Pollutionwatch: the solvable problem of home wood burners

Wood burning is causing dirty air from the UK to Australia, but a study shows incentives to switch can work

In 2010, air pollution scientists from three of Europe’s biggest cities – Paris, Berlin and London – sat down together. Our data showed a new and consistent pattern. Air pollution from wood burning had returned to our cities. Biomass energy schemes were subsidising new wood burners in schools and offices and wood was being burned in power stations, too, but the additional air pollution in our cities was coming from homes. We wrote a paper warning that biomass subsidies to reduce climate emissions may be leading to increased acceptability and popularity of home wood burning in stoves and fireplaces too.

By 2016, home wood burning was the second-largest source of particle pollution emitted in London. By 2018, it was responsible for nearly half the emissions across Europe.

Now an Australian study has calculated the health cost of home wood burning. It took place in Armidale, a city of about 25,000 people, midway between Sydney and Brisbane, known for its two cathedrals and elegant 19th-century buildings. Frosty nights are a feature of winter here and these are frequently polluted by the 40% of homes that use wood heaters. Researchers estimated that the air pollution from wood heating was responsible for up to 14 early deaths each year, an annual health cost of between A$5,000 and A$11,000 for each wood-burning home(about £3,000-6,000). A similar study in Tasmania valued the annual health harm at about A$4,200 for every wood-burning home.

The problem is solvable. Stopping burning wood works for health. An earlier programme in Launceston, Tasmania, incentivised homeowners to switch from wood heating. It reduced wintertime respiratory deaths by 28% and heart deaths by 20%.

Prof Fay Johnston at the University of Tasmania, who was involved in the Armidale and Launceston studies, said: “Wood heaters really punch above their weight when it comes to polluting the atmosphere. Any scheme that replaces wood heaters with less polluting forms of heating will pay for itself within a year and provide ongoing savings from the avoided additional disease and death associated with woodsmoke.”

On the eve of Cop26, research from Chatham House has provided more evidence that the UK’s subsidised large-scale burning of wood for energy, such as wood chips burned at Drax power station, results in more carbon dioxide in our air, not less, for decades to come. If the government and homeowners had spent the past 10 years investing in insulation and non-combustion renewables, instead of wood burning, we would have healthier air in our cities today and less carbon dioxide in our atmosphere.

Contributor

Gary Fuller

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Domestic wood burners having a deadly impact in outside areas
Deaths due to wood-burning stoves are comparable to those of ‘black summer’ bushfires, says Australian study

Gary Fuller

26, Jan, 2024 @6:00 AM

Article image
Pollutionwatch: Africa increases its reliance on fossil fuels
Continent is embarking on a huge expansion of power stations, most of which will burn coal

Gary Fuller

07, Nov, 2019 @9:30 PM

Article image
Pollutionwatch: why cleaning the air is like taking milk out of tea
Scrubbing up polluted air is hard: not polluting it in the first place is much easier

Gary Fuller

20, Dec, 2018 @9:30 PM

Article image
Pollutionwatch: what we can learn from London’s deadly smog of 1952
Seventy years on, piecemeal political policies are failing to adequately tackle toxic air

Gary Fuller

02, Dec, 2022 @6:00 AM

Article image
Pollutionwatch: Cold snap worsens air quality
Particle pollution increases as the wind slows down and chilly weather prompts the lighting of more wood fires

Gary Fuller with David Green and Timothy Baker, King's College London

15, Mar, 2018 @9:30 PM

Article image
Pollutionwatch: how skilful driving can reduce toxic fumes
Gentler acceleration and electric vehicles can reduce air pollution but walking or cycling are best

Gary Fuller

12, Sep, 2019 @8:30 PM

Article image
Pollutionwatch: air pollution evidence needs translating into action
The facts are there but scientists need to do more to convince politicians, policymakers and the public

Gary Fuller

15, Jul, 2022 @5:00 AM

Article image
Pollutionwatch: where would we be without EU environmental laws?
Netherlands study offers UK good indication how it would have fared without EU rules

Gary Fuller

30, Jan, 2020 @9:30 PM

Article image
Pollutionwatch: Canada moves to limit wood burning
Strict new standards in Canada aim to end winter smogs caused by wood burning that have plagued cities such as Montreal

Gary Fuller

11, Oct, 2018 @8:30 PM

Article image
Pollutionwatch: generating a problem across Africa
Unreliable power supply has resulted in inefficient diesel backup generators being used widely by homes and businesses

Gary Fuller

25, Oct, 2018 @8:30 PM