Draft EU policy to cut shipping emissions condemned as ‘disaster’

Exclusive: leak reveals law promotes liquified natural gas and will lock in fossil fuel use for decades, says NGO

A leaked draft of a key EU policy designed to cut carbon emissions in shipping, one of the world’s biggest polluters, has been described as an environmental disaster for “promoting” liquified natural gas, a fossil fuel, as an alternative to heavy oil.

The decision, says an NGO that has analysed the plans, will ‘lock in the use of fossil fuels for decades to come and make the EU’s target of net emissions neutrality by 2050 unreachable.

The green fuel law for EU shipping – FuelEU Maritime – is due to be published on 14 July. But a draft of the policy seen by the Guardian reveals the European Commission has considered but rejected requiring specific green fuels to be used by shipowners.

Brussels has instead opted for a goal-based approach that would set increasingly stringent “greenhouse gas intensity targets” to be met for the energy used on board.

The commission’s leaked paper says this approach, rather than a “prescriptive” fuel regulation, “answers the needs for flexibility, which have been stressed by stakeholders during the consultation activities” (in particular operators and ports). The commission cites the fast pace of technological developments as a factor in its decision.

Of the 136 responses to a consultation, 121 were either shipowners or ship managers, energy producers and fuel suppliers, short sea shipping companies, shipbuilding and marine equipment manufacturers or logistics suppliers, shippers and cargo owners.

The result, environmental groups claim, is that liquified natural gas (LNG) would be eligible to power EU ships calling at the union’s ports until around 2040, and that fossil fuel would probably still be the cheapest compliance option for two decades.

The sustainable transport NGO, Transport and Environment (T&E), has studied the plans closely and argues the decision will lock in the use of fossil fuels, in the form of LGN, for decades and make the EU’s target of net emissions neutrality by 2050 unreachable.

The “flexible” policy, it is claimed by T&E, will encourage price-sensitive shipowners to opt for LNG ships as the cheaper solution over zero-emissions fuels such as green hydrogen or ammonia. Shipowners will then be locked in to using them for another 30 years, the average lifetime of a ship.

More than half (55%) of the energy used by ships calling at EU ports could be LGN and “unsustainable” biodiesel, derived from biomass such as plant or algae material or animal waste, by 2035, it is claimed.

T&E, which first obtained the leaked policy draft, claims most LNG-powered ships emit more greenhouse gas than heavy fuel oil ships.

Faig Abbasov, the NGO’s shipping programme director, said the commission still had time to change the policy to explicitly exclude fossil LNG and first-generation biofuels from the scope of the regulation.

He said: “This supposedly green fuels law would push the cheapest alternatives, which are also the most destructive.

“Counting fossil gas and biofuels as green will lock shipping into decades of further pollution while we should be promoting carbon-free, renewable hydrogen and ammonia. There’s still time to kick out fossil fuels and stop the European Green Deal turning shipping’s transition into an ecological disaster.”

The EU has set a target of cutting greenhouse gas emissions by at least 55% by 2030 and becoming climate neutral by 2050, requiring a 90% reduction in transport emissions by 2050.

The commission’s aim is for renewable and low-carbon fuels representing between 6% and 9% of the international maritime transport fuel mix in 2030 and 86% and 88% by 2050.

A European Commission spokesperson declined to comment on the leaked policy document, but said: “Air and maritime transport have significant decarbonisation challenges in the next decades, due to the current lack of market ready zero-emission technologies, long development and life cycles of aircraft and vessels, the significant investments required in refuelling equipment and infrastructure, and international competition in these sectors.

“EU international emissions from navigation and aviation have grown by more than 50% since 1990. Action in these sectors is urgently needed, including as they recover from the current crisis, and we will make proposals as part of our ‘Fit for 55 Package’ to address these challenges.

“The ReFuelEU Aviation and FuelEU Maritime initiatives are intended to boost the production and uptake of sustainable aviation and maritime fuels.”

The industry is also understood to have concerns over the sustainability of biofuels mandated for use but has been broadly supportive of the draft regulation’s flexibility.

Claes Berglund, the president of the European Community Shipowners’ Associations, said: “The European shipping sector is committed to decarbonise the shipping industry as quickly as possible. However, shipowners cannot be held accountable for the quality of fuels. This is the sole responsibility of fuel suppliers.”


Daniel Boffey

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
UN chief urges airlines and shipping firms to do more to cut emissions
António Guterres says current efforts are more consistent with global heating ‘way above 3C’

Fiona Harvey Environment correspondent

14, Oct, 2021 @3:38 PM

Article image
UN shipping summit criticised for ‘dangerous’ delay on emissions plan
International Maritime Organization lacks urgency needed to tackle climate crisis, say campaigners

Karen McVeigh

24, Nov, 2021 @12:52 PM

Article image
Shipping firms vow to cut emissions if governments support low-carbon tech
Industry calls for levy to fund new technologies – but environmentalists say proposal blocks climate progress

Fiona Harvey Environment correspondent

05, Oct, 2021 @11:00 AM

Article image
Here’s why it’s so hard to electrify shipping and aviation
Reducing emissions for cargo ships and planes isn’t as simple as sticking a huge battery in them

Rashida Kamal and Alvin Chang

11, Nov, 2021 @1:00 PM

Article image
Pressure grows on shipping industry to accept carbon levy
World Bank among those urging levy to fund climate action in developing world and encourage fleets to upgrade

Fiona Harvey environment editor

22, Mar, 2023 @1:21 PM

Article image
Shipping’s dirty secret: how ‘scrubbers’ clean the air – while contaminating the sea
Told to reduce air pollution, the shipping industry could have switched to cleaner fuels – instead, many vessels turned to special devices that simply dump the toxins into the water

Richa Syal

12, Jul, 2022 @9:45 AM

Article image
The shipping industry faces a climate crisis reckoning – will it decarbonize?
World’s largest shipping company Maersk plans to power new container ships on carbon-neutral methanol but very little of it is produced today

Maddie Stone

12, Nov, 2021 @1:00 PM

Article image
‘Black carbon’ threat to Arctic as sea routes open up with global heating
As climate crisis allows new maritime routes to be used, sooty shipping emissions accelerates ice melt and risk to ecosystems

Karen McVeigh

10, Apr, 2022 @2:00 PM

Article image
Monsters or a must? Venice tussles with return of cruise ships
The arrival of the MSC Orchestra has rekindled tensions over the pros and cons of the giant vessels

Angela Giuffrida in Venice

14, Jun, 2021 @4:00 AM

Article image
Venice’s ban on cruise ships is a vital step towards saving the city from disaster | Neal E Robbins
The Italian government has finally taken action to help avert an environmental catastrophe in this fragile lagoon, says author Neal E Robbins

Neal E Robbins

08, Apr, 2021 @3:15 PM