In the safe, sanitised world of the multiplex, where product placement and brand partnerships reign supreme, it’s rare to see a mainstream film with the guts to double as a takedown of a multi-billion dollar company. But, after watching Peter Berg’s surprisingly yet deservedly angry restaging of the 2010 Deepwater Horizon disaster, which caused 11 deaths and the biggest oil spill in history, it’ll take a minor PR miracle to restore the average moviegoer’s faith in BP.

On paper, Berg is a poor choice for the material. His last film at sea was Battleship, a soulless, swaggering Transformers knock-off based on a board game, and his last with star Mark Wahlberg was the viscerally effective but heavy-handed Navy Seals drama Lone Survivor. He also tried and failed to make something resembling an issues movie with the forgettable Saudi-set actioner The Kingdom. But for the most part in this effective disaster thriller, he keeps the flag-waving jingoism to a minimum, to focus on the devastating tragedy at hand.

Wahlberg stars as Mike Williams, an engineer who heads off to sea, leaving his wife (Kate Hudson) and daughter at home. It seems like business as usual as he makes his way to Deepwater Horizon, an oil rig in the Gulf of Mexico, but once aboard, there is uncomfortable tension. His senior, a gruff Kurt Russell, is warring with visiting BP execs, who insist a drilling operation go ahead despite safety concerns. The most ruthless suit, a drawling John Malkovich, appears unmoved by complaints about faulty equipment and unfinished checks.

When the work begins, under protest, it soon becomes clear there are major problems at play, and soon men are fighting for their lives on a burning oil rig in the middle of the sea.

Deepwater Horizon: Mark Wahlberg in disaster movie trailer

There’s no denying the harrowing nature of the story being told, but Berg is admirably, uncharacteristically restrained. Wahlberg’s family dynamic is briskly yet believably constructed, and we’re spared some of the more cliched moments we’d usually expect in this kind of film. There’s no heavy signposting or emotional goodbye when he sets off for the rig. And once we’re at sea, the dialogue is terse, tense and delivers often complex technical minutiae clearly, without anything feeling as if it has been dumbed down.

The film also squarely, and quite rightly, places the blame for the disaster at BP’s door. Without turning them into moustache-twirling villains, we see its representatives callously place profits over potential loss of human life and environmental damage. I can’t recall a film that’s been quite so brave or clear in its untainted bile for one particular company (“money-hungry sonsabitches”).

When all hell breaks loose, Berg stages the action horribly well, capturing the panic and gruesome mayhem without the film ever feeling exploitative. It’s spectacularly constructed, yet it doesn’t forget about the loss of life, ensuring that, despite thin characterisation, the impact is felt. Sentiment is kept at bay, and it’s only a treacly country song at the end, over an otherwise powerful photographic tribute, that feels a bit clumsy.

Wahlberg, again, makes for a solid everyman, and there’s a nice decision, late in the film, to focus on his shock back on land rather than a sugary reunion with his family. Russell and Malkovich riff on types they’ve played before, but with predictable skill, while Jane the Virgin breakout Gina Rodriguez makes the most of a small role as a young worker who calls for help.

Deepwater Horizon is a gruelling disaster movie and a reminder of one company’s catastrophic oversights, and it stands as a worthy tribute to the brave men involved.

Contributor

Benjamin Lee

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The 'well from hell' – my fight with BP to film Deepwater Horizon
The 2010 explosion in the Gulf of Mexico triggered an environmental catastrophe and resulted in unbelievable human heroism – so it was a natural fit for Hollywood. But what do you do when your film leads you into conflict with a corporate oil giant? The film’s director, Peter Berg, explains

Peter Berg

04, Oct, 2016 @3:07 PM

Article image
Deepwater Horizon review – BP oil spill drama captures heroics and heartache
Mark Wahlberg stars in Peter Berg’s excellent nail-biting drama about the 2010 disaster that cost 11 lives

Peter Bradshaw

29, Sep, 2016 @10:00 PM

Article image
BP faces further $2.5bn charge over Deepwater Horizon spill
Oil company has paid out more than $60bn in liabilities over environmental disaster that still threatens wildlife and ecology around Gulf of Mexico

Terry Macalister

14, Jul, 2016 @5:54 PM

Article image
Deepwater Horizon: jury selection begins for BP exec charged in oil spill
David Rainey accused of obstructing congressional investigation as prosecutors say he misled officials about quantity of oil entering Gulf of Mexico

Dominic Rushe in New York

01, Jun, 2015 @4:16 PM

Article image
'Of course it could happen again': experts say little has changed since Deepwater Horizon
The danger of deepwater oil operations, combined with the loosening of Obama-era rules, mean the risk of a repeat disaster is high

Emily Holden in Washington

20, Apr, 2020 @8:54 PM

Article image
BP to pay $175m to investors over Deepwater Horizon spill
Settlement compensates investors who claimed BP publicly underplayed amount of oil flowing from Macondo well into Gulf of Mexico

Rob Davies

03, Jun, 2016 @10:14 AM

Article image
Deepwater Horizon review – gripping real-life disaster
Mark Wahlberg, Kurt Russell and John Malkovich star in this explosive yet intelligent take on the BP Gulf of Mexico oil spill

Wendy Ide

02, Oct, 2016 @7:00 AM

Article image
Deepwater oil spill: BP steps up PR effort to insist all is well in the Gulf
Oil giant says area is making a rapid recovery but evidence mounts that wildlife is still struggling to rebound, five years after Deepwater Horizon spill

Peter Moskowitz in New Orleans

31, Mar, 2015 @11:48 AM

Article image
Five years after the Deepwater Horizon oil spill, we are closer than ever to catastrophe
Important changes have been made since 2010, but the oil and gas industry has not learned from the historic oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico

András Tilcsik and Chris Clearfield

17, Apr, 2015 @8:53 AM

Article image
Government $1bn deal to controversial Petrobras deep-sea oil drilling
Funding to Brazil state-owned company from ECGD department raises environmental concerns from MPs and campaigners

Rupert Neate

11, Jul, 2012 @6:21 PM