Marcel Carné: Les Enfants du Paradis

"What a strange and sad fate - to be universally acclaimed as the director of several of the finest films ever made, and to go on making films to which no one pays any attention." So wrote Richard Roud, my predecessor as Guardian film critic, of Marcel Carné, the maker of Les Enfants du Paradis.

"What a strange and sad fate - to be universally acclaimed as the director of several of the finest films ever made, and to go on making films to which no one pays any attention." So wrote Richard Roud, my predecessor as Guardian film critic, of Marcel Carné, the maker of Les Enfants du Paradis.

Roud added that Les Enfants was to 30s French cinema what Gone With The Wind was to American cinema: a fully realised expression of the period, and also the death-knell for a certain kind of cinema some people wish we still had now.

Les Enfants du Paradis was inspired by the popular theatre of the 19th century, and translated into an epic cinematic romance that will probably never be equalled for both substance and style. Three of its extraordinary gallery of characters, are based on historical figures - the pantomime artist Baptiste Debureau, the romantic actor Frederick Lemaitre and the criminal Lacenaire. Each falls in love with, and is briefly loved by Garance, a beautiful actress who leaves them only when her freedom is threatened by their attempts to possess her.

They meet in the neighbourhood of the Funambules theatre in Paris, sometimes called the Boulevard du Crime, which was reconstructed, amazingly enough considering that the Nazis were occupying Paris, at great expense and with sets stretching over a quarter of a mile. Actually the Germans encouraged the production which caused it to be either sabotaged or halted when various members of the cast could not be found. Some of them, working for the Resistance, had their scenes shot secretly. And Carné and Prévert hid key reels from the occupiers hoping that, by the time the film was finished, Paris would be liberated.

Carné pointed out that "paradis" is the colloquial name for the theatre's gallery where the "real" people watched and vociferously commented upon their entertainments and to whom the actors pitched their performances. You could say the film is about freedom, symbolised by the sophisticated Garance, but it is as much about our reactions to what is going on, and the actors reactions to our own.

Certainly the performances are marvellous and superbly directed by Carné too, easily transcending Prévert's sometimes precious though undeniably skilful text. They are led by Arletty as Garance, an actress whose beauty and grace was matchless (she had posed for Braque and Matisse) and whose capacity to suggest not only the spirit of popular theatre, but also the "new woman" who needed and deserved her liberty, made her every moment vivid. She was jailed as a collaborator when Les Enfants opened, largely because she had had an affair with a Luftwaffe officer during the war.

But if Arletty is unforgettable, Jean-Louis Barrault as the pantomime artist (which he was in life), Pierre Brasseur as the romantic Lemaitre and Marcel Herrand as the criminal are very nearly as good, centering the huge canvas of the film securely for its three-hour duration. Cinema and poetry are the same thing, Prévert said in an interview before the film's first showing. Not always, alas. But it's surely true here.


Derek Malcolm

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Les Enfants du Paradis
Made in extraordinary circumstances during the Nazi occupation of France, Marcel Carné's epic enjoyed a triumphant reception at its premiere, writes Philip French

Philip French

22, Sep, 2012 @11:05 PM

Article image
Les Enfants du Paradis – review
The restoration of the French theatreland classic only improves a glorious narrative carousel, as gripping as any soap opera, writes Peter Bradshaw

Peter Bradshaw

10, Nov, 2011 @10:25 PM

Article image
Les Enfants du Paradis – review

Philip French welcomes a newly restored version of a romantic classic set in 1830s Paris

Philip French

13, Nov, 2011 @12:05 AM

Marcel Varnel: Oh, Mr Porter!

One of the biggest successes at the Paris Cinémathèque in the late 80s was a retrospective of British comedy curated by Bertrand Tavernier. Among the discoveries for the French was Will Hay, who, with his henchmen Graham Moffatt (the fat boy) and Moore Marriott (the wizened old codger), perfectly represented a certain type of bumbling British humour. One of the best of their films was Oh, Mr Porter! - and the French were pleased to find that it was directed by Paris-born Marcel Varnel. One of the great directors of British comedy in the 30s, Varnel considered Oh, Mr Porter! his best work

Derek Malcolm

27, Jul, 2000 @12:26 PM

Article image
La Performance review – bittersweet homage to Les Enfants du Paradis
A hazily defined relationship makes it hard to fathom the squabbles and romance in this wordless show inspired by 1940s French cinema

Mark Fisher

14, Oct, 2022 @10:06 AM

Orson Welles: A Touch of Evil

It might seem a trifle eccentric to nominate Orson Welles's A Touch Of Evil above Citizen Kane or The Magnificant Ambersons as one of the best 100 of all time. The film, now substantially restored the way Welles wanted it, is by no means his most ambitious. But it remains a mature, complex and endlessly fascinating example of film noir, a genre that has produced more satisfying movies than most others, precisely because of its seeming lack of pretension.

By Derek Malcolm

07, Jan, 1999 @3:57 PM

GW Pabst: Pandora's Box

[There is] an atmosphere of sexual delirium that pervades what was at that time a dangerously shocking film. It still remains an intensely sexy one. This was also expressionism put to use with unerring skill as a commentary on the social hypocrisy of the time

Derek Malcolm

22, Jul, 1999 @1:58 AM

Win A Century of Films

Tackle our quiz on the Century of Films for a chance to win one of five copies of Derek Malcolm's Personal Best: A Century of Films

Derek Malcolm

18, Jan, 2001 @12:17 PM

G2: Derek Malcolm concludes his Century of Film

Every Thursday for two years Derek Malcolm has been writing about his top 100 movies. He explains how he made his choice.

Derek Malcolm

18, Jan, 2001 @8:28 AM

Walt Disney: Fantasia

"Dull as it is towards the end, ridiculous as it is in the bend of the knee before Art, and taking one thing with another, it is one of the strange and beautiful things that have happened in the world."

Derek Malcolm

21, Oct, 1999 @10:39 AM