The Curious Case of Benjamin Button: very long fade to Brad Pitt

The multiple-Oscar-nominated David Fincher film is out on DVD this week, but if Brad Pitt and Cate Blanchett are not enough to get you through its 165-minute running time, here's our carefully boiled-down version

The Curious Case of Benjamin Button By Paul MacInnes (with apologies to Eric Roth and Robin Swicord)

INTERIOR of a modern hospital. DAY. Outside tempestuous rain is lashing against the windows. Inside a daughter, CAROLINE, stands by the bed of her dying mother, OLD DAISY. The room is variously decorated with PAPERS, OUTLANDISH ARTEFACTS and umpteen photos of BRAD PITT.

CAROLINE
Hey Momma, now that Hurricane Katrina is about to destroy our beloved New Orleans and, with it, much of its storied history, I guess we ought to hurry up with this silly old tale about the one true love of your life. Plus, I got to tell you, American Idol is on in an hour.

OLD DAISY
(almost unintelligibly)
whyinevertheresnoneedtobesoru...

CAROLINE
I know, Momma, I love you too. I get it that this Benjamin guy had some kind of backwards disease and saw no colour, creed nor cripple – which was lucky for you I must say – but if you wouldn't mind I'd like to cut through the crap a bit here.

OLD DAISY picks up a battered diary, marks out some pages with Post-it notes, and throws it at her daughter in disgust. CAROLINE is oblivious to her anger and, picking up the diary, begins to read from it, opening at the first note. As she reads, her voice transforms into that of BENJAMIN BUTTON and the screen turns sepia.

BENJAMIN BUTTON
1935 – well, wouldn't you believe it if I didn't just go an' get laid. She was a lovely wumman and I paid her with my own money, which taught me the value of hard work. And because I'm a 4ft tall, fully-bald 17-year-old, I even got to sit down a while afterward. Arthritis playing up, gumbo for supper again.

FADE OUT on sepia. FADE IN to CAROLINE, rolling her eyes. FADE OUT again to sepia.

BENJAMIN BUTTON
1941 – Pearl Harbor attacked. Cap'n Mike is taking our tug to war. I try to tell him that a tug ain't fit for war, but he's a bit like Lt Dan in Forrest Gump and doesn't listen. I go and have sex with cold Englishwoman Mrs Elizabeth Abbott so as to feel better. I have hair like a university lecturer, I think she likes it. Pickled herring for supper again.

FADE OUT of sepia. FADE IN to CAROLINE waving a Post-it in the face of her beleaguered mother. OLD DAISY points to the diary. FADE IN to the sepia.

BENJAMIN BUTTON
1962 – Paris. I'm hanging around the city, being super nice. With a bit of luck, 30 years of continuing equanimity (my friend the pygmy taught me that word, he's from Equatorial Guinea), and Daisy might fall in love with me. Or maybe my now stunning good looks might swing it. Who knows. Duck à l'orange with pureed potatoes and white truffle reduction for dinner again.

BENJAMIN BUTTON
Update! Daisy now in love with me. Guess being nice worked! Either that or she heard about me with those dancing girls! Now to have that baby!

FADE OUT of sepia. FADE IN on CAROLINE with her jaw agape. OLD DAISY has a quiet smile on her face.

CAROLINE
You're telling me ... that ... he's my ... father?

OLD DAISY
yes ... and I ...

CAROLINE
Momma, will you shut your mouth for once! Can't you see I'm having a major life-stress?

OLD DAISY
... and I ...

CAROLINE
And Idol starts in 15 minutes. What am I going to do?

OLD DAISY
... AND I'VE WRITTEN YOU OUT OF MY WILL YOU UNGRATEFUL LITTLE WRETCH! oh. dear. i think i'm spent ...

OLD DAISY gently closes her eyes and passes on to the other side. A HUMMINGBIRD, the likes of which are rarely seen in air-conditioned hospitals, buzzes into the room and lingers over OLD DAISY'S BED. CAROLINE, rather peeved, swats it with her hand.

Contributor

Paul MacInnes

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Film review: The Curious Case of Benjamin Button

Brad Pitt and Cate Blanchett star in 166 minutes of twee tedium about a life lived backwards. By Peter Bradshaw

Peter Bradshaw

06, Feb, 2009 @12:01 AM

Article image
Film trailer: The Curious Case of Benjamin Button

David Fincher's film about a man who ages backwards, which stars Brad Pitt, Cate Blanchett and Tilda Swinton

09, Dec, 2008 @2:58 PM

The Curious Case of Benjamin Button trailer: time well and truly spent

The trailer for David Fincher's latest only demands 1/60th of the time you'd need to watch the film in full - but with so much going on, it makes Anna Pickard wonder if the film's running time is three hours or three days

Anna Pickard

13, Jan, 2009 @10:39 AM

Article image
DVD review: The Curious Case of Benjamin Button

Rob Mackie: This is not so much a movie, as a 166-minute-long special effect

Rob Mackie

05, Jun, 2009 @4:07 PM

Article image
You review: The Curious Case of Benjamin Button

It's up for 15 Oscars, but the only ones it scooped at yesterday's Baftas were best hair and best makeup. Who's right?

Ben Child

09, Feb, 2009 @1:16 PM

Article image
Film review: The Curious Case of Benjamin Button

Philip French asks whether Brad Pitt can pull it off where others have previously failed

Philip French

08, Feb, 2009 @12:01 AM

Article image
Video: In the director's chair with David Fincher, director of The Curious Case of Benjamin Button

The director of The Curious Case of Benjamin Button talks to Jason Solomons about what drew him to Eric Roth's script, working with Brad Pitt, and how he shot the video for Madonna's Vogue in 16 hours

Jason Solomons

04, Feb, 2009 @10:32 AM

Article image
Transcript of the Guardian interview with David Fincher at BFI Southbank

Onstage at the BFI Southbank, David Fincher tells Mark Salisbury about the technical challenges of making his Oscar-nominated romance The Curious Case of Benjamin Button, why he still hates his debut feature and makes it clear he is not responsible for torture porn

18, Jan, 2009 @11:59 PM

Article image
Film Weekly podcast: David Fincher, director of the 13-Oscar-nominated Benjamin Button

Oscar-nominated director David Fincher onThe Curious Case of Benjamin Button, Jason Solomons and Catherine Shoard review Revolutionary Road, plus Guardian first film award winner Joanna Hogg

Jason Solomons

29, Jan, 2009 @10:37 AM

Article image
Review: The Curious Case of Benjamin Button by F Scott Fitzgerald

Review: The Curious Case of Benjamin Button by F Scott Fitzgerald
This droll short story has been elevated to the status of a Penguin Classic by the new film, says Jane Housham

Jane Housham

20, Dec, 2008 @12:01 AM