Mississippi Burning: a civil rights story of good intentions and suspect politics

Willem Dafoe and Gene Hackman star as FBI agents who crack a 1964 conspiracy of racist murderers – without any help from the activists who played such a vital role at this time

Mississippi Burning (1988)
Director: Alan Parker
Entertainment grade: B
History grade: D–

On 21 June 1964, one black and two white civil rights activists disappeared near Philadelphia, Mississippi. The FBI codenamed the case MIBURN – short for Mississippi Burning.

Crime

The three activists – in real life, James Chaney, Andrew Goodman and Michael Schwerner, though they are not named in the film – are driving, tailed by several cars. When they stop, they are murdered and their bodies hidden by a mob of white men connected to the Ku Klux Klan. Later, the FBI turn up, in the fictionalised forms of spiky white liberal intellectual Agent Ward (Willem Dafoe) and rough-around-the-edges white liberal anti-intellectual Agent Anderson (Gene Hackman). Viewers may erroneously conclude that the FBI in 1964 was the vanguard of liberalism, though there is a brief reference to the rather less progressive views of its director J Edgar Hoover. Anderson and Ward are based approximately on real FBI agents John Proctor and Joseph Sullivan.

Civil rights

Ward escalates the investigation with agents from Washington. "You'll start a war," Anderson warns him. "It was a war long before we got here," Ward snaps back. This, along with a nod to the story of James Meredith, is about as far as the film gets towards contextualisation. On release, it was criticised by civil rights figures including Coretta Scott King for largely ignoring the role of black and white activists. One figure who could have been in the movie (and isn't) was Mrs King's husband, Martin Luther King Jr. He visited Philadelphia a month after the disappearances, and declared: "This is a terrible town. The worst I've seen. There is a complete reign of terror here."

Racism

Though Mississippi Burning depicts many appalling (and broadly accurate) incidents of racist violence, its narrative focus is on what race politics meant to white people. Most of the black characters in the film are passive, with two notable exceptions. First, the screenplay puts a few aspirations to freedom in the mouth of an angelic young boy, perhaps hoping that the fact he is a child will render anything that sounds like a demand less threatening to any jittery white people in the audience. Second, it creates a flip side to the innocent black child: the scary black monster. Badass FBI Agent Monk (Badja Djola) kidnaps the town's racist mayor and threatens to chop his privates off with a razor blade if he doesn't give up the guilty men. Monk is pretty implausible, though there were such things as black FBI agents in 1964: the first was appointed in 1919. Real-life mafioso and FBI informant Gregory Scarpa (who was of white Italian heritage) claimed to have fulfilled a role similar to Monk's, though historians of the case generally take that with a substantial pinch of salt. Clearly, Mississippi Burning has good intentions when it comes to portraying the history of race politics. Even so, with Monk and the boy as its only substantial black characters, it can't help echoing Rudyard Kipling's description of conquered peoples as "half-devil and half-child" – hinting that, deep down, it isn't immune from some rum old ideas itself.

Investigation

In the film, Mrs Pell (Frances McDormand), wife of sheriff's deputy and lynch mob leader Clinton Pell (Brad Dourif), reveals a police conspiracy. This leads Anderson and Ward to another of the guilty men, who they soon intimidate into a confession. All of these characters are fictional. In place of Mrs Pell, there was a "Mr X", who has subsequently been named by journalists as highway patrolman Maynard King. Rather than resorting to the vigilante tactics used by Anderson in the film, the FBI allegedly paid cash for information to crack the case. Seven men (out of 18 accused) were convicted on relatively minor conspiracy charges. The only man convicted of the manslaughter of the three activists was Edgar Ray Killen, who was finally prosecuted in 2005.

Verdict

Mississippi Burning is written, acted and filmed with flair, but its history and politics are as murky as a Mississippi swamp.

Contributor

Alex von Tunzelmann

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Mississippi Burning review – incandescent civil rights thriller
Alan Parker’s finest film, based on the notorious real-life murders of three civil-rights activists by the KKK, remains tragically relevant

Philip French

11, Oct, 2015 @7:00 AM

Article image
'An untimely visit': Trump avoids protest at Mississippi Civil Rights Museum
The president flew in to Jackson, took a tour, spoke briefly, hid from the public, and left. Many celebrating a historic state project said that was just as well

Alan Huffman in Jackson, Mississippi

09, Dec, 2017 @9:55 PM

Article image
‘It’s good to think strategically’: Thomas E Ricks on civil rights and January 6
In his new book, the historian considers the work of Martin Luther King and others through the lens of military thought

Martin Pengelly in Washington

08, Oct, 2022 @6:00 AM

Article image
Fruitvale Station: quiet and unassuming but a significant story

This brilliant film sticks closely to the known facts about one unlawful killing in 2009, but is part of a wider, ever relevant story about the treatment of young black men in America

Alex von Tunzelmann

14, Aug, 2014 @12:08 PM

Article image
Mississippi man pleads guilty to burning cross in yard to intimidate Black family
DoJ says Axel Cox ‘admitted he burned cross because of the victims’ race and because they were occupying a home next to his’

Adam Gabbatt in New York

05, Dec, 2022 @10:00 AM

Mississippi jury refuses to indict for civil rights era murder
A last hope of justice over one of the most painful episodes in the racial history of the US was apparently lost yesterday when a Mississippi grand jury refused to issue an indictment for the killing of Emmett Till, the teenager whose murder 50 years ago galvanised the civil rights movement.

Suzanne Goldenberg in Washington

28, Feb, 2007 @12:03 AM

Roy Greenslade: Mississippi paper apologises for civil rights coverage

This is a classic example of better late than never. A Mississippi daily newspaper, the Meridian Star, has just apologised for its past coverage of civil rights issues

Roy Greenslade

19, Jan, 2009 @8:20 AM

Article image
Trump's Mississippi visit is story of his campaign: focused on money, not votes
Candidate’s trip through deep red states rather than battleground ones is a quintessential move – favoring habit over conventional political wisdom

Matthew Teague in Jackson, Mississippi

24, Aug, 2016 @2:00 PM

Article image
Remembering Medgar Evers – and carrying on his fight for civil rights | Martha Bergmark

Martha Bergmark: Fifty years ago, the NAACP activist was gunned down in Jackson, Mississippi. But his work lives on to this day

Martha Bergmark

12, Jun, 2013 @1:15 PM

Article image
To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee taken off Mississippi school reading list
Official says ‘some language in the book makes people uncomfortable’ although copies will remain in school libraries

Guardian staff and agencies

14, Oct, 2017 @9:36 PM