Red-carpet revolt? No, the Oscars will always be about the dress

Actresses and designers want publicity. This drives the Oscars obsession with fashion and it will never change

I read an article earlier this year in an American newspaper that said “a revolt” was beginning on the red carpet among female celebrities. Did this revolt happen?
Caroline, by email

Oh my God, Caroline, how could you have missed it? It was veritable bloodshed at the Oscars, I tell you – bloodshed! Julianne Moore decapitated E!’s Giuliana Rancic for asking “Who are you wearing?”; Reese Witherspoon stabbed Ryan Seacrest when he tried to put her hand in the mani-cam, and Patricia Arquette turned up in a burlap sack, flummoxing fashion editors who weren’t sure if she was making a statement or was this made-to-order Balenciaga? Behind all the carnage, the rest of the female celebrities marched down waving banners and chanting slogans: “No, no, we won’t go, the red carpet is a load of bull!”

I jest. Nothing of the sort happened. There has been talk for some time of an imminent red-carpet revolution, including, I’m proud to say, in this very column, which last year promised a full-on massacre of entertainment journalists. The New York Times, which always takes its editorial direction from this column, followed a year later (try to keep up, New York Times!), promising that “On the red carpet, a revolt builds over pageantry.”

And did this revolt happen? In all honesty, it did not. There were some half-hearted changes from the Oscars red-carpet coverage this year – E! ditched the mani-cam and there was a vague attempt on the part of some entertainment journalists to ask female celebrities about something other than their dresses. #askhermore, urged the social media hashtag (and you just knew there’d be a hashtag behind this, didn’t you? It’s a wonder how the suffragettes got off the ground without one). Unfortunately, no one remembered until it was too late that the only subjects most US actresses like to talk to journalists about, when not shilling clothes, are their amazing charitable contributions, how wonderful and amazing everyone they work with is and what an incredible calling the acting profession truly is. Great TV this does not make, and while watching women being commanded to flaunt their manicures wasn’t much fun either, I don’t think anyone watching the Oscars was convinced we’d arrived at a long-term solution.

It is, clearly, ridiculous that actors are expected to gussy themselves up like My Little Ponies to go to what is essentially an industry event, and that careers can be made and broken by the choosing of a dress. But that is the nature of the beast that has been built by the media, fashion designers and, yes, female celebrities working in cahoots, and not one of them is willing to break this bond. After all, celebrities have long since crossed over into being fashion models, as a glance at the covers of fashion magazines, which are now dominated by actors, not models, proves.

Reese Witherspoon was especially outspoken this year about the need for actresses to be asked about more than their clothes: “Let’s hear their stories!” she battlecried before the Oscars. As she finished battlecrying, she put down her megaphone and posed for a photo in her Oscars outfit, which she tweeted, detailing the source of everything she was wearing, from her dress to her jewels to something she referred to as her “glow”. The other female celebrities were similarly keen to give shout-outs to their designers. Perhaps those are their stories?

And just to prove that nothing’s really changed, E!’s indefatigable Rancic was so characteristically tenacious in her fashion criticism about the Oscars that one particular opinion verged on racist when she snarked that US actor Zendaya’s dreadlocks looked like they smelled of marijuana. Rancic later apologised, although in today’s social media climate I’m not sure if she felt bad about the racism or the failure to #askhermore.

Reese Witherspoon 2015 Oscars
To the barricades? Reese Witherspoon at the Oscars. Photograph: Broadimage/Rex

No one looks to the Oscars for guidance about movies. If your innocence wasn’t destroyed when Crash won best film, then it must have been when Boyhood didn’t. For heaven’s sake, have you seen the people of the academy who vote for this? They make the Republican party look demographically diverse. No, the Oscars has become completely about the clothes, and this is because the media cover the event, female celebrities know they can get extra publicity by looking good and designers will take any free advertising they can get. The morning after, I turned on the TV in Los Angeles and, while reading analysis of the dresses in the New York Times, the LA Times and the British press, I was able to flick between – no exaggeration – five TV programmes debating the merits of the dresses. No one, it seemed, was too interested in the actors’ “stories”, but they were all fascinated by Julianne Moore’s gown: some of them liked it and – waddyaknow! – some of them didn’t, suggesting fashion analysis is not the objective scientific study it is sometimes portrayed as being.

I recently interviewed the wonderful Angela Lansbury. She recalled that, the first time she went to the Oscars, in 1945, there was no press on the red carpet. She wore a simple dress she’d bought, took her mother as her date and got on with her night. No matter how many social media hashtags are coined, the media still values female celebrities by their looks, and so do the vast majority of people who consume the media (not you. You’re far more intellectual). So, until the media stop covering the red carpet, it will always about the dress. And when will the media stop covering the red carpet, obsessing over actress’s looks and reducing them to show ponies? I can exclusively reveal that it will be at 10 past never.

Post your questions to Hadley Freeman, Ask Hadley, The Guardian, Kings Place, 90 York Way, London N1 9GU. Email


Hadley Freeman

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Oscars 2011: How to talk about red-carpet fashion

The guide to saying 'Wow, that is so Prada 2007' and other useful phrases for the Academy Awards. Plus, how to become a style icon

Hadley Freeman

27, Feb, 2011 @10:45 PM

Article image
Oscars 2015: The red carpet, ceremony and reaction as it happens
It was the year that Birdman triumphed – but all the best picture nominees left with something. Relive all the best dresses, tuxes, speeches, tweets and memes

Stuart Heritage, Hadley Freeman, Peter Bradshaw, Imogen Fox, Hannah Marriott, Rory Carroll, Ben Beaumont-Thomas, Benjamin Lee , Steven W ThrasherHenry Barnes, Catherine Shoard

23, Feb, 2015 @7:54 AM

Article image
Oscars fashion: fall, dance or photobomb – how to win the red carpet

Jess Cartner-Morley: The winners on the red carpet this year knew that personality trumps aloof glamour

Jess Cartner-Morley

03, Mar, 2014 @1:47 PM

Article image
Oscars 2014: the night I got hugged by Bill Murray at the Vanity Fair party

How I beat the dress code, took selfies on the red carpet and watched Jane Fonda dance to Chic

Hadley Freeman

03, Mar, 2014 @5:25 PM

Article image
Oscars 2014 red carpet fashion – rated

The standout looks from the red carpet – rated and reviewed by the Guardian fashion team

Jess Cartner-Morley and Imogen Fox

03, Mar, 2014 @4:06 AM

Article image
Starry, starry night: Oscar winners on Hollywood’s biggest prize
Susan Sarandon thinks it’s the luck of the draw, Juliette Binoche tussled with Lauren Bacall, and someone stood on Ben Kingsley’s head: 14 Oscar winners reveal what really goes on at the Academy Awards

Interviews by Abigail Radnor, Rosie Ifould, Simon Hattenstone and Hadley Freeman; portraits by Pål Hansen, Chris Buck, Roberto Frankenberg, Reed Young and John Lee; produced by Troy Griggs and Daan Louter

07, Feb, 2015 @8:00 AM

Article image
Why boobs are massive on the red carpet in 2015
The stars are flashing cleavage as if the 1970s never went away – what does this extreme trend mean for the rest of us?

Hadley Freeman

09, Feb, 2015 @3:48 PM

Article image
Red-carpet fashion at Oscars 2019: 'A bright pink confetti explosion'
Rachel Weisz won hearts and minds, Lady Gaga went conventional and the gender-fluid ‘gown-cedo’ made its debut … but one colour dominated

Jess Cartner-Morley

25, Feb, 2019 @7:48 AM

Article image
Awards season fashion? Expect to see a lot of bland full-length gowns
As Oscar season approaches, it's worth remembering that the red carpet is to fashion what Twitter is to reasoned discourse – it dilutes it to a series of easily digestible and forgettable hits

Hadley Freeman

14, Jan, 2013 @2:07 PM

Article image
The Oscars: showcasing Hollywood’s generous sense of global obligation
What lessons can the Oscars of the travel industry or the Oscars of the golf service industry learn from Hollywood about making the world a better place?

Marina Hyde

26, Feb, 2015 @5:28 PM