God's Own Country review – Dales answer to Brokeback that's a very British love story

This Yorkshire-set story about a relationship between a farmer and an immigrant worker is a beautifully judged, unsentimental study from first time director Francis Lee

This debut feature from Yorkshire-born actor and first-time director Francis Lee is tough, sensual, unsentimental, with excellent lead performances from Josh O’Connor and Alec Secareanu. Johnny (O’Connor) is the unhappy, angry young guy working on the family farm, dulling his emotional pain with drink and casual sex; Gheorghe (Secareanu) is a hired hand from Romania brought in for a few weeks. They give tremendous performances – and Gemma Jones and Ian Hart are both very good in the supporting roles as Johnny’s grandmother and father, stoic and tightlipped by temperament and repressed by years of work and responsibility, and in his father’s case by the aftermath of a stroke.

It is almost – but not quite – a Dales Brokeback, a love story which does not exist in quite as much of a homophobic context as the classic Ang Lee movie and Annie Proulx story, and which does not require two female partners to exist in respective states of denial. (In fact, the storyline and its bucolic setting are rather more similar to Catherine Corsini’s recent French film La Belle Saison, or Summertime.) It is, in its way, a very British love story, bursting at the seams with unspoken emotions, unvoiced fears about the future, and a readiness to displace every emotion into hard physical work.

Lee follows in the path of British films like Duane Hopkins’s Better Things and Andrea Arnold’s Wuthering Heights, or even Peter Hall’s 70s classic Akenfield: films which show that the countryside is not a bland picturesque place, gentle and calming. It is fierce, lonely and strange: qualities which echo with the people who live there. There is an unsparingly tough scene in which Gheorghe skins a dead lamb so that the pelt can be laid upon another one so that the dead animal’s mother will give it milk: a classic piece of country lore, unselfconsciously presented.

Johnny is a borderline alcoholic with a perpetually bleary face, almost asymmetric with hungover agony. All his friends from school have gone off to uni, including Robyn, who teases him about his morose attitude when she sees him down the pub – a nice performance from Patsy Ferran. But Johnny has had to stay behind to help look after the farm when his widowed father (Hart) was affected by a stroke. And what does he live for, now? When he is in town for livestock auctions, Johnny has fleeting sexual encounters with people he meets there: Lee coolly places one such liaison after a scene in which Johnny has made a manual examination of a cow with an antiseptically lubricated plastic gauntlet. We are far from James Herriot country.

Things change when Gheorghe arrives: a thoughtful, watchful young man who calmly submits to the squalor and hardship of living in a grim caravan in the yard. But Gheorghe is a good worker and he has ideas: he asks the family if they have considered making sheep’s cheese from the milk, a possible lucrative sideline. They hadn’t. Gheorghe and Johnny have to spend nights away from the farmbuilding up in the hills repairing a dry stone wall. Inevitably, things happen away from judging eyes.

God’s Own Country is not an exercise in miserabilism: it is does not believe that love or adventures of the heart are doomed. Not at all. And the title is not in any way ironic; although I thought the Super 8-style nostalgia footage of bygone harvests that accompanied the closing credits was not tonally right for the tough candour of what had gone before. It is a film which lives and dies by the performances which Lee gets from his cast, and these are excellent: sharp, intelligent and emotionally generous.

Contributor

Peter Bradshaw

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
A Ghost Story review: Casey Affleck channels Swayze in haunting love story
The hereafter is a slow, subtle affair in David Lowery’s evocative followup to Ain’t Them Bodies Saints, in which bedsheet-clad Affleck watches over bereaved partner Rooney Mara

Jordan Hoffman

23, Jan, 2017 @11:12 AM

Article image
Casting JonBenét review – magnificent provocation to the very notion of truth
Kitty Green’s avant garde documentary allows people auditioning to play JonBenét Ramsey and her family to expound their conspiracy theories about the unsolved murder of the child beauty pageant star

Charlie Phillips

24, Jan, 2017 @11:02 AM

Article image
God's Own Country and Lady Macbeth triumph at British independent film awards
Yorkshire-set love story and atmospheric period drama honoured at this year’s Bifa ceremony, with a Guardian short film also among the winners

Gwilym Mumford

11, Dec, 2017 @1:31 PM

Article image
Newness review: swipe left on this shallow dating drama
Nicholas Hoult and Laia Costa are a dull millennial couple addicted to Tinder in this visually slick yet emotionally vapid take on modern relationships

Jordan Hoffman

26, Jan, 2017 @9:11 PM

Article image
Rebel in the Rye review – JD Salinger drama catches attention but sinks into cliche
Nicholas Hoult plays the author in a watchable but shallow take on creativity and the process of writing a classic

Jordan Hoffman

25, Jan, 2017 @8:30 PM

Article image
Strong Island review – an authentic, painful journey into injustice
Yance Ford’s extraordinary documentary on the murder of his brother is part journalistic examination, part devastating essay on grief for black US families

Charlie Phillips

26, Jan, 2017 @2:38 PM

Article image
City of Ghosts review: could be the definitive Syria documentary
Cartel Land director Matthew Heineman’s film on citizen journalist group Raqqa Is Being Slaughtered Silently reveals the reality of life in Isis territory

Charlie Phillips

27, Jan, 2017 @4:58 PM

Article image
Last Men in Aleppo review – gruelling portrait of a city without hope
Feras Fayyad’s heartbreaking documentary offers powerful insights into the courageous rescue work of the White Helmet volunteers

Charlie Phillips

24, Jan, 2017 @12:27 PM

Article image
Landline review: faint deflation on speed dial as Obvious Child crew reunite
Love Jenny Slate? Then you’ll likely enjoy her latest collaboration with Gillian Robespierre: a familiar, 90s-set yarn of dysfunctional familial fidelity. But if you’re allergic … run fast and far

Jordan Hoffman

21, Jan, 2017 @3:04 PM

Article image
An Inconvenient Sequel review – Al Gore's new climate change film lacks heat
The former vice president’s latest documentary on the threat to the planet, which opened the Sundance festival, is desultory and surprisingly vainglorious

Jordan Hoffman

20, Jan, 2017 @10:42 AM