Semi-independents warn against Oscar video ban

Hollywood's anti-piracy ban on informal pre-Oscar screenings could lead to big-budget domination of the awards, semi-independent studios have warned.

Hollywood's anti-piracy ban on informal pre-Oscar screenings could lead to big-budget domination of the awards, semi-independent studios have warned.

The practice of posting DVDs to Academy members - banned this week by the Motion Picture Association of America - had been favoured by smaller firms, who are often squeezed out of available screening rooms.

Now the independent arms of studios such as Miramax, Paramount and United Artists fear the move will see a return to the days when the studios dominated the Oscars.

Magnolia Pictures president Eamon Bowles told Variety: "Ultimately this just centralises and consolidates the industry-town nature of the Oscars and puts us squarely back in the area of favouring the studios for the Oscars.

"I don't know if I'm cynical enough to say that's the main reason this is being done, but it certainly will be a by-product of it that I'm sure people are aware of."

Miramax was at the centre of speculation earlier this week that it would boycott the ban, but co-chairman Harvey Weinstein told Variety he would be complying. He said: "I will go along with the ban if it is for the reason of combatting piracy. Disney has assured me that this is the purpose."

Truly indie distributors, which include Newmarket, Lions Gate and Newmarket, will not be hit by the ban since they are not affiliated with any MPAA studios.

Independent films which could benefit include IFC's Whale Rider, about a young Maori girl who comes into conflict with her ageing grandfather, and Magnolia's shocking documentary Capturing the Friedmans, which chronicles a Jewish family's day-to-day lives as their father is charged with molesting children.

Staff and agencies

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

The Observer Profile: Harvey Weinstein

The Hours, Chicago and Gangs of New York are all from the Miramax stable. Its ebullient co-founder has been accused of bullying his way to the top but with 40 Academy Awards to his credit and 40 more nominations this year, he's not perturbed: Harvey Weinstein.

Vanessa Thorpe

16, Feb, 2003 @4:25 AM

Letter from LA: 10 films you need to see if you want to be in the Oscar loop

There are 10 films you need to see if you want to be in the Oscar loop. And here they are... with accompanying gossip.

Anne Thompson

17, Nov, 2002 @12:59 AM

Miramax's Oscar contenders

Competition is strong for the Golden gong.

15, Dec, 2002 @3:13 AM

Oscar v the sneaks

Film: So you want to win an Oscar? You'd better follow these new rules ...

15, Oct, 2003 @12:28 AM

Chicago leads Oscar nominations

The musical Chicago was nominated for 13 Oscars this afternoon, pitting it against literary drama The Hours and Martin Scorsese's Gangs of New York for the big prizes

Sean Clarke

11, Feb, 2003 @4:29 PM

Article image
Chicago man's Oscar faith justified

Chicago director Rob Marshall last week told us he expected that his musical extravaganza could do as well at the Oscars as any weighty drama. The director's faith was justified today when his first film was shortlisted for 13 Academy awards.

Sean Clarke

11, Feb, 2003 @4:23 PM

Afghanistan rejoins record Oscar race

Films from an unprecedented 54 countries submitted for best foreign film award

Staff and agencies

03, Dec, 2002 @12:59 AM

Those Oscar war protests in full

Who boycotted, who 'gave it a miss', and who had something to say

Staff and agencies

24, Mar, 2003 @12:16 PM

Article image
Warrior fails to get Oscar nod

Asif Kapadia's The Warrior was rejected as Britain's entry in the best foreign language Oscar category, it has been revealed.

Staff and agencies

04, Dec, 2002 @12:59 AM

Article image
O'Toole miffed about honorary Oscar

Peter O'Toole has asked the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences to hold off with the honorary statuette because he 'is still in the game'

Staff and agencies

29, Jan, 2003 @10:53 AM