Can Anna Wintour survive fashion's reckoning with racism?

While Condé Nast has said the Vogue editor-in-chief will not be stepping down, turmoil has been mounting as employees past and present speak out

For decades she has stood astride the fashion industry, micromanaging the look and content of US Vogue, marshalling a significant part of the global fashion industry to her worldview, and presiding over an annual gala at which, for $25,000 a head, paying guests and favored courtiers mounted the lavishly carpeted steps of the Metropolitan Museum of Art to symbolically kiss the ring.

But for Anna Wintour this has been her annus horribilis. New York fashion week has been written off, the Met Gala has been cancelled, magazine advertising revenues are plummeting and there are scarcely any frocks to shoot since the coronavirus barged its way into the European fashion shows in February.

Yet now a crisis is breaking over Wintour, Vogue and the Condé Nast publishing empire: the reckoning with racism in America, triggered by the killing of George Floyd by a white police officer in Minneapolis, that has now spread to all aspects of American life, from publishing to academia to sports.

Last week, Condé Nast, the publisher of Vogue and other lifestyle glossy publications, was hit by charged criticism for failures to support diversity in the workplace and in terms of the content it typically publishes. With two senior editors leaving over racial insensitivity, and former employees describing the Vogue workplace as fearful, accounts of discrimination in the New York office of Condé Nast flood out.

Speculation mounted last week that Wintour’s position as Vogue’s editor-in-chief, as well as the publisher’s US artistic director and “global content adviser”, could be becoming untenable after several employees spoke out about racial discrimination in the workplace and pay inequities.

On Friday, Condé Nast’s top executive convened a town hall meeting of employees to say that Wintour would not be stepping down.

“There are very few people in the world who can have the influence on change and culture, as it relates to the activities that our business has, than Anna,” Condé Nast’s CEO, Roger Lynch, said. “The reason she is here is because she can help influence the change that we need to make, and I know she is committed to it.”

Mounting turmoil at the publisher in recent days has included the resignation of Adam Rapoport, the editor-in-chief of Bon Appétit magazine who reported to Wintour, over Instagram photos of Rapoport and his wife in a Latino version of brownface at a Halloween party in 2013. A public apology said staff members conceded that the magazine “continued to tokenize” the people of color that it did hire.

That was quickly followed by the exit of Condé Nast’s head of lifestyle video programming, Matt Duckor, after staffers claimed that Condé Nast failed to feature people of color in videos and did not pay them for appearances. A number of Duckor’s tweets with racist and homophobic comments were recirculated online.

Wintour has attempted to quell the tide of protest, admitting to making mistakes and publishing material that has been intolerant, as well as not doing enough to promote black staff and designers at the magazine. In a memo sent earlier this month, Wintour apologized to staff for “publishing images or stories that have been hurtful or intolerant” and admitted there were too few employees of color.

“I want to say plainly that I know Vogue has not found enough ways to elevate and give space to black editors, writers, photographers, designers and other creators. We have made mistakes too, publishing images or stories that have been hurtful or intolerant. I take full responsibility for those mistakes.”

But the letter was met with scorn by an African American former member of Vogue’s staff. Former colleague and ally André Leon Talley shared his views on Wintour’s email in a podcast interview.

“[Wintour’s] statement came out of the space of white privilege,” Talley said. “I want to say one thing: Dame Anna Wintour is a colonial broad, she’s a colonial dame, she comes from British, she’s part of an environment of colonialism. She is entitled and I do not think she will ever let anything get in the way of her white privilege.”

Others have followed suit with damning portrayals of the treatment of minorities within the company.

Former staffer Shelby Ivey Christie wrote on Twitter: “My time at Vogue, at Condé Nast, was the most challenging + miserable time of my career – The bullying + testing from white counterparts, the completely thankless work, the terrible base pay + the racism was exhausting.”

Wintour’s position may be further undermined by the appointment of Samira Nasr, formerly of Vanity Fair, as the first female black editor of rival Harper’s Bazaar. “As the proud daughter of a Lebanese father and Trinidadian mother, my worldview is expansive and is anchored in the belief that representation matters,” said Nasr in a video message.

British Vogue also has a minority editor, Edward Enninful, who has done much to steer the magazine away from predominantly featuring white subject material. In the current issue, Enninful commissioned a series of powerful portraits by Jamie Hawkesworth of women, often minorities, and often working in healthcare and other essential services on the frontlines of the Covid-19 pandemic.

The turmoil at Condé Nast comes as the magazine industry, as well as publishing in general, has been slammed by coronavirus-related advertising revenue drops of about 45%. In recent years, the publisher has cut or reduced publication of several titles and sublet six of its 23 floors at 1 World Trade Center.

Wintour will be hoping Condé Nast’s 10-member board of directors, headed by Lynch and made up by members of the Newhouse family and two independent directors, including the former Gucci CEO Domenico De Sole, continue to stand behind her, as they have for decades.

But some observers are not so sure.

“Fashion comes and goes,” one former glossy magazine editor, who declined to be identified, told the Guardian. “Magazine publishing and fashion were in deep trouble before all this. Will Anna get washed away in that flood? Probably.”

Contributor

Edward Helmore

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Anna Wintour defends Vogue's controversial Kamala Harris cover
Editor-in-chief of fashion magazine responds to online accusations of whitewashing and disrespecting the vice-president-elect

Priya Elan

12, Jan, 2021 @3:08 PM

Article image
Anna Wintour cements influence as Condé Nast's new artistic director

Famous Vogue editor takes on first of its kind role at publishing empire and ends speculation over role in Obama administration

Paul Harris in New York

13, Mar, 2013 @5:17 PM

Article image
Film reveals soft side to Vogue's icy style queen Anna Wintour

A new acclaimed documentary offers a revealing portrait of legendary American Vogue editor Anna Wintour

Amelia Hill

23, May, 2009 @11:01 PM

Article image
Anna Wintour apologises for not giving space to black editors at Vogue
Editor of fashion bible says sorry for printing ‘hurtful and intolerant’ stories and images

Morwenna Ferrier

10, Jun, 2020 @2:34 PM

Article image
Thirty years at Vogue: how Anna Wintour changed the way the world gets dressed
In her years as editor of American Vogue, Wintour has invented soft power dressing and become as famous as her celebrity cover stars. Lionised and satirised, respected and feared – could she now be ready to abdicate?

Jess Cartner-Morley

05, Sep, 2018 @8:44 AM

Article image
Vogue has a race problem. It can't be fixed with a few token black models | Priya Elan
Anna Wintour has apologized to black creatives for their treatment at the magazine. But will words turn into actions?

Priya Elan

16, Jun, 2020 @10:30 AM

Article image
Why Anna Wintour is closing in on that top diplomatic job
The White House has not denied that the Vogue editor will be its UK ambassador – and she might be ready for the role, reports Paul Harris

Paul Harris in New York

08, Dec, 2012 @12:45 PM

Article image
Lindsay Peoples Wagner: taking the hard road to the height of fashion
The trailblazing young magazine chief and champion of diversity wants to open up the style world to real people

Edward Helmore

04, Sep, 2021 @2:00 PM

Article image
Si Newhouse, media baron who ran Condé Nast, dies aged 89
Vogue’s Anna Wintour pays tribute to ‘most extraordinary leader’ who also ran magazines including Vanity Fair and the New Yorker

Martin Pengelly and agencies

01, Oct, 2017 @8:22 PM

Article image
GQ editor to leave men’s style bible in Condé Nast cull
Dylan Jones is latest casualty of editorial clearout at publisher after 22 years at helm of men’s monthly

Priya Elan & Vanessa Thorpe

16, May, 2021 @7:15 AM