Far from the Madding Crowd review – solid, but needs more mud

Thomas Vinterburg’s adaptation of the Hardy classic is handsome and well played but could do with a little less polish

Danish director Thomas Vinterberg’s take on Thomas Hardy’s earthy tale of an independent woman torn between three suitors and a dream of self-determination is both self-consciously modern and oddly old-fashioned. Carey Mulligan is Bathsheba Everdene, unexpected inheritor of her uncle’s farm, which is sorely in need of a firm hand. Proving herself more than a match for any man, Bathsheba swithers between the proposals of solid Gabriel Oak (Matthias Schoenaerts) and wealthy William Boldwood (an excellently uneasy Michael Sheen) only to fall for rakish Sergeant Troy (Tom Sturridge) and his sexy sword-waving skills – a scene rendered with less gropey lust but more breathlessly passionate weirdness in John Schlesinger’s recently reissued 1967 adaptation.

The film team review Far From the Madding Crowd

Shot on film by cinematographer Charlotte Bruus Christensen, this captures its Dorset scenery (“200 miles from London” we are told) in hues that are both bucolic and foreboding; the opening shot finds Bathsheba emerging from darkness, a portentous visual motif that continues throughout the film. Screenwriter (and novelist) David Nicholls, who wrote the BBC’s 2008 Tess of the D’Urbervilles mini-series, plays up the story’s proto-feminist core, Bathsheba explicitly declaring herself to be “too independent” for marriage while wrestling with a language designed by and for men. Mulligan takes all this in her stride, her “woman out of time” bristling with proudly untamed energy, the master of men and horses alike. There’s some sympathy, too, for the rotten Sergeant Troy, whose jilted-at-the-altar tear underwrites his anger with pathos – a quality notably lacking from Terence Stamp’s 1960s portrayal.

Whether this adds substantially to Schlesinger’s classic (which was roughly received at the time) remains a moot point. Vinterberg, who made his name with Festen and its flip-side Jagten, reins in the gruelling emotional cruelties of yore, treating the text respectfully if playfully, relishing the opportunity to indulge its scenic charms, amplified by the ascending larks of much lush swooning music. Personally, I could have done with a little more mud, a touch of the Andrew Köttings to take the designer edge of these dirty faces. But it’s solid stuff; well played, affectionately told, and still stirring in its role reversals, both personal and political.


Mark Kermode, Observer film critic

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Far from the Madding Crowd; Phoenix; The Good Lie; Top Five; Narcos – review
Carey Mulligan’s Bathsheba Everdene is hardly Hardy’s in Thomas Vinterberg’s handsome adaptation, but Nina Hoss is immaculate in a postwar psychodrama

Guy Lodge

30, Aug, 2015 @6:00 AM

Article image
Far from the Madding Crowd review – Carey Mulligan is a fierce presence
This good-looking version of Thomas Hardy’s romance had a hard act to follow after John Schlesinger’s 1967 film classic, and is heartfelt but flawed

Peter Bradshaw

30, Apr, 2015 @8:01 PM

Article image
A Jungian take on Thomas Vinterberg's Far From the Madding Crowd
The battle between the masculine and feminine takes centre stage in this vibrant adaptation of Thomas Hardy’s classic novel

Alison Sayers

11, May, 2015 @12:18 PM

Article image
Far From the Madding Crowd review: Carey Mulligan shines in Hardy perennial
Thomas (Festen) Vinterberg turns out to be a half-eccentric, half-inspired choice to direct Thomas Hardy’s rural tragedy, nearly 50 years after John Schlesinger’s classic adaptation

Peter Bradshaw

02, Apr, 2015 @9:00 AM

Article image
Trailer Trash
BBC Films fall in love with Matthias Schoenaerts, Danny Boyle reminisces with Philip French, and Olivia Colman seeks direction, writes Jason Solomons

Jason Solomons

11, May, 2013 @11:06 PM

Article image
Far from the Madding Crowd director Thomas Vinterberg: ‘It’s always been me-me-me-me – until now’
He was the Dogme auteur who had the world at his feet, then it all fell apart. Thomas Vinterberg talks about hitting rock bottom, splitting up with Lars Von Trier – and what a ‘Danish handshake’ really means

Andrew Pulver

28, Apr, 2015 @5:10 PM

Article image
Far From the Madding Crowd review – less haste, more feeling
An atmospheric adaptation of Thomas Hardy’s tortured romance stumbles in its race to the finish

Clare Brennan

26, Apr, 2015 @7:00 AM

Article image
Far From the Madding Crowd review – still quite dazzling
John Schlesinger’s 1967 film of Hardy’s novel, ravishingly shot by Nicholas Roeg, is hard to beat

Mark Kermode Observer film critic

15, Mar, 2015 @8:00 AM

Article image
Shame – review
Michael Fassbender is gripping and intense in Steve McQueen's chilling story of a New York sex addict, writes Philip French

Philip French

15, Jan, 2012 @12:01 AM

Article image
Drive – review
Ryan Gosling shines as the man behind the wheel in Nicolas Winding Refn's gripping take on Hollywood noir, writes Philip French

Philip French

24, Sep, 2011 @11:05 PM