The Venerable W review – the poisonous monk behind Myanmar's anti-Muslim vendetta

This intimate documentary on Ashin Wirathu, the Buddhist fanatic whose ideas have brought down Aung Sun Suu Kyi, is a bleak study of sectarianism by Barbet Schroeder



Barbet Schroeder’s overpoweringly bleak documentary about the Buddhist monk stirring up ethnic hate against Myanmar’s Rohingya Muslims is the third in what has now emerged as his “trilogy of evil” – a trio of disquieting documentaries of which the first two were General Idi Amin Dada in 1974 and Terror’s Advocate in 2007 about the genial, cigar-smoking Jacques Vergès, lawyer for Klaus Barbie.

The Venerable W delivers a nauseous, almost black-comic jab at any liberal who fondly believed that Buddhism and Buddhists somehow float ethereally free of the sectarianism and bigotry that infect any other religion. And it also emerges as a devastating indictment of someone who is not its subject and appears only briefly: Aung San Suu Kyi, the leader who is now increasingly resembling a passive-aggressive Eva Perón, or perhaps a Mother Teresa, but the way Christopher Hitchens considered her: as a self-important matriarch of nationalism.

It is actually about Ashin Wirathu, an orange-clad Buddhist monk with a mass following, who despite a bland and almost torpid manner is a fanatical anti-Muslim activist, using social media and unceasing programmes of public speaking and DVD propaganda to stir up violent hate against the Rohingya Muslims – claiming that they are a Saudi-backed Bangladeshi insurgency whose purpose is to infiltrate the country, destroy Myanmar’s traditional Buddhism and establish a caliphate. At this monk’s instigation, Rohingyas have their villages burned and they are harassed, beaten and killed. Wirathu himself drops his quiet mannerisms at the end of the film, for a raucous speech calling the UN human rights envoy Yanghee Lee a “whore” and for an acid interview mocking Angela Merkel. Time magazine ran a cover story about Wirathu in 2013, but Schroeder’s movie gives a more substantial, and stomach-turningly intimate study of the man, even more relevant now that Aung San Suu Kyi’s fall from grace has focused attention on Myanmar’s sectarianism.

Schroeder’s film persuasively points out that Rohingya persecution is nothing new. The government’s Operation King Dragon carried out similar actions in the late 1970s: ostensibly a counter-insurgency, but more resembling a pogrom, fuelled by the conviction that the territory bordering Bangladesh is rich in mineral deposits. Beating up and killing the Muslim minority is a traditional risk-free way of reaffirming Myanmar’s embattled statehood. And the country’s Buddhist monks are a willing civilian militia.

There are gruesome images of violence in this film which reminded me of Josh Oppenheimer’s The Act of Killing (2012) and The Look of Silence (2014), about the brutal mass slaughter in Indonesia, or perhaps Matthew Heineman’s City of Ghosts (2017) about Isis in Raqqa.

So is this film more evidence that we are reliving the 1930s? Actually, it put me in mind of the 1990s. This preposterously poisonous monk reminded me of the Belgian-born journalist and radio announcer Georges Ruggiu whose inflammatory broadcasts in Rwanda against the Tutsis were a very substantial cause of the massacres. Like Wirathu, there is the same touch of pure irrational malevolence, something that does not have a political or ideological explanation. Maybe it’s a clinical pathology. Nationalist fever could simply be a pretext for a bacchanal of violence. And of course there is the example of the Bosnian genocide: mass killings in the very midst of Europe, where “never again” had been a political mantra for four decades.

There is the same paranoia over territory and the same self-pitying overdog victimhood – beating up a smaller minority, and claiming that they are in fact the larger force, backed by foreigners. Wirathu even deploys an outrageous “false flag” claim: that Rohingyas are setting fire to their own villagers to get international support. Maybe Wirathu had studied the Serbs’ PR in the 1990s: they used to say that the Muslims were bombing their own positions in Sarajevo.

The Venerable W does not explicitly debate the existence of evil as such, but it certainly argues that nationalism, ignorance, arrogance, dogmatic religion and fear are its constituent elements. This is a sombre, pessimistic but necessary film.

Contributor

Peter Bradshaw

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
No vote, no candidates: Myanmar's Muslims barred from their own election
As the country prepares for crucial polls, millions of Muslims are being denied the chance to vote for the candidates of their choice

Poppy McPherson in Mandalay

03, Nov, 2015 @1:39 AM

Article image
I Am Rohingya: A Genocide in Four Acts review – youthful counterblast to oppression
A group of refugees from Myanmar, living in Canada, make a stage show of their traumatic experiences in Yusuf Zine’s deliberately upbeat documentary

Mike McCahill

13, Mar, 2019 @6:00 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on Pope Francis and the Rohingya: call them by their name | Editorial
Editorial: The pope has condemned the ethnic cleansing of the Rohingya. But on his visit to Myanmar he has been urged not even to mention them by name. He should speak out

Editorial

27, Nov, 2017 @6:57 PM

Article image
'No Muslims allowed': how nationalism is rising in Aung San Suu Kyi's Myanmar
Concerns grow that Buddhist extremism may flourish unless country’s new democratic leaders counter discrimination against minorities

Poppy McPherson

23, May, 2016 @2:11 AM

Article image
78/52 review – Hitchcock's Psycho shower scene gets an expert autopsy
An array of film-makers and writers line up to praise the skill of the iconic sequence – but leave the trickier issues frustratingly unaddressed

Peter Bradshaw

13, Oct, 2017 @11:00 AM

Article image
Apostasy review – faith and fellowship in potent account of hidden world of Jehovah's Witnesses
Daniel Kokotajlo’s debut about life among a religious community in Oldham is authentic, sensitive and subtle but has a sledgehammer narrative punch

Peter Bradshaw

09, Oct, 2017 @1:49 PM

Article image
No Stone Unturned review – murky aftermath of Northern Ireland massacre
Alex Gibney’s dogged documentary on the murder of six Catholics during the Troubles will help the victims’ families but fails to expose the cover-up

Peter Bradshaw

06, Oct, 2017 @10:53 AM

Article image
The Kingdom of Us review – knotty chronicle of family defined by single traumatic event
When Paul Shanks killed himself in 2007, he left behind seven children and his wife Vikie. Lucy Cohen’s sensitive documentary shows how they are coping

Andrew Pulver

08, Oct, 2017 @1:30 PM

Article image
‘It only takes one terrorist’: the Buddhist monk who reviles Myanmar’s Muslims | Marella Oppenheim
Critics of Ashin Wirathu and his denim-clad disciples say the monk incites racial violence against Rohingya refugees. He claims he is merely protecting his people

Marella Oppenheim

12, May, 2017 @1:46 PM

Article image
Indie rockers Side Effect channel the resilient spirit of Myanmar's youth
They once worked in fear of Myanmar’s military government. Now one of the country’s most feted bands are pushing ever harder for expressive freedom

Fran McElhone

14, Sep, 2018 @6:00 AM