Why climate crisis means some English roses will bloom no longer

Award-winning rose varieties are being retired due to changing garden conditions and evolving pests

Think of the quintessential English garden and a rose will invariably spring to mind. Their sweet scent and plush petals have long been prized by gardeners, but now some of the most beloved varieties are being retired by growers due to climate breakdown and pests.

Though their use in gardens is thought to have originated in China and Iraq, for hundreds of years they have been a prize bloom across England. And the undisputed king of rose-growing in the past six decades has been David Austin, who died in 2018 but whose roses fill gardens all over the country with their colour and intoxicating smell. His company, which is still going, has said it is to retire some of its most well-loved species because they are no longer practicable to grow.

The ballet slipper pink blooms and fruity tea fragrance of A Shropshire Lad, a beautiful climbing rose, has won awards from the Royal Horticultural Society (RHS) since it went on sale in 1996. With its almost thornless stems and perfectly symmetrical petals, it soon became the climbing rose of choice from David Austin’s collection for those who wanted flowers with a pearly pink colour. But in recent weeks it has been removed from sale.

Tim Smith, the operations director at David Austin Roses, said: “We cannot stand still and observe as we see diseases and pests evolve as conditions and climates change, threatening the health and success of some of our most popular varieties.

Munstead Wood was only cultivated in 2007 but has been removed from sale.
Munstead Wood was only cultivated in 2007 but has been removed from sale. Photograph: AY Images/Alamy

“This means re-trialling all our releases and, in some instances, retiring very popular varieties eg A Shropshire Lad. Whilst these plants may still perform in some conditions, in the long term the changing conditions mean that we recommend alternative varieties that are better suited to the changing environment.

“Whilst this is not an easy decision and will in the short term result in lower revenue, we must take the brave decision to remove them.”

Another rose retired this year is the beloved and dramatic Munstead Wood, which has deep, velvety crimson petals and a classic old rose scent of blackberry and damson. Though it was only cultivated in 2007, so is a relatively new breed, it is thought pests have ravaged it, causing it to be removed from sale.

While once the main consideration for a perfect rose was its showy blooms and beautiful scent, horticulturalists are now selecting for climate resilience. Rose growers are now cultivating blooms in countries with more arid conditions, in order to ensure that as climate breakdown causes conditions to change in England, they do not lose their quality. Some growers are testing their flowers in hot, muggy areas including Florida in the US and in Shenzhen in China.

Simon Toomer, the curator of living collections at Kew Gardens, said: “The roses we see in gardens are the products of hundreds of years of plant breeding from wild species. Most of that breeding has been aimed at selecting showy, reliable flowers and scent.

Dame Judi Dench holds a disease-resistant apricot rose named in her honour.
Dame Judi Dench holds a disease-resistant apricot rose named in her honour. Photograph: Victoria Jones/PA

“As well as flower quality, selection has always been influenced by resistance to diseases such as black spot and powdery mildew. As the climate has changed rapidly over the last few years, especially wet mild springs and hot dry summers, these diseases have become more damaging. This is partly due to the fact that rose plants are less suited to the new climatic conditions so more susceptible to disease.”

Pests also thrive in the muggier conditions brought to England by the climate emergency. Toomer explained: “The humid conditions in spring also suit the biology of the fungal pests themselves. This has meant that plant breeders have had to put a greater emphasis on disease resistance by introducing genes (through hybridisation) from more disease resistant plants. These are often the more wild types of rose that have a natural disease resistance. It also means that some varieties (including some old favourites) are now too disease prone to be viable.”

Some parts of England are unsuited for many rose types, according to the RHS, so some growers are hybridising the flowers with climate-resistant plants including tea. David Austin Roses recommends particularly disease-resistant plants on its website, including the Dame Judi Dench, an apricot-coloured rose created for the actor in 2017, and the Scarborough Fair, a light pink, old-rose-scented bloom bred in 2003.

Aphids and ladybird
Aphids usually peak in June before ladybirds can fully help control their population. Photograph: Alamy

Guy Barter, the chief horticulturist at the RHS, said: “As well as breeding for climate change there is also the choosing of plants suitable for the site, so very hot, dry sites which are not well suited now for roses will become less so in future and we can expect more tolerant plant species to be chosen. However, this will apply first in the south and east with other regions less affected. Similarly, clay-rich moisture retentive soils favoured by roses will be less affected too. Choosing the right plant for the site will get ever more important.

“The extreme weather makes plants much more vulnerable to disease – after this summer they were stressed from the drought for example so vulnerable to mildew and other disease. The same would be said of a very wet summer – so climate change makes plants more vulnerable generally and extreme conditions would make certain diseases more commonplace.”

Ravaged roses – the pests and diseases spreading due to climate breakdown

  • Rose black spot in a wet summer can totally strip a rose of leaves and is the main constraint for breeders. Breeders select for resistant varieties but over time as the fungi evolves they become less resistant. Black spot can be treated by removing all affected leaves and plant parts, raking up and destroying them. Then, prune the rose back hard with clean tools.

  • Powdery mildew and rust also mar blooms and do well in muggy conditions. Destroying fallen infected leaves in autumn will reduce the amount of infectious spores next spring. Promptly pruning out infected shoots will reduce subsequent infection.

  • Aphids can swarm in a warm early summer. They peak in June before ladybirds can fully help control their population. The RHS recommends using finger and thumb to squash aphid colonies where practical, and encouraging predatory insects.


Helena Horton Environment reporter

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Swap your fence for a hedge, says RHS as it begins climate study
Charity to look at how hedge varieties provide benefits such as rainwater control and wildlife shelter

Helena Horton

23, Mar, 2022 @12:05 PM

Article image
Asian wasp listed as threat to UK's sweet chestnut trees
Forestry commission elevates oriental chestnut gall wasp to high-priority tree pest after 2015 outbreaks

Adam Vaughan

26, Apr, 2016 @2:22 PM

Article image
Mow problem: gardeners encouraged not to cut lawns in May
No Mow May scheme promotes letting wild plants thrive to provide nectar for insects

Helena Horton Environment reporter

29, Apr, 2022 @5:45 AM

Article image
Climate change threatens rare British orchid that tricks bees into mating
Researchers find that warmer temperatures are upsetting the seasonal relationship between the early spider orchid and pollinating bees

Patrick Barkham

05, Apr, 2018 @11:37 AM

Article image
Chelsea flower show garden inspires additions to pollinator-friendly plant list
Scientists monitored the Royal Entomological Society’s garden and listed its most bug-friendly plants

Helena Horton Environment reporter

01, Jun, 2023 @11:48 AM

Article image
Climate crisis prompts RHS to plan for sending rhododendrons north
Plants are thought more likely to thrive at Harlow Carr in Yorkshire than at their current home at Wisley in Surrey

Mark Brown North of England correspondent

04, Jan, 2023 @3:00 PM

Article image
Warmer UK weather adding to spread of fruit tree diseases
Royal Horticultural Society links spread of orchard infections to heatwave with trees still at risk

Helena Horton Environment reporter

03, Mar, 2023 @12:06 PM

Article image
RHS criticised over products that kill bugs and wildflowers
Garden charity no longer categorises slugs and snails as pests but sells items that harm them, say critics

Sarah Marsh

28, Apr, 2023 @3:00 PM

Article image
UK butterflies vanish from nearly half of the places they once flew – study
Butterfly Conservation report reveals 42% decline in distribution of 58 native species since 1976

Patrick Barkham

03, Feb, 2023 @6:00 AM

Article image
‘Planet friendly’: RHS to no longer class slugs and snails as pests
Royal Horticultural Society says the gastropods ‘play an important role’ in maintaining a healthy ecosystem

Helena Horton

04, Mar, 2022 @10:24 AM