Welcome to New York review – Abel Ferrara is unencumbered by good taste

Gérard Depardieu lets it all hang out, and director Abel Ferrara indicts the super-rich, in a brutal, pitiless and sulphurous spin on the Dominique Strauss-Kahn sexual-assault case

Abel Ferrara's crazy, sulphurous, toweringly unpleasant Welcome to New York is like an "issue" movie about sexual assault being beamed to cinema screens live from the seventh circle of hell. There are no blurred lines here, no ambiguities, no water-cooler talking points about gradations of consent. This film's protagonist is simply guilty; he is a rapist, grown obese on his own wealth and entitlement. Steve McQueen made a movie about sex addiction called Shame. This one could be called Pride. Or maybe Self-Pity. Only Ferrara, that raucous director, could have made it – being so entirely unencumbered by the kind of middlebrow good taste that might have led another kind of film-maker into revisionism and equivocation. Ferrara was the director responsible for the under-rated pulp classics The Addiction and The Funeral, all about the endless DNA-replication of evil. We get a taste here of the same eternal despair. There are some clunky moments in the dialogue and direction, and maybe Ferrara doesn't quite finesse the switches between French and English, but Welcome to New York has the brutal courage of its convictions. It sets out to show a monster, and it succeeds.

The film takes as its starting point the case of Dominique Strauss-Kahn, the French leftist economist and politician accused in 2011 of sexually assaulting a maid in his New York hotel room, but finally acquitted when his defence team succeeded in undermining her evidence and credibility; he later admitted to "inappropriate" behaviour and settled a civil suit out of court. A statement, flashed up on screen before the film begins, announces the film's fictional credentials, though conceding it is inspired by Strauss-Kahn. But, with some insolence, Ferrara uses TV press conference footage of the actual Strauss-Kahn case and slots it into the narrative.

Gérard Depardieu plays Devereaux, the president of a French financial institution; he is a smug and self-satisfied player on the Parisian social scene, a near-exhausted volcano of political ambition whose bleary liberalism and affected sexual frankness amount to boorish arrogance. He is addicted to prostitutes and to using them for coercion and leverage in official dealings. Devereaux travels to New York on business, enjoys a gruesome 12 hours of champagne, drugs and escorts in his suite and winds up by attempting to grab and masturbate over the maid, played by Pamela Afesi, who has come to clean up his room.

He is guilty: no question about it, his guilt, reeking to high heavens, infuriates his wife Simone, played by Jacqueline Bisset, who is burdened with her loyalty to this ageing priapic baby and by the certainty that the case, however it turns out, has definitively ruined both their lives.

There are two unforgettably horrible parts to this film: the first is the hideous, mirthless laughter of the middle-aged men and the prostitutes taking part in the grisly demi-orgy, people laughing at things that aren't funny; it is the deathly sound of porn-star bad acting, partly, but also the chillingly plausible sound of men who do a lot of coke looking forward to what they imagine to be consequence-free sex.

Then there is Devereaux's stay in prison, which reaches its nadir when he is forced to strip. Depardieu's nakedness is truly startling. His stomach's emergence is like a flesh mudslide. To paraphrase Hanif Kureishi, it spills out over his penis like a suitcase falling off the top of a wardrobe. And there is a horrendous moment when he is told to put his clothes back on: rather than endure the drawn-out indignity of getting his tent-like underpants back in place, Devereaux quickly pulls his trousers on and absurdly stuffs his pants quickly in his pocket – to the guards' savage incredulity and contempt.

This is a brutal, occasionally inelegant film, but it pulls no punches and shines a stark, pitiless light on its subject. Some of this man's conquests have been consenting in the past, which only emboldens him to believe that he is entitled to take what he wants in every case. A dark night of the soul while the case is in progress is soon replaced by his sentimental belief in himself as the injured party, unrepentant to the very end.

What Depardieu himself makes of his character and his own (excellent) performance is something of a mystery. There is a weird pre-emptive, "interview" scene at the beginning in which he explains to a gallery of fictional reporters that he was attracted to the role precisely because the man is so unpleasant, and unpleasant he certainly is: as unpleasant as Ferrara's King of New York, his Bad Lieutenant, and his vampires in The Addiction. He is another creature of the night, strip-mined of all human feeling.


Peter Bradshaw

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Abel Ferrara threatens to sue over US cut of Welcome to New York
Director insists his name on edited version of film based on Dominique Strauss-Kahn scandal ‘is a crime’

Ben Child

20, Mar, 2015 @6:11 PM

Article image
Abel Ferrara accused of 'slinging mud' over Welcome to New York row
IFC Films claims the director’s lack of involvement forced it to re-cut his satire inspired by the Dominique Strauss-Kahn case

Benjamin Lee

23, Mar, 2015 @12:14 PM

Article image
Welcome to New York review – Gérard Depardieu offers naked ambition
Gérard Depardieu is remarkable as a Dominique Strauss-Kahn figure in an incoherent tale with flashes of brilliance, writes Jonathan Romney

Jonathan Romney

10, Aug, 2014 @8:00 AM

The Guardian Film Show: Welcome to New York, God's Pocket, Lilting and All This Mayhem - video reviews

Henry Barnes, Leslie Felperin and Andrew Pulver review this week's big releases, including Abel Ferrera's jaw-dropping take on the DSK scandal and Philip Seymour Hoffman's last starring role

Henry Barnes, Leslie Felperin, Andrew Pulver, Richard Sprenger, Tom Silverstone, Phil Maynard and Leah Green

08, Aug, 2014 @6:50 AM

Article image
Abel Ferrara at Cannes: 'You gotta be careful what you say … but I'm not'
Catherine Shoard: Abel Ferrara has long been one of Hollywood's most provocative directors. This week his new film, Welcome to New York, was the hot ticket at Cannes – especially after ex-IMF boss Dominique Strauss-Kahn decided to sue

Catherine Shoard

23, May, 2014 @5:29 PM

Article image
Jacqueline Bisset: 'Older women continue to want sex but men don't want to sleep with them'
In Welcome to New York, Jacqueline Bisset plays the long-suffering wife of an adulterous financier, based on Dominique Strauss-Kahn. She talks to Catherine Shoard about sexual desire and what divides men and women

Catherine Shoard

24, Jul, 2014 @4:17 PM

Welcome to New York: watch Gérard Depardieu in the trailer for Abel Ferrara's take on the Strauss-Kahn scandal - world exclusive video

Watch Gérard Depardieu in the exclusive trailer for Welcome to New York, Abel Ferrara's sex scandal drama, inspired by the Dominic Strauss-Kahn story

10, Jul, 2014 @12:40 PM

Article image
Abel Ferrara: 'Pasolini's death is not some kind of fictional event'
The fearless champion of bad taste talks spirituality, improvisation and his shamanic approach to shooting a film about Pasolini’s fateful final hours

Rowan Righelato

11, Sep, 2015 @7:00 AM

Article image
Pasolini review – monument to a murdered film-maker
Abel Ferrara has a taste for trouble equal to Pier Paolo Pasolini’s, but this chronicle of the late film-maker’s final hours is surprisingly restrained

Peter Bradshaw

10, Sep, 2015 @2:30 PM

Article image
Siberia review – Willem Dafoe and Abel Ferrara on fine freaky form
Dafoe has gravitas as a barkeep on a journey of delusion and epiphany in Ferrara’s glacial, woozy dream-odyssey

Peter Bradshaw

23, Sep, 2021 @6:00 AM