How to build on the success of Cop15 agreement | Letters

Ian Rappel says we should welcome the inclusion of agroecology in the targets agreed in Montreal, and Sophie Dembinski says developing the legal and regulatory framework for the environment is key

To generate lasting hope from the Cop15 outcomes, we need to look in the right direction (What’s this unfamiliar feeling I have after the Cop15 meeting? It might just be hope, 20 December). It is good to hear that biodiversity is being framed with the same international parity as climate change. As promising as the “30 by 30” targets sound, however, that “headline ambition” cannot replace our rich environmental ethics. A target-driven ecological audit culture will not offer much hope for the world’s biodiversity. As with the “net zero” lexicon around climate, these quantitative approaches are the comfort zone of greenwashing corporations and their political allies.

To generate meaningful optimism, we need commitments towards transformative change. For biodiversity, that means a radical overhaul of the food system – halting all the ecocidal practices associated with industrial agriculture. In looking for hope on that front, thanks to the activists at Montreal, we should welcome the inclusion of agroecology in target 10 of the Cop15 agreement. Agroecology – farming with, instead of against, nature – is already practised by millions of small farmers around the world. It is the basis of the discussions taking place again at the Oxford Real Farming Conference in January. If adequately supported in the UK, it would greatly enhance and complement our biodiversity conservation efforts.
Ian Rappel
Talgarth, Powys

• The Guardian asks if Cop15 has delivered for the natural world (Cop15 in Montreal: did the summit deliver for the natural world?, 20 December). I believe it has – because of the newfound global ambition and commitment to halt and reverse biodiversity loss by 30% this decade.

But with the deal agreed, the next step must be for governments to strengthen the legal and regulatory framework for the environment. It is this that will determine Cop15’s successful implementation.

We need to look at an international law on ecocide – to be upheld by the international criminal court – that could serve to deter the most damaging practices that underpin systemic biodiversity loss, avert major disasters and realign businesses’ relationship with nature in the long term.
Sophie Dembinski
Head of public policy and UK, Ecosia

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Giving back to the land through regenerative farming | Letters
Letters: If regenerative agriculture is to move into the mainstream, we need a system of grants that rewards flexibility and experimentation, says Mandy Lieu. Meanwhile Tom Fyans makes a case for investing in hedgerows


27, Sep, 2021 @4:05 PM

Article image
Country diary: lost in wonder in the underwater jungle
Baston Fen, Lincolnshire: The verdant bioabundance of the Counter Drain overwhelms my plant identification abilities

Matt Shardlow

25, Sep, 2018 @4:30 AM

Article image
The Guardian view on the Cop15 agreement: nations must do more for nature | Editorial
Editorial: International cooperation is the only way to halt biodiversity losses. But the action promised so far isn’t enough


19, Dec, 2022 @7:05 PM

Article image
Wildlife needs a new plan for agriculture | Letters
Letters: Chris Packham’s manifesto for wildlife won’t work without a radical new plan for agriculture, says Michael Bunney


20, Sep, 2018 @4:58 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on game bird shooting: the threat is to nature | Editorial
Editorial: Steps to limit the harm caused by driven-grouse and pheasant shoots can no longer be put off – and the hunting industry must cooperate


12, Oct, 2020 @6:30 PM

Article image
How livestock grazing is benefiting the planet | Letters
Letters: Readers respond to George Monbiot’s article about the damage caused by organic, pasture-fed beef and lamb


21, Aug, 2022 @4:11 PM

Article image
Cop15 negotiators close to agreeing nature deal as talks draw to end
Final agreement could see better protection for vital ecosystems and big reforms to agriculture

Patrick Greenfield and Phoebe Weston in Montreal

18, Dec, 2022 @11:05 PM

Article image
Scotland must commit to helping beavers make a comeback | Letter
Letter: Environmental organisations say beavers breathe new life into landscapes by creating dynamic woodland and wetland habitats


21, Dec, 2018 @6:00 AM

Article image
Cop15: what are the key targets for the biodiversity agreement?
Countries are negotiating a framework that will cover issues from pesticides to plastic, from soil to human-wildlife contact

Patrick Greenfield in Montreal

10, Dec, 2022 @8:30 AM

Article image
Value farmers if you want to save bees | Letters
Letters: We need new agricultural policies to encourage biodiversity, says Jean McKendree, while Morris Bradley congratulates the Guardian for changing how it talks about the climate


20, May, 2019 @5:02 PM