Low traffic neighbourhoods popular with London voters, analysis finds

Parties that back schemes to improve air quality and boost active travel outperformed critics in mayoral election

Schemes to promote cycling and walking condemned by some critics as controversial and unpopular actually appear to be welcomed by many voters, according to analysis of last month’s election results in London.

Examination of the London mayoral election on 6 May on a ward-level basis showed that votes for parties that support such projects tended to rise in areas where they had been introduced, while parties that opposed them were more likely to shed votes.

The analysis was carried out by Julian Bell, who was the Labour leader of Ealing council in west London for 11 years until being replaced after last month’s local elections. Under Bell’s leadership, Ealing trialled several so-called low-traffic neighbourhoods (LTNs), one of which has since been removed.

The LTN scheme promotes walking and cycling by using planters or bollards to make some residential streets access-only for motor traffic, while allowing pedestrians and cyclists to use them as normal. While there is evidence the schemes can, over time, reduce the overall number of shorter car trips, some opponents claim they increase congestion by pushing through motor traffic on to a smaller number of streets.

Bell’s analysis showed that in five Ealing wards where LTNs had been created, campaigns against them by the Conservatives and local Liberal Democrats – including a specifically anti-LTN visit by the unsuccessful Tory mayoral hopeful Shaun Bailey – appeared to achieve little.

While the overall Conservative mayoral vote across Ealing rose by 0.64 percentage points compared with the 2016 mayoral election, it fell across the five LTN-focused wards, as did support for the Lib Dems.

Labour was strongly in favour of the schemes, both through the re-elected mayor, Sadiq Khan, and the local council. While the party’s vote dropped in the five wards, it fell less than the borough-wide average, and it took the most first-preference votes in all of them.

Across the wards, more than 50% of voters opted for Labour or the Greens, both which back LTNs. This effect was magnified when second-preference votes were included – the London mayoralty election uses a supplementary vote system, giving people a first and second choice.

According to Bell’s analysis, a similar pattern was seen in other areas where Conservatives campaigned against cycling and walking schemes.

Across the west London borough of Hounslow as a whole, the Tory vote rose by 1.2 percentage points against 2016, while Labour’s fell by more than 4 points. But in three wards in Chiswick, along the route of the new CS9 segregated track on Chiswick High Road, bitterly opposed by the local Tories and by Bailey personally, the Conservative vote dropped by between 10 and 12 percentage points, while Labour’s vote in the wards rose by 4.4 points.

It was a similar picture in Kensington, where the Conservative-run council removed a separated cycle lane on Kensington High Street just seven weeks after it was installed.

Borough wide, the Conservative vote was down 11 points on 2016, with Labour up 2.2 points. But in the four wards covering Kensington High Street, Tory support dropped by an average of nearly 17 points, while Labour’s was up 6.7 points.

Writing for the Guardian about the research, Bell said: “What does seem quite clear is that in a bad year for Labour, cycle schemes saved or won votes for us, not lost them. And that if there was any ‘controversy’, it worked largely in our favour.”


Peter Walker

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The evidence is in: low-traffic neighbourhoods are popular
The London election proves that measures to make streets safer are a vote-winner, says a former Labour leader of Ealing council

Julian Bell

02, Jun, 2021 @7:00 AM

Article image
Road closed or open? The signs revamping low-traffic neighbourhoods
Fearing red signs sent the wrong message, one resident created an alternative – and councils are taking note

Claire Hamlett

03, Sep, 2020 @7:00 AM

Article image
Despite a loud opposing minority, low-traffic neighbourhoods are increasingly popular
YouGov poll found positive views on LTNs are three times higher than negative ones

Peter Walker

22, Oct, 2020 @6:30 AM

Article image
London mayor race: transport watchdog urges road traffic reduction policy
The capital’s official transport users’ representative has produced ten policy ideas for the next mayor

Dave Hill

18, Feb, 2016 @11:07 AM

Article image
London’s cycle network overhaul has come to a standstill
Sadiq Khan’s claims to have built 140km of infrastructure in the capital are simply false

Andrew Gilligan

25, Feb, 2019 @7:00 AM

Article image
'Our playground': London cyclists find utopia in Regent's Park
Every morning groups of cyclists gather to ride the park’s Outer Circle. As cycling gains momentum in the city, more circuits might flourish

Simon O'Hagan

12, Dec, 2017 @7:30 AM

Article image
London cycling: pedestrians, congestion and learning from mistakes
Sadiq Khan’s approach to improving the streets for cyclists and others will be mindful of the weaknesses of his predecessor’s

Dave Hill

12, Oct, 2016 @9:19 PM

Article image
London mayor race: pros and cons of Lib Dem Caroline Pidgeon's HGV curb
The attractions of restricting large, dangerous vehicles in rush hours are clear, but road space management in the capital is rarely simple

Dave Hill

23, Feb, 2016 @8:03 PM

Article image
Boris Johnson planning traffic light mirrors to save cyclists from lorries
Mayor of London wants to improve bike safety as he seeks to quadruple number of cycle trips

Hélène Mulholland

16, Jun, 2009 @11:58 AM

Article image
Five cycling tests for Sadiq Khan | Andrew Gilligan
Andrew Gilligan: Will the new mayor uphold his election pledges and prove he is serious about improving cycling in the capital?

Andrew Gilligan

17, Nov, 2016 @7:00 AM