Animals we’ve lost: the vivid ‘waving’ frog that vanished suddenly

Chiriquí harlequin frogs went extinct in 1996 due to a fungal disease that has driven the decline of 501 amphibian species

It was a remarkably elaborate mating ritual. When a male Chiriquí harlequin frog found its mate, it would climb on to the female’s back, grip its armpits with its forelimbs and hug it. Females of the species were often twice as large as the males, and they would remain in this mating clasp for days or even months – depending on when the female was ready to lay her eggs. During this time, the male might forgo eating and lose up to 30% of its body weight, but it was willing to wait.

It has been almost 30 years since a scientist last witnessed this act. In 2019, with little fanfare, the species was declared extinct.

Once, the Chiriquí harlequin frog (Atelopus chiriquiensis), which, scientifically speaking, was a toad, could be found in abundance in the wet highland forests of Costa Rica and Panama, usually where mean annual rainfall exceeds 4,000mm. In February 1994, when Erik Lindquist, an American biologist, visited La Amistad international park linking the two countries, he heard them calling from all over, and frantically counted 113 Chiriquí harlequin frogs within a 10-metre stretch of creek.

“You kind of realise, oh my goodness, I may be stepping on some, because they’re just everywhere,” he recalls.

Despite being classified as a toad, it didn’t look like one. It had smooth, not warty, skin. Its vivid colouration – it could be green, yellow, rust brown or grey, with lavender or red mottling – warned predators of its toxicity. It preferred meandering on dry land to swimming.

Lindquist saw some of them “waving” their forelimbs at others, perhaps to avoid fights, or as a mating behaviour. “I’ve also seen females signal to males, like, hey, come get me, kind of thing,” he says, laughing.

Yet when Lindquist returned to the area just three months later, the streams were silent.

This decline in numbers was also being observed in other protected sites and with other frog species in Central America. In 1996, at the Fortuna forest reserve in Panama, the American herpetologist Karen Lips found 54 dead or dying frogs belonging to 10 species from four streams, when their numbers had been abundant just a year earlier. She described dying frogs expiring in her hands after a short struggle to escape and dead ones being “frozen” in their normal calling positions.

That year – 1996 – marked the last year a Chiriquí harlequin frog was ever seen, anywhere in the world. It vanished so suddenly that any last-ditch attempts to save it via captive breeding were impossible.

Scientists found this sudden and widespread disappearance of frogs in Central America perplexing, since it was occurring in protected forests and could not be attributed to habitat loss. In 1999, Lips landed on the culprit: a fungal disease that infects a frog’s skin, stopping it from breathing and regulating its water levels, causing its heart to fail. Harlequin frogs are particularly susceptible to the fungus since they favour cool, moist habitat that is conducive to its growth.

The disease, native to Asia and, perhaps, unintentionally introduced elsewhere as part of the global wildlife trade, continues to threaten amphibian species. It has reportedly devastated global biodiversity more than any other disease ever recorded, having driven the decline of 501 amphibian species, of which 90 are presumed extinct in the wild.

But there is still a sliver of hope.

“At least some frog species in Costa Rica have been found again in places that we thought they had disappeared from, and some have been found in new localities,” says Federico Bolaño, a local biologist.

Encouraged, scientists continue to visit the known habitats of vanished frogs, hoping they will find survivors. However, according to Jorge Rodríguez-Matamoros, a Costa Rican conservationist: “The new populations tend to be very small, and the species continue to be fragile to extinction.”

Experts also think climate change may have compromised the frogs’ immunity or altered how the disease survives and spreads in some way.

The loss is personal for biologists like Lindquist. “These frogs are a little bit special for me because they were everywhere,” he says. “And then they weren’t.”


Emily Ding

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Frog back from the dead helps fight plans for mine in Ecuador
Campaigners say if copper mine gets go-ahead in cloud forest, the longnose harlequin, once thought to be extinct, will be threatened again

Graeme Green

23, Nov, 2021 @11:00 AM

Article image
One of world's rarest toads bred in captivity for first time in Manchester
Programme may help to ensure the survival of the critically endangered variable harlequin toad

Phoebe Weston

07, Mar, 2021 @6:30 PM

Article image
‘Gamechanging’ £10m environmental DNA project to map life in world’s rivers
eBioAtlas programme aims to identify fish, birds, amphibians and land animals in freshwater systems from the Ganges to the Mekong

Patrick Greenfield

16, Jun, 2021 @11:01 PM

Article image
Counting the species: how DNA barcoding is rewriting the book of life
We do not know how many species live on Earth. Barcoding could change that – and open the way for incredible discoveries

Patrick Greenfield

07, Oct, 2020 @10:38 AM

Article image
Animal crossings: the ecoducts helping wildlife navigate busy roads across the world
India’s tiger corridor and Australia’s possum ‘tunnel of love’ are among the myiad infrastructure projects providing safe passage

Patrick Greenfield

29, Dec, 2021 @10:15 AM

Article image
Dancing, starry dwarf and narrow-mouthed: new species make India a frog paradise
Dozens of discoveries in recent years have shown the country to be a treasure trove of amphibians

Kalpana Sunder in Chennai

21, Sep, 2021 @6:00 AM

Article image
Juliet and friends found for Romeo the lonely water frog
Five frogs found on Bolivian expedition funded through lonely hearts profile

Damian Carrington Environment editor

15, Jan, 2019 @5:49 PM

Article image
Frog goes extinct, media yawns
Is the loss of a unique life form on Earth big news? Not according to most media outlets. But how can the public care about global mass extinction if they aren’t even told about its victims?

Jeremy Hance

27, Oct, 2016 @7:23 AM

Article image
Lost and found: the rediscovery that became ‘Leonardo DiCaprio’s frog’
The longnose harlequin frog, not seen since the 1980s, was found again in 2016 and has since become a symbol of defiance against mining plans in the Intag Valley

Graeme Green

29, Dec, 2022 @4:00 PM

Article image
The final wave of the Panamanian golden frog

Conservationists are hoping they have not seen the last of this species in the wild after a fungal disease that swept through Central America decimated amphibian populations

Jessica Aldred

03, Sep, 2012 @6:00 AM