Floating ‘Wall-E’ scarecrow stops seabirds diving into fishing nets

Googly-eyed device to be tested in gillnet fisheries after study finds it deters long-tailed ducks

Scarecrows may be outstanding in their field, but now scientists have created an unusual floating version that could help reduce the number of vulnerable seabirds caught by fishing nets.

The device, known as a looming-eyes buoy (LEB), and developed in collaboration with engineers from Fishtek Marine, was trialled in Küdema Bay, Saaremaa island, Estonia, on long-tailed ducks. It uses bright eyespots and looming movements to act as a natural deterrent, preventing seabirds from diving into gillnets – vertical nets used in small-scale fisheries in many countries.

Publishing their findings in the journal Royal Society Open Science, the scientists – from BirdLife International and the Estonian Ornithological Society – found the device to reduce the numbers of birds by a quarter within a 50-metre radius of the buoy.

Yann Rouxel, lead author of the study, and project officer at the BirdLife International marine programme, said: “Unfortunately seabirds can drown if caught up in the nets. We thought if we can reduce the chances of seabirds from diving too close to gillnets, we could prevent deadly interactions from happening.”

After 250 hours of observation, the team found LEB devices could reduce long-tailed ducks congregating between 20-30%, compared with traditional fishing buoys. The birds also came back to the area even after the buoy had been removed, suggesting that they were not permanently deterred.

It is hoped the device, still in its prototype phase, will be tested in small-scale fisheries and help save thousands of seabirds each year.

Rouxel said: “There have been many, many attempts to try to find a solution. Nothing seemed to work across different fisheries and species, so we wanted to try something different, and explore something that will work above the water, instead of underwater.

“We know from experience that direct confrontations … could be counter productive, and we have proven through other programmes that collaborating with fishermen could bring really good results.

“If we can keep the birds away from the real vicinity of the gillnet, if they don’t dive too close, the risk of bycatch is limited.”

Bycatch – the catchment of marine organism not targeted by fishermen – remains one of the biggest threats to ocean wildlife. According to research, at least 400,000 birds die in gillnets each year globally.

Dr Alex Bond, the senior curator of birds at the Natural History Museum in London, said it was “really promising” to see these devices used as a way to reduce bycatch.

He said: “The idea that you can put up what looks like something from Wall-E or some other Pixar film to keep the birds away from where they might come into contact with the nets is great.”

In the past, black and white contrasting panels on fishing nets, and LED lights “almost in the shape of a banana”, attached to the nets were used to drive birds away. For Bond, the googly-eyed devices are an inexpensive way to reduce bycatch.

“It’s relatively cheap, it’s relatively robust, the birds come back when you remove it. The big catch now is to see how it works in small fisheries.”

Madeleine Goumas, a researcher at the University of Exeter’s Centre for Ecology and Conservation, said: “Fishing is a hugely problematic industry for marine animals, and many different species, from dolphins to birds, get caught in fishing equipment as bycatch in the UK each year.

“A wide range of animals show a fear of direct eye contact and even just of model eyes or eye-like spots. It’s interesting to see researchers using this as a way to deter birds and that there might be some promise in reducing the numbers of individuals caught.

“One potential issue might be that the birds habituate to the device over time, especially as – unlike real eyes – they presumably don’t follow movement, so it may be that other strategies need to be considered in tandem.”


Rhi Storer

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Fishing boats 'killing up to 320,000 seabirds a year'
Report says some albatross, petrel and shearwater species nearing extinction as fleets failing to implement simple measures

James Meikle

26, Sep, 2011 @3:11 PM

Article image
Simple change to fishing gear saves thousands of birds in Namibia
Birds that became tangled in baited lines appear to be scared off by coloured pipes

Chris Baraniuk

19, Jan, 2021 @9:55 AM

Article image
Overfishing and climate change push seabirds to extinction
Kittiwakes and gannets are among seabirds that have joined endangered species on IUCN red list as food stocks dwindle, says study

Matthew Taylor

12, Dec, 2017 @6:01 AM

Article image
Vast majority of Europe's key habitats in poor or bad condition – report
State of Nature in the EU survey finds only a quarter of species have good conservation status

Fiona Harvey Environment correspondent

19, Oct, 2020 @10:00 AM

Article image
EU fishing quotas pose risk to some stocks, say campaigners
Ministers setting limits for 2019 accused of ignoring scientific advice on overfishing

Fiona Harvey Environment correspondent

19, Dec, 2018 @11:14 AM

Article image
After 60 million years of extreme living, seabirds are crashing
Jeremy Hance: A new study finds that the world’s seabird populations have plummeted by almost 70% in just 60 years.

Jeremy Hance

22, Sep, 2015 @7:56 AM

Article image
Major fishing deal offers protection to Arctic waters
Leading seafood suppliers, including McDonald’s, Tesco and Birds Eye, say suppliers won’t expand cod fisheries into pristine Arctic region

Jessica Aldred

25, May, 2016 @10:27 AM

Article image
Industrial fishing ushers the albatross closer to extinction, say researchers
Satellite data suggests protection measures are being ignored as huge fishing lines snare endangered seabirds

Karen McVeigh

31, Jan, 2019 @11:21 AM

Article image
EU proposes total commercial fishing ban on Atlantic sea bass
Move would also cut Scottish whiting catches to zero, while Celtic cod and Irish sole face hefty reductions to prevent stocks collapsing

Arthur Neslen in Brussels

27, Oct, 2016 @3:41 PM

Article image
Hidden problem of 'ghost gear': the abandoned fishing nets clogging up oceans
A new global initiative founded by World Animal Protection hopes to tackle the problem that’s killing animals and costing business

Hannah Gould

10, Sep, 2015 @4:57 PM