Show Dogs under fire for scene which 'grooms children for sexual abuse'

Rottweiler groping in family comedy normalises ‘unwanted genital touching to its child audience’, according to US’s National Center on Sexual Exploitation

Show Dogs, a new family comedy about a police hound who goes undercover to infiltrate a dog show, has come in for criticism over a scene which some feel sends a troubling message to impressionable audiences.

In a statement on Tuesday, the National Center on Sexual Exploitation (NCOSE) says a scene in which Max (voiced by the actor-rapper Ludacris) is instructed to put his discomfort over genital groping to one side and instead “go to a zen place” sends “a troubling message that grooms children for sexual abuse”.

The movie concerns the case of a stolen baby panda, which leads Max, a talking Rottweiler, to team up with human FBI agent played by Will Arnett. Their covert mission means Max learns what it takes to be a dog show champion, by way of pedicures, Botox, waxing and tolerating the judges checking his genitals.

Dawn Hawkins, the executive director of the NCOSE, said her organisation objects to “multiple scenes where a dog character must have its private parts inspected, in the course of which the dog is uncomfortable and wants to stop but is told to go to a ‘zen place’.

“The dog is rewarded with advancing to the final round of the dog show after passing this barrier. Disturbingly, these are similar tactics child abusers use when grooming children: telling them to pretend they are somewhere else and that they will get a reward for withstanding their discomfort.

“Children’s movies must be held to a higher standard, and must teach children bodily autonomy, the ability to say ‘no’ and safety – not confusing messages endorsing unwanted genital touching.”

The organisation has asked Global Road Entertainment, which co-produced and co-financed the film with Riverstone Pictures, to halt the film’s release until it can be recut.

But Global Road has defended the film by saying such touching is common practice in dog shows. “The dog show judging in this film is depicted completely accurately as done at shows around the world, and was performed by professional and highly respected dog show judges,” they said in a statement to CNN.

“Global Road Entertainment and the film-makers are saddened and apologise to any parent who feels the scene sends a message other than a comedic moment in the film, with no hidden or ulterior meaning, but respect their right to react to any piece of content.”

In a statement released on Wednesday, the British Board of Film Classification appeared to concur with Global. “[T]he scenes in question are entirely innocent and non-sexual and occur within the clear context of preparation for and judging in a dog show,” they wrote. “We regard the comments made about the film as suggesting ‘grooming’ as a misinterpretation of the scenes in question.”

In the UK, Show Dogs carries a Parental Guidance rating for “mild bad language, rude humour and violence”. In the US, it carries the same rating.

Max Botkin, one of the film’s chief writers, denies penning the scene in question, saying that his original script was “heavily rewritten by 13 other writers”, 12 of whom are uncredited.

Botkin was not a part of the rewrite process and “didn’t get to see the film until it was in its final stage of completion, and had zero say in creative choices the second I signed away the rights to my work”.In a statement he wrote: “I absolutely condemn any suggestion or act of non-consensual touching in any form, as well as disassociation as a coping mechanism for abuse of any kind. I understand and empathise with the parents’ and groups’ concerns regarding the message the movie may impart.”

Concerned bodies have taken to Twitter to express their scepticism about the scene.

“This is letting a movie of funny cartoon dogs teach our kids that hey, “sometimes ya just gotta let someone molest you”

A kids movie critic explains why this movie “Show Dogs” sends a message about “grooming” & 2 keeps kids from watching#OpChildSafety

— #OpChildSafety (@_OpCS__) May 22, 2018

Warning: New Kids Movie 'Show Dogs' Grooms Children for Sexual Abuse, Survivors Say

— Parenting by PJM (@PJ_Parenting) May 21, 2018

PSA DO NOT GO TO OR SUPPORT THE MOVIE “Show Dogs”. ***IT NORMALIZES SEXUAL ABUSE*** spread the word, I know many parents who would have no idea because it’s portrayed as kid-friendly & rated PG. This is just not okay.

— lucinda (@lucindasowards) May 20, 2018

Notices in the mainstream US media have so far been less outraged. In a review for Variety, Nick Schager said found the film age-appropriate, writing: “Max’s transformation necessitates getting his rear end waxed and learning to stay completely still when his private parts are inspected.

“Along with a blast of canine flatulence, those bits are aimed squarely at preschool viewers who still think bathroom and crotch jokes are the apex of hilarity.” Meanwhile, the New York Times’s critic bemoaned the gendered stereotyping, but did not mention the scene in question.

London’s Daily Telegraph critic Tim Robey said he went into Tuesday’s press screening aware of the controversy. “Even so, it’s just so bizarre when the dog goes to this zen place in the sky, frolicking around with his owner among the stars, oblivious to this hand on his balls – like any good dog should be.”

The Guardian’s reviewer, Mike McCahill, wrote that he found the focus surprising but not especially troubling: “No film in motion picture history can ever have made more fuss about the state of one canine’s anus.”


Catherine Shoard

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The Queen’s Corgi review – palace pooch in the doghouse
Jack Whitehall voices a disgraced doggie who ends up joining a canine fight club in this mirthless animated caper

Mike McCahill

05, Jul, 2019 @6:00 AM

Article image
Dogtanian and the Three Muskehounds review – delightfully retro canine capers
Alexandre Dumas’ bitingly good novel enjoys yet another walk around the block in this marvellously muttish animation

Leslie Felperin

24, Jun, 2021 @2:05 PM

Article image
A Dog’s Journey review – corny canine caper
Bailey the body-hopping hound bounds back in this unashamed agglomeration of poop jokes and puppy eyes

Mike McCahill

03, May, 2019 @9:00 AM

Article image
Show Dogs review – canine caper that's as ruff as they come
This tale of talking mutts, voiced by minor celebrities, is a mirthlessly cynical cinematic chew toy

Mike McCahill

25, May, 2018 @5:00 AM

Article image
Strays review – Will Ferrell leads brutally funny comedy of foul-mouthed talking dogs
With turns from Ferrell and Jamie Foxx, this barking stoner caper follows a neglected animal plotting revenge on a beastly owner

Peter Bradshaw

17, Aug, 2023 @7:00 AM

Article image
How can you prevent dogs jumping at children? How should I respond when it happens?
The long-running series in which readers answer other readers’ questions on subjects ranging from trivial flights of fancy to profound scientific and philosophical concepts

27, Jul, 2021 @11:00 AM

Article image
Cinema may be going to the dogs, but at least dogs are going to the cinema
Booming canine audiences are defying the downward trend elsewhere in movieland. Never mind Paw Patrol, get ready for Barkenheimer

Stuart Heritage

27, Sep, 2023 @10:47 AM

Article image
The Art of Racing in the Rain review – Kevin Costner as a lovable pup
Costner voices the inner monologue of a golden retriever in this three-hankie weeper with Milo Ventimiglia and Amanda Seyfried

Peter Bradshaw

08, Aug, 2019 @6:00 AM

Article image
Watch the fur fly: why cat films are better than dog films
Films with cats are cool and mysterious. Mutt movies are a soppy wet lick to the face. No surprise then which Hollywood favours

Ellen E Jones

28, Jun, 2017 @9:43 AM

Article image
23 Walks review – dog-lovers follow the path to romance
In this warm and kindly drama, Alison Steadman and Dave Johns play a couple brought together by their daily perambulations with pooches

Leslie Felperin

24, Sep, 2020 @4:00 PM