The Green Mile

Peter Bradshaw: If you can stand this three-hour-plus stretch of saccharine gibberish and patronising racial politics, you've got a stronger stomach than me

The execution of black men in the American south: what an obvious subject for a sentimental slice of feelgood drama starring Tom Hanks! This is the substance of The Green Mile, adapted from Stephen King's novel and directed by Frank Darabont, who brought us The Shawshank Redemption. His subject need not evoke the unlovely realities associated with, say, Ricky Ray Rector, the mentally disabled black man whose 1992 execution in Arkansas was enthusiastically endorsed by Governor Bill Clinton. This is because the story takes place in the picturesque olden days of 1935: heritage death penalty.

Tom Hanks plays Paul Edgecomb, possibly the most liberal death-row prison guard in the history of the universe, never mind the 30s. That bulbous, funny-shaped lower lip of his is permanently throbbing with sensitivity, though scruples about the death penalty itself play no part in his quivering humanity.

Our Tom gently presides over an ethnic rainbow of prisoners lining up for the electric chair: one white francophone, one Native American, one horrible white-trash hick, and one black man called John Coffey, who is physically enormous (naturally) a gentle giant (of course) and possessed of luminous Christ-like healing powers (oh, behave). Tom lets John Coffey put his hand on his nether regions to cure his urinary infection! And the saintly prison governor allows John unaccompanied into his wife's boudoir - did I mention this is set in 1935? - to cure her brain tumour!

If you can stand this three-hour-plus stretch of saccharine gibberish and patronising racial politics, you've got a stronger stomach than me.

Contributor

Peter Bradshaw

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Moonlight Mile

Donnie Brighto is what they should have called this feeble, sucrose emotional drama starring Jake Gyllenhaal - from Brad Silberling who directed the Wings of Desire remake City of Angels. It's a film which starts with an interesting idea but relapses into forgiving sentimental blandness. We are in the early 1970s, with plenty of gleaming period automobiles rolling past on cue. Gyllenhaal plays Joe, whose fiancée has been killed by a gunman; he is now living with his prospective parents-in-law, Ben and JoJo (Dustin Hoffman and Susan Sarandon), as a pseudo-son figure and has agreed to go into Hoffman's real estate business in a half-understood attempt to assuage their grief.

Peter Bradshaw

21, Feb, 2003 @2:25 AM

Moonlight Mile

Something of a companion piece to In the Bedroom with its subject matter of grief and loss and its determination to avoid the cliches cinema often surrounds death with, Moonlight Mile treats its characters with care and interest before eventually succumbing to a pat Hollywood ending.

Rob Mackie

22, Aug, 2003 @1:31 AM

Article image
8 Mile

Peter Bradshaw: The problem is Eminem himself, who has clearly been drilled by the director to play to what will have to pass as strengths: stillness, cool, control

Peter Bradshaw

17, Jan, 2003 @2:11 AM

Moonlight Mile

Peter Bradshaw: Donnie Brighto is what they should have called this feeble, sucrose emotional drama starring Jake Gyllenhaal

Peter Bradshaw

21, Feb, 2003 @2:27 AM

8 Mile

A very serviceable lead role for Eminem in what amounts to a lightly fictionalised biopic (probably for legal reasons, knowing the writ-packed history of the Mathers family). Eminem's charisma survives intact and his blank-eyed stare is genuinely disturbing.

Rob Mackie

30, May, 2003 @1:31 PM

Article image
One Mile Away – review

A documentary that helped spark a reconciliation between rival gangs in Birmingham is a little short on context, but inspiring none the less, writes Henry Barnes

Henry Barnes

28, Mar, 2013 @10:45 PM

Article image
One Mile Away – review

Penny Woolcock's documentary about two Birmingham gangs trying to forge a truce is revealing and often disturbing, writes Philip French

Philip French

31, Mar, 2013 @12:04 AM

Article image
One Mile Away - video review

Henry Barnes, Peter Bradshaw and Andrew Pulver review One Mile Away

Henry Barnes, Peter Bradshaw, Andrew Pulver, Christian Bennett, Phil Maynard and Josh Strauss

29, Mar, 2013 @9:39 AM

The jury's out, by a mile

This year was an exceptional Cannes, says Derek Malcolm, though the tabloids dismiss it. Here he selects the ten best films from this year's festival: don't expect to find the Palme d'Or winner, or the deliberately controversial Irréversible

Derek Malcolm

28, May, 2002 @11:49 AM

Article image
VS. review – the 8 Mile of Southend
This low-budget British film about a young white male channelling his rage into the rap battle scene has real storytelling punch

Peter Bradshaw

19, Oct, 2018 @5:00 AM