Tesco chicken supplier should pay to clean up River Wye, says charity

Campaigners urge leading poultry producer Avara Foods to fund reparations for pollution from its chicken farm suppliers

Avara Foods, a leading supplier of chicken to Tesco, is being urged by campaigners to pay reparations to help clean up the River Wye.

The Wye, a river running from mid-Wales to the Severn estuary, has been affected by increasing algal blooms. These are partly caused by poultry farms spreading more manure than the land can absorb, say scientists, leading to excess phosphorus leaching into waterways.

Avara Foods is responsible for more than 16 million of the 20 million chickens reared in the Wye catchment, which has seen a surge in chicken numbers over the past two decades.

The company recently announced a plan promising that by 2025, its supply chain would “not contribute to excess phosphate in the River Wye”. However, clean river campaigners say that that is not enough.

Last month, one of Avara’s joint owners, the US food giant Cargill, lost a court case in the US and was held responsible for polluting the Illinois River with poultry manure. The companies have until mid March to reach an agreement with the state of Oklahoma on how they will work to remedy the pollution’s effects, which included algal blooms.

Campaigners say the US court ruling sets an example and that Avara now needs to pay for cleaning up the River Wye.

“It is time that Avara committed to paying to restore the Wye as a matter of urgency. The principle of ‘the polluter pays’ should apply here just as it does in America,” said Richard Tyler of campaign group Save the Wye.

Avara has said it is its chicken suppliers rather than the company itself that applies poultry manure to the land, and that “the excess phosphate in the Wye arises from a significant number of producers and users in the catchment – of whom we are but one”.

However, the company’s new plan pledges to introduce “more robust nutrient, soil and manure management standards” that would export more manure out of the river catchment and ensure its poultry waste will only be spread on land in the area when there is evidence it is needed.

Avara told the Guardian that it had not determined how its stricter standards would be independently verified and upheld, but that it would welcome greater regulation and enforcement from environmental agencies.

The company claims to have reduced phosphate in its poultry feed by 27% since 2016, yet it also significantly expanded production over that period, putting millions more birds into the Wye catchment.

Scientists have recommended reducing overall bird numbers in the region, but Avara said this was not on its agenda.

“There’s a continued demand for meat. There is no signal out there that says stop and cut back. We’re serving the consumer. If we didn’t produce [chicken meat] here, it would be imported,” Avara’s agricultural director John Reed said.

The US court ruling against Avara’s joint owner Cargill stated that the company had known since the 1980s about the damaging effects to rivers of phosphorus in poultry manure and yet continued to allow its manure to be applied to the land without any appropriate management.

In 2004, Cargill took out newspaper advertisements which appeared to promise to develop nutrient management standards and reduce the amount of poultry litter applied within the watershed by exporting more manure out of the area.

Avara said its own plan was “based on the individual circumstances of the Wye and the nature of our supply chain within it”.

The US lawsuit was filed in 2005, and while the trial ended in 2009, it has taken 13 years for the ruling to be given by the judge.

Interactive

Paul Withers professor of catchment biogeochemistry at Lancaster University said that past applications of manures and fertilisers had created a legacy of phosphorus in Wye catchment soils that would “continue to leak into the river for many years”.

A spokesperson for Avara said the company was focused on supporting projects that created “economically viable alternatives to spreading manure on the land, while working to establish independent standards for soil and nutrient management for any manure from our supply chain put on the land.”

The spokesperson added: “Improving the condition of the Wye will not only require action from all producers, it will require credible solutions that allow arable farming in the area to thrive without the need for excess phosphate or other nutrients. Without this, our product will simply be replaced with another.”

Charles Watson, chair of the charity River Action, said the lack of any robust regulatory framework to monitor and police Avara’s proposed solutions was “clearly a huge issue”.

“Also, as these mitigations are finally implemented, the debate will have to move on to the need for these self-confessed polluters to pay the necessary reparations to help restore the river to its former natural state. In this regard, the US ruling sets for the Wye an intriguing precedent.”

A spokesperson for Tesco said it wascommitted to playing our part in ensuring the protection of the River Wye, alongside other actors across the food industry”.

• The main image on this story was replaced on 3 February 2023, as the original picture featured a logistics company that was unconnected to the content of the story.

Contributors

Nicola Cutcher and Tom Levitt

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
How a Tesco chicken deal may have helped pollute one of the UK’s favourite rivers
The River Wye flows through Herefordshire where bird numbers – and their waste – surged in the year after the supermarket signed a deal with a local processor, Guardian investigation shows

Nicola Cutcher, Tom Levitt and Robin Eveleigh

14, Jul, 2022 @5:15 AM

Article image
Tesco suppliers must raise standards to avert death of River Wye, say campaigners
River Action warns of phosphates in excrement produced by intensive chicken farming suffocating life

Sandra Laville

07, Jul, 2022 @6:00 AM

Article image
Chicken farm giant linked to River Wye decline was sued over water blight in US
Cargill was taken to court 20 years ago in Oklahoma over the same pollution issue it is now linked to in UK

Robin Eveleigh and Jon Ungoed-Thomas

25, Sep, 2022 @5:00 AM

Article image
Tesco drops Irish supplier over horsemeat scandal
Tesco drops Silvercrest for 'breach of trust' after it supplied meat with up to 29% equine DNA that had come from Poland

James Meikle and Felicity Lawrence

30, Jan, 2013 @2:15 PM

Article image
River Cottage v Tesco - celebrity chef's chicken crusade hijacks investor meeting

Protests over turtles and treatment of US workers, but Fearnley-Whittingstall loses poultry welfare vote

David Teather

27, Jun, 2008 @11:01 PM

Article image
Retailers move to reassure consumers over chicken safety after drug seizure
A shipment of Chinese antibiotics, headed for a Northern Ireland poultry farm, has sparked an investigation into food security

Tom Levitt

23, Oct, 2019 @2:18 PM

Article image
Walmart selling beef from firm linked to Amazon deforestation
Exclusive: US chains Walmart, Costco and Kroger selling Brazilian beef produced by JBS linked to destruction of Brazilian rainforest

Andrew Wasley and Alexandra Heal

13, Feb, 2021 @7:00 AM

Article image
Landmark decision on mega poultry farm could mean ‘life or death’ of River Wye
Welsh government considers whether to block plan after experts say manure from intensive units is turning Wye into ‘pea soup’

Nicola Cutcher

10, Jan, 2023 @6:30 AM

Article image
WWF shelved report exposing River Wye pollution ‘to keep Tesco happy’
The wildlife charity allegedly dropped a study highlighting farm pollution linked to the supply chain of its former supermarket partner

Jon Ungoed-Thomas

02, Mar, 2024 @6:00 PM

Article image
The end of dairy’s ‘dirty secret’? Farms have a year to stop killing male calves
Supermarket support and rising use of sexed semen expected to help UK farmers meet new welfare rules by the end of 2021

Tom Levitt

10, Dec, 2020 @6:15 AM