Appetite for frogs’ legs in France and Belgium ‘driving species to extinction’

Conservationists say exploitation of amphibians leading to depletion of native species abroad

A voracious appetite for frogs’ legs among the French and Belgians is driving species in Indonesia, Turkey and Albania to the brink of extinction, according to a report.

Europe imports as many as 200 million mostly wild frogs every year, contributing to a serious depletion of native species abroad.

Scientists estimate that the Anatolian water frog could be extinct in Turkey by 2032, because of over-exploitation while other species such as the Albanian water frog are now threatened.

Export quotas for Indonesia’s Javan frog have also been withdrawn in a move that conservationists suspect may be as a result of population depletion.

Dr Sandra Altherr, the co-founder of the conservation charity Pro Wildlife, which co-authored the report said: “In Indonesia, as now also in Turkey and Albania, large frog species are dwindling in the wild, one after the other, causing a fatal domino effect for species conservation.”

“If the plundering for the European market continues, it’s highly likely that we will see more serious declines of wild frog populations and, potentially, extinctions in the next decade.”

Charlotte Nithart, the president of the French NGO Robin des Bois, which co-wrote the paper, said: “Frogs play a central role in the ecosystem as insect killers – and where frogs disappear, the use of toxic pesticides is increasing. Hence, the frogs’ legs trade has direct consequences not only for the frogs themselves, but for biodiversity and ecosystem health as a whole.”

Amphibians are the most threatened group among vertebrates, according to the International Union for the Conservation of Nature (IUCN), and the EU’s habitats directive prevents native wild frogs from being caught in member countries.

The 27-country bloc does not restrict imports, however, and every year about 4,070 tonnes of frogs netted abroad are served up on European plates.

The craving for frog meat appears highest in Belgium, which takes 70% of the imports, but Pro Wildlife says most of these are then sent on to France, which directly imports 16.7%. The Netherlands takes in 6.4%.

The IUCN will publish a conservation status report for amphibians later this year, but Jennifer Luedtke, who manages the union’s red list assessments said that at least 1,200 amphibian species – 17% of the total – are traded on the international market.

“It causes drastic population declines in the countries where these frogs originate from, as well as the unintentional spreading of lethal pathogens to amphibians,” she said.

“A shift in public consciousness needs to take place in Europe [to realise] that the burden of these declines in amphibian populations is being placed on poorer countries because of demand in wealthier ones.”

Luedtke, who also coordinates the IUCN’s amphibian specialist group, said: “We need to talk about sustainable use and if that’s even possible.”

Indonesia provides an estimated 74% of frogs imported to the EU, followed by Vietnam with 21%, Turkey 4% and Albania 0.7%, the report says.

Over-exploitation in non-EU countries has led the IUCN to give vulnerable and near-threatened classifications to species such as the giant spiny frog in China and Cambodia’s Asian grass frog.

In Africa, fewer than 250 mature Togo slippery frogs are thought to survive, and the giant African bullfrog may already be extinct in Swaziland.

Pro Wildlife and Robin de Bois say that they want EU counties to restrict imports, ensure the traceability of frogs’ legs products, provide better information to consumers and develop listing proposals for endangered species in the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species (Cites).

Altherr also called for an end to cruel practices such as the cutting of frogs legs with axes or scissors without anaesthetic.

EU insiders suggested it was unfortunate that the Pro Wildlife report had been published after a 17 June deadline for the submission of listing proposals to the next Cites conference of the parties, which will take place in Panama in November.

A European Commission official said: “The EU is ready to consider support for any listing proposals coming from [Cites] range states, for which there is scientific evidence demonstrating that there is a risk that international trade threatens the survival of the species.”


Arthur Neslen

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Funding boost to help save England's rarest species from extinction
Shrill carder bee and chequered skipper butterfly are among 20 endangered bugs, bees, butterflies and plants to benefit from £4.6m in lottery funding

Staff and agencies

31, Mar, 2017 @5:30 AM

Article image
Red list research finds 26,000 global species under extinction threat
IUCN fears planet is entering sixth wave of extinctions with research from Australia revealing more risks to reptiles

Jonathan Watts

05, Jul, 2018 @1:46 PM

Article image
One in 10 UK wildlife species faces extinction, major report shows
State of Nature reveals the destructive impact of intensive farming, urbanisation and climate change on plants, animals and habitats

Damian Carrington

14, Sep, 2016 @5:01 AM

Article image
Shark species face extinction amid overfishing and appetite for fins

Nine more shark species added to endangered list as scientists warn of extinction threat

Alok Jha in Boston

18, Feb, 2008 @4:37 PM

Article image
Raccoon, mongoose and cabbage among invasive species banned from UK
New EU regulation blacklists 37 non-native plant and animal species in a bid to tackle threats to native wildlife and economic losses

Jessica Aldred

02, Aug, 2016 @1:24 PM

Article image
Can Scotland save its wildcats from extinction?
The secretive mammals are fast disappearing from the Highlands but last-ditch efforts to save them are fraught with challenges

Libby Brooks

15, Jun, 2018 @3:52 PM

Article image
One in eight bird species threatened with extinction, global study finds
Report on the state of the world’s birds reveals a biodiversity crisis driven by intensive farming, with once-common species such as puffins and snowy owls now at risk

Patrick Barkham

22, Apr, 2018 @11:01 PM

Article image
Overfishing and climate change push seabirds to extinction
Kittiwakes and gannets are among seabirds that have joined endangered species on IUCN red list as food stocks dwindle, says study

Matthew Taylor

12, Dec, 2017 @6:01 AM

Article image
Sixth mass extinction of wildlife accelerating, scientists warn
Analysis shows 500 species are on the brink of extinction, the same as were lost over the entire last century

Damian Carrington Environment editor

01, Jun, 2020 @7:00 PM

Article image
Police to visit UK zoos and wildlife parks after rhino killing in France
Britain’s wildlife crime head says urgent security checks are needed to protect 111 rhinos in UK after attack near Paris

Caroline Davies

08, Mar, 2017 @4:43 PM