Unbreakable review – supernatural thriller that sends you on a frantic mental scurry

Lingers potently in the mind for hours, and somehow without its flaws, eccentricities and longueurs it would not be the film it is

This compelling conundrum of a film marks the maturity of Sixth Sense director M Night Shyamalan as a distinctive, even a remarkable film-maker. Every scene, every frame of this deeply strange and intriguing movie is permeated with a mood and a feel that the writer-producer-director effortlessly establishes as his signature. In some ways, Unbreakable is an unfinished, unrealised film, but it lingers potently in the mind for hours, and somehow without its flaws, eccentricities and longueurs it would not be the film it is.

Like The Sixth Sense, this is a supernatural thriller with a twist, starring Bruce Willis. The ending will also send you on a frantic mental scurry back to the beginning to check you have got everything right. But unlike The Sixth Sense, there is ambiguity: we are not sure quite how much we've seen is illusory. And crucially, the whole idea of the twist - the surprise ending that the critic cannot reveal - is diluted in intensity but enlarged in scope. In Unbreakable, the ending is arguably the twist, but then so arguably is the middle and the beginning too - along with the whole genre of the film. Perhaps Unbreakable is one enormous twist!

Anyway, Willis is David, a security guard who, astonishingly, emerges utterly unscathed from a horrific train crash that kills everyone else. Then he receives an unsettling message from Elijah, a comic book collector and connoisseur with a genetic disorder which means that his bones break at the slightest mishap. Elijah believes he is the alter ego of David, and just as he is condemned to a life of pain and vulnerability, so David is unbreakable; so Elijah passionately urges him to cultivate his destiny as a 21st century superhero.

Samuel L Jackson plays Elijah, and gives a terrific performance - his best since Pulp Fiction. His bizarre, angular presence shimmers with charisma. And Shyamalan gets excellent work from fellow Pulp Fiction graduate, Willis. Their relationship is a pairing that works superbly, and their story progresses with its own bizarre realist logic.

At the end Unbreakable feels oddly like a first "collector's issue" comic, introducing the superhero and setting him up for a long series. So it is unsatisfyingly incomplete in itself, but any sequel in that vein that Shyamalan might give us would spoil the original's mystery and enigma. Nevertheless it is a fascinating film. I am preparing to pay to see it again - and I can't say fairer than that.


Peter Bradshaw

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
M Night Shyamalan announces sequel to Unbreakable and Split in same film
Director reveals both films will ‘collide’ in the new movie titled Glass, with Unbreakable’s Samuel L Jackson taking a lead role alongside Bruce Willis and Split’s James McAvoy

Andrew Pulver

27, Apr, 2017 @11:26 AM

Article image
Unbreakable at 20: the film that finally took superheroes seriously
M Night Shyamalan’s 2000 fantasy drama showed that superhero narratives can be told with patience and a straight face which changed the genre forever

Charles Bramesco

23, Nov, 2020 @2:35 PM

Article image
Glass review – M Night Shyamalan's superheroes assemble
The director unites Samuel L Jackson, Bruce Willis and James McAvoy from earlier films in a pointless supernatural sequel

Peter Bradshaw

17, Jan, 2019 @6:00 AM

Article image
Glass review – an entertaining end to M Night Shyamalan’s superhero trilogy
Samuel L Jackson’s villain gets his origin story as the Unbreakable and Split characters join in the fun

Simran Hans

20, Jan, 2019 @8:00 AM


Philip French: ...a film to see, to enjoy, and perhaps to ponder

Philip French

31, Dec, 2000 @3:37 PM

Article image
Shattered Glass: why we need to stop deconstructing our superheroes
M Night Shyamalan’s ambitious yet empty end to his comic book-inspired trilogy should be the last attempt to make faux-intellectual points about big screen heroes

Zach Vasquez

17, Jan, 2019 @8:00 AM

Article image
My favourite film aged 12: The Sixth Sense
M Night Shyamalan’s ghost story terrified me to my teenage core – and ignited a love for clever storytelling

Rachel Hall

03, Jun, 2020 @6:00 AM

Bad break

Unbreakable reunites Bruce Willis and M Night Shyamalan following The Sixth Sense. But lightning has failed to strike twice, says Joe Queenan

23, Dec, 2000 @2:02 PM

Article image
The Sixth Sense at 20: the smash hit that remains impossible to define
M Night Shyamalan’s somber breakout brought him critical and commercial acclaim and gave us one of cinema’s most talked about twists

Scott Tobias

06, Aug, 2019 @5:00 AM

Article image
Bruce Willis and M Night Shyamalan to reunite for Labour of Love

Sixth Sense collaborators in talks to bring Shyamalan's screenplay about a man who walks across the US as love letter to late wife

Ben Child

30, Jan, 2014 @12:54 PM