Hinkley Point nuclear power station: a new type of nationalisation

A third of British infrastructure now is in the hands of foreign companies, often largely state-owned. Is nationalisation OK as long as someone else is doing it?

Rejoice! Britain's first new nuclear power station in a generation is to be built at Hinkley Point in Somerset, and David Cameron could not be happier. "This is a very big day for our country," he said yesterday, "the first time we've built a new nuclear power station for a very long time."

There is only one snag: "we" are not building it at all. Thanks to an amazingly cushy 35-year deal agreed with the government, the plant to be known as Hinkley C is the responsibility of a consortium largely split between the French energy giant EDF and two Chinese setups, the China General Nuclear Power Group and the China National Nuclear Corporation. EDF is 85% owned by the French government; the Chinese state owns all of the latter two companies. Nationalisation, it seems, is back – only it's a new kind, whereby it is overseas governments who get to buy up our national assets.

Just look at the evidence. At the last official count, a third of British infrastructure was overseas-owned – but what's particularly interesting is the amount of government money involved. EDF – it stands for Électricité de France – already owns two British coal-fired power stations, eight UK nuclear plants and a couple of British wind farms. Germany's Deutsche Bahn is a 100% state-owned railway company, and since 2010, it has also owned Arriva, which controls an array of British bus services as well as the majority of trains that run in Wales, and a whole load that serve Birmingham (prior to buying Arriva, DB had already bought the Chiltern main line, overground services in London and Tyne and Wear Metro).

DP World owns 60 or so ports across the planet, including the Port of London and the Port of Southampton – and is controlled by Dubai World, an investment company that acts on behalf of Dubai's government. The state-backed China Investment Corporation owns nearly 10% of Thames Water and a similar-sized chunk of Ferrovial, the Spanish-owned conglomerate that has a big stake in the airports at Heathrow, Southampton, Glasgow and Aberdeen. Those airports are also 20% owned by Qatar Holding, which slings money around on behalf of Qatar's rulers. Oh, and just to bring things up to date, among the big investors that bought thousands of shares in Royal Mail were sovereign wealth funds whose money comes from the governments of Kuwait and Singapore.

The Hinkley Point deal is traceable to a memorandum of understanding on infrastructure investment, agreed by the governments of China and the UK in 2011, and boosted by George Osborne's recent trip to Beijing (where he announced that another state-owned Chinese company is to get involved in Manchester airport). There will, it seems, be much more of this stuff – not least, perhaps, when it comes to the new high-speed rail line that will run between London and Birmingham and beyond. Among the firms who are interested in a piece of that particular action are the state-owned China Railway Group, though while in China, Osborne said talks about all that were "for another day".

Strange, perhaps, that the same Tories who warn of the perils of government intervention in the economy and our supposed loss of sovereignty to the wicked old EU should be going down this road, but there we are: state ownership is obviously fine, so long as it's someone else's state that's doing it.


John Harris

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Hinkley Point C nuclear power station gets government green light
Labour and environmental groups say new safeguards for foreign investment are merely ‘window dressing’

Rowena Mason and Simon Goodley

15, Sep, 2016 @3:00 PM

Article image
Hinkley nuclear power station gets go-ahead as coalition signs off EDF deal

Building to commence on Britain's first nuclear power station in 20 years as government hands subsidy to French company

Patrick Wintour

21, Oct, 2013 @7:32 AM

Article image
New Hinkley Point nuclear power station may be further delayed
France’s EDF gives no definite schedule for construction of £24.5bn plant, which still awaits firm’s final investment decision

Terry Macalister

03, Sep, 2015 @6:05 PM

Article image
Hinkley Point C nuclear power plant decision delayed again by EDF
French economy minister says the energy giant’s green light on the £18bn project is now not expected until September

Rob Davies

24, Apr, 2016 @5:34 PM

Article image
Hinkley Point: Osborne seeks to ease doubts with £2bn guarantee
Chancellor calls project a ‘win-win-win’ as he seeks to calm anxieties over Chinese involvement in controversial nuclear plant

Tom Phillips in Beijing and Katie Allen and Terry Macalister in London

20, Sep, 2015 @11:01 PM

Article image
Planned Hinkley Point nuclear power station under fire from energy industry
Energy analyst says that for same price as Hinkley Point C, providing 3,200MW of capacity, almost 50,000MW of gas-fired power capacity could be built

Nils Pratley and Sean Farrell

09, Aug, 2015 @7:16 PM

Article image
Hinkley Point nuclear plant still on track, ministers insist
UK and French governments say project will go ahead despite uncertainties prompted by row at its main backer, EDF Energy

Rob Davies, Kim Willsher in Paris and Sean Farrell

07, Mar, 2016 @7:46 PM

Article image
Pro-nuclear environmentalists in call to scrap Hinkley C plans
Three leading experts urge government to end nuclear project saying delays will create panicked scramble back to fossil fuels

Terry Macalister

18, Sep, 2015 @2:03 PM

Article image
Hinkley Point nuclear plant building costs rise by up to £2.9bn
EDF Energy blames ground conditions for rise but says energy bills will not go up

Jillian Ambrose Energy correspondent

25, Sep, 2019 @4:38 PM

Article image
Hinkley nuclear power station delay deals blow to government hopes
Earthwork preparation of Hinkley site put back as election of Francois Hollande as French president hits confidence

Damian Carrington

14, May, 2012 @3:05 PM