Poverty, not climate breakdown, caused Madagascar’s food crisis, finds study

But scientists say ‘moral imperative’ remains to prepare vulnerable populations for increasingly extreme weather

Poverty and a heavy reliance on annual rains are the key factors behind the devastating food crisis in southern Madagascar not climate breakdown, a new study finds.

A million people in the region are struggling for food following the worst drought in 30 years. But the scientific analysis did not show a convincing link to global heating, despite the World Food Programme describing it as the “world’s first climate-induced famine”.

The researchers said their work nonetheless highlighted the “moral imperative” to reduce poverty and improve infrastructure in places that would suffer increasingly extreme weather as global heating mounted.

Previous analyses have shown clearly that the climate emergency has made severe heatwaves much more likely. Global heating is also increasing the risk of more complex events, such as droughts and floods, but it is harder to separate the influence of heating of these from natural variability, which is high in Madagascar.

In two consecutive rainy seasons in southern Madagascar rainfall has been 40% below average, causing severe drought, crop failures and a humanitarian crisis, with tens of thousands of people facing famine. More than 90% of people in the region live in poverty and farmers rely on each season’s rain rather than on stored water and irrigation.

Infestations of migratory locusts and fall armyworms have made the crisis even worse, while Covid-19 restrictions have stopped people seeking work elsewhere in the country, as they have during previous difficulties.

Maarten van Aalst, director of the Red Cross Red Crescent Climate Centre and part of the 20-strong scientific team behind the study, said: “This event in Madagascar shows that in many cases we are not even prepared for today’s climate.”

Piotr Wolski, at the University of Cape Town, South Africa, said: “Even though we do not clearly see the role of anthropogenic climate change in this particular event, similar events will happen in the future, and will more likely be exacerbated rather than alleviated by climate change.

“Adapting and reducing vulnerabilities to such events is a moral imperative that should not be frustrated by inherent uncertainties of climate change projections or statistical analyses.”

The researchers assessed the influence of global heating on the Madagascan drought using weather records, climate projections and computer models. This enabled them to compare the likelihood of the event in today’s world, already 1.2C hotter, with the likelihood in a world in which no human-caused global heating has happened at all.

They found rainfall in the region is highly variable and that the drought had a one in 135 chance of occurring in a given year in today’s climate. Global heating might have slightly increased the likelihood of the drought but the effect was not statistically significant.

Friederike Otto, at Imperial College London, UK, said: “While our analysis cannot exclude that human-caused global warming may have made a small contribution to the lack of rain, we cannot separate this signal from the generally high natural variability of the region.”

Previous research indicates that perceptible changes in drought due to global heating will only emerge in this region if the global temperature exceeds 2C above pre-industrial levels.

Similar analyses have shown that the heatwave that scorched western North America this year would have been “virtually impossible” without the climate crisis and that the deadly flooding across Germany and Belgium in July was made up to nine times more likely by such changes.


Damian Carrington Environment editor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Global water crisis will intensify with climate breakdown, says report
Flooding, droughts and wildfires will worsen as global heating disrupts the planet’s water cycle

Fiona Harvey Environment correspondent

17, Aug, 2021 @6:00 AM

Article image
Climate change will devastate Africa, top UK scientist warns
Professor Sir Gordon Conway warns continent will face intense droughts, famine, disease and floods

John Vidal, environment editor

28, Oct, 2009 @5:41 PM

Article image
How bringing back the wild yam is feeding the hungry in drought-hit Madagascar
This year’s Guardian and Observer campaign supports four charities fighting global climate injustice. Here, we look at the work of East African farmers and Kew scientists

Patrick Greenfield

19, Dec, 2021 @8:00 AM

Article image
UN warns of looming worldwide food crisis in 2013

Combination of record low grain stocks, extreme weather, and rising food prices threaten disaster and unrest

John Vidal

13, Oct, 2012 @6:35 PM

Article image
We have 12 years to limit climate change catastrophe, warns UN
Urgent changes needed to cut risk of extreme heat, drought, floods and poverty, says IPCC

Jonathan Watts Global environment editor

08, Oct, 2018 @6:23 AM

Article image
Madagascar is drying out – there’s no harvest, only hunger | Anonymous
A doctor in the south of the country says people are eating cactus leaves and ashes as the rains become more erratic


11, Nov, 2021 @8:00 AM

Article image
Third of global food production at risk from climate crisis
Food-growing areas will see drastic changes to rainfall and temperatures if global heating continues at current rate

Fiona Harvey Environment correspondent

14, May, 2021 @4:28 PM

Article image
COP22 host Morocco launches action plan to fight devastating climate change
As UN climate talks start in Marrakech, Morocco calls on world leaders to put the focus on concrete plans for helping Africa’s small-scale farmers

Celeste Hicks in Midelt

07, Nov, 2016 @12:26 PM

Article image
Study reveals greater climate impacts of 2C temperature rise
Analysis of difference between 1.5C and 2C of warming finds extra 0.5C would mean longer heatwaves, greater droughts and threats to crops and coral reefs

Damian Carrington

21, Apr, 2016 @12:00 PM

Article image
Climate change 'cause of most under-reported humanitarian crises'
Report says few headlines sparked by food crises that ravaged Madagascar, Ethiopia and Haiti

Arthur Neslen

21, Feb, 2019 @10:00 AM