child

17, Oct, 2019 @11:32 AM

Article image
The Personal History of David Copperfield review – Iannucci relishes the absurdity
The London film festival opened with Armando Iannucci’s larger-than-life adaptation of the Dickens crowdpleaser, starring Dev Patel as Copperfield

Peter Bradshaw

02, Oct, 2019 @3:19 PM

Article image
Citizen K review – strange tale of the oligarch who became Putin's nemesis
Alex Gibney’s absorbing new documentary about Mikhail Khodorkovsky charts the Russian businessman’s transformation from plutocrat to political dissident

Peter Bradshaw

03, Oct, 2019 @7:00 AM

Article image
Beanpole review – Russians pay a bitter price for survival
Kantemir Balagov brilliantly deploys shock tactics to weigh the horrors of peace against the trauma of war in 1945 Leningrad

Peter Bradshaw

11, Oct, 2019 @2:19 PM

Article image
Azor review – eerie conspiracy thriller about the complacency of the super-rich
Andreas Fontana’s debut feature is an unnervingly subtle drama about a Swiss private banker visiting clients in Argentina during the period of the military junta and ‘disappearances’

Peter Bradshaw

13, Oct, 2021 @9:40 PM

Article image
Robert De Niro on Donald Trump: 'I can't wait to see him in jail'
The Irishman actor tells the Guardian that Trump and the Republicans ‘have to know they can’t get away with bullying us’

Andrew Pulver and agencies

11, Oct, 2019 @2:26 PM

Article image
Martin Scorsese defends decision to make deal with Netflix for The Irishman
Director says no one else in Hollywood would back his new film The Irishman after costs soared due to pioneering ‘de-aging’ technology

Andrew Pulver

13, Oct, 2019 @3:30 PM

Article image
'Audiences won’t have seen anything like this': how Iranian film Chess of the Wind was reborn
Mohammad Reza Aslani’s gothic family thriller was banned in Iran and presumed lost, only to be found years later in a junk shop. Now it’s showing at the BFI London film festival

John Harris Dunning

30, Sep, 2020 @7:00 AM

Article image
Armando Iannucci's David Copperfield film to open London film festival
Dickens adaptation starring Dev Patel alongside Tilda Swinton, Hugh Laurie and Peter Capaldi will have its European festival in capital in October

Catherine Shoard

16, Jul, 2019 @7:00 AM