Australian period underwear makers deny using ‘forever chemicals’ after Thinx settles suit in US

Modibodi and Bonds say they avoid using PFAS chemicals, which break down slowly over time and have unclear health impacts

Australian manufacturers of period underwear have denied using “forever chemicals” in their products following a class-action lawsuit in the US, while experts say more research is needed into the compounds and their potential health impacts.

Thinx, a US manufacturer of menstrual hygiene products, announced last week that it had reached a settlement in a class-action lawsuit over allegations “regarding the presence of short chain per-and polyfluoroalkyl substances (‘PFAS’)” in its underwear.

Thinx said the settlement was “not an admission of guilt or wrongdoing”, and that PFAS had “never been a part of its product design, and that it will continue to take measures to help ensure that PFAS are not intentionally added to Thinx Period Underwear at any stage of production”.

The manufacturer had marketed its period underwear as “organic, sustainable and nontoxic”, but independent analysis in 2020 suggested the presence of PFAS in Thinx products.

PFAS are often referred to as “forever chemicals” because they persist in the environment for long periods of time and break down extremely slowly.

Regulators across the world have introduced some PFAS bans, including on PFOA (also known as C8), PFOS and PFHxS, out of concerns for their potential health impacts. A large epidemiological study has found, for example, that exposure to PFOA may be associated with conditions including testicular and kidney cancer, thyroid disease and pregnancy-induced hypertension.

Australian manufacturers of period underwear contacted by Guardian Australia have ruled out the presence of PFAS in their goods.

The undergarment company Modibodi said it used a combination of fabrics and specific sewing techniques to make leak-proof linings in its products. “Modibodi does not design products that require the functionality of PFAS,” it said in a statement.

“While there are some variations across styles, our lining layers include 100% Merino wool for its breathability and natural odour control, polyester/polymamide for absorbency and a thin polyester layer for its lightness and durability.”

“We don’t use PFAS and test our fabrics and products to Oeko-tex Standard 100, which tests for PFAS.”

Kelly McBride, the general marketing manager at Bonds, said the company had an extensive restricted substances list. “In developing our Bonds Bloody Comfy Period Undies, PFAS chemistry was deliberately avoided,” she said.

Cotton On did not respond to a request for comment.

PFAS are common in consumer products. “Most of us will have had some sort of background exposure to PFAS, and that’s through basically everything that claims water-repellent properties,” said Prof Brett Nixon of the University of Newcastle. “Things like Gore-Tex, things like nonstick fry paints, things such as Scotchgard that are used as stain repellents on carpets and other fabrics.”

Experts said much more research was needed into the potential impacts of PFAS.

“[The impact of] low-dose chronic exposure is somewhat unclear, as many toxicity studies have investigated toxic effects at elevated concentrations,” said Prof Albert Juhasz, a researcher at the University of South Australia who focuses on the impact of legacy and emerging contaminants on environmental and human health.

“The so-called legacy PFAS that are being phased out are the longer chain ones,” Nixon said. “They’re the ones that have been studied in the context of human health in most detail.”

“What they’re replacing them with are shorter chain or branched chain PFAS. But the reality is that most of those haven’t been investigated at any level,” he said. “The new generation of PFAS chemicals that are replacing them aren’t proven to be any necessarily safer or less long-lasting [in the environment].”


Donna Lu

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Australian government lowers safe exposure levels of toxic firefighting chemicals
Move brings tolerable daily intake levels in line with US standards and follows months of controversy over contaminations near airports and military bases

Helen Davidson in Darwin

03, Apr, 2017 @8:55 AM

Article image
Toxic firefighting chemicals 'the most seminal public health challenge'
US environmental official says chemical found is firefighting foam is contaminating water supplies

Christopher Knaus

18, Oct, 2017 @4:52 AM

Article image
How ‘forever chemicals’ are using marine life to travel the world by sea
First it was PCBs, now it’s PFAS – harmful toxic pollutants that don’t biodegrade are affecting ecosystems around the globe

Anna Turns

14, Feb, 2022 @12:01 PM

Article image
Australian women with endometriosis face six-year wait for diagnosis, study finds
Experts call for ‘dedicated women’s pain services’ after survey finds people often undergo surgeries that fail to improve their chronic agony

Melissa Davey

22, Oct, 2020 @12:55 AM

Article image
Australian food is grown with dangerous chemicals banned in other countries
Australia has a global reputation as a source of clean food. In fact, the country has some of the most lax regulation of pesticide use in the western world

Anne Davies

26, Sep, 2022 @5:30 PM

Article image
Free pads and tampons now available to all Victorian public school students in Australian first
The initiative aims to boost inclusivity and break down ‘the stigma of periods’

Elias Visontay

28, Jul, 2020 @6:29 AM

Article image
Pro-tobacco lobbyists circle Australian government’s proposed vaping reforms
As the TGA considers at least 4,000 submissions, tobacco companies appear to be heightening lobbying efforts

Melissa Davey Medical editor

20, Mar, 2023 @12:45 AM

Article image
Deaths from Covid in Australian aged care pass 5,000 after monthly fatalities double in January
Department of Health says significant jump to 597 deaths from 22 December to 25 January was partially influenced by a change in reporting methodology

Henry Belot

02, Feb, 2023 @11:00 PM

Article image
‘Relatively common’: WA’s lost-and-found radioactive capsule not the only missing material around
The tiny capsule that fell out of a Perth-bound truck captured the world’s attention, but experts say hundreds of radioactive sources go missing each year

Tory Shepherd

02, Feb, 2023 @2:00 PM

Article image
Smoke exposure from intense fires linked to long-term respiratory and cardiovascular disease
Scientists studying 2014 Hazelwood coalmine fire say breathing in tiny particles is linked to increased emergency presentations

Donna Lu

14, Feb, 2023 @2:00 PM