A lurid tale of vengeance and lust, set against the backdrop of the American west at the end of the 19th century, Brimstone stars Dakota Fanning as a mute woman persecuted by a preacher (Guy Pearce) who is determined to destroy her and everything she holds dear. Although the four-chapter structure is neatly handled and the savage backdrop strikingly photographed, there’s something a little unsavoury about this picture. It’s not the graphic violence, rape, incest and numerous shots of women being bound and flogged that are the problems, as such. It’s the hint of tumescence behind the camera accompanying these scenes that gives the whole picture a queasily sensationalist quality.
Brimstone review – queasily sensationalist
Wendy Ide
This strikingly photographed story of a vengeful preacher and his victims in America’s old west revels too much in its savagery towards women
Contributor
Wendy Ide
Wendy Ide is the Observer's chief film critic
Wendy Ide
The GuardianTramp